What does Cold-Start Price Testing conclude, in numbers, about “Priors Without History: Six Sources and One Synthesis”?
Answer: At zero history an owner holds six kinds of information. Cost gives the hard boundary: Qitong Studio's fictional unit cost of 32.50 yuan and fees of one tenth give a zero-contribution floor of 36.11 yuan and a 40%-margin floor of 65.00 yuan. The competitor band's geometric mean of 117.5 yuan, the adjacent-category anchor of 126.7 yuan, the Gabor–Granger ladder's best rung of 119 yuan, the experts' calibrated merge of 142.0 yuan and the previous chapter's NMS figure of 140.0 yuan combine into a log-normal prior centred on 128.6 yuan, with a conservative 80% interval of 100.6 to 164.3 yuan. The simplified conjoint gives no price level, only feature premiums: about 21.8 yuan for the gift box and about 26.7 yuan for the video guide. Each of the four price arms has a Beta prior with n0 = 60; ranked by revenue, 129 yuan leads, ranked by conversion, 99 yuan does. The fictional first week shows that a weak prior can be swayed by luck, so the posterior is first used to steer traffic, not to close arms. The next chapter hands these priors to the bandit to learn while selling on real traffic.
Scope of the numbers: Laws on price display and segment pricing are described only in general terms and are not legal or tax advice. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations, sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it; the source studied is the "Guoxu" chapter of the Guanzi on gathering and releasing goods and the "level" price.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 100.6, 117.5, 126.7, 128.6, 129, 140.0
| NMS revenue max | 140.0 yuan log sd 0.200 weight 0.366 |
| Gabor-Granger max | 119.0 yuan log sd 0.200 weight 0.366 |
| pooled experts | 142.0 yuan log sd 0.472 weight 0.066 |
| competitor band | 117.5 yuan log sd 0.419 weight 0.083 |
| adjacent anchor | 126.7 yuan log sd 0.350 weight 0.119 |
| prior on log price: centre 128.6 yuan, sd 0.121 | 80% 110.1 .. 150.1 |
| if only 2 sources were independent: sd 0.191 | 80% 100.6 .. 164.3; floor 65.00 stays |
| arm NMS trial prior mean Beta a Beta b revenue/visitor | |
| 99 | 0.196 0.0307 1.84 58.16 3.04 |
| 129 | 0.192 0.0300 1.80 58.20 3.87 |
| 149 | 0.164 0.0257 1.54 58.46 3.84 |
| 179 | 0.118 0.0185 1.11 58.89 3.31 |
| prior P(arm is revenue-best) | 99 0.186 129 0.292 149 0.294 179 0.228 |
| arm visitors sales posterior mean prior weight | |
| 99 | 300 10 0.0329 0.167 |
| 129 | 300 9 0.0300 0.167 |
| 149 | 300 3 0.0126 0.167 |
| 179 | 300 4 0.0142 0.167 |
| invented true revenue/visitor | 99 3.366 129 3.870 149 3.874 179 2.864 |
| posterior P(arm is revenue-best) | 99 0.280 129 0.561 149 0.036 179 0.124 |
| belief mean 0.03 sd 0.01 -> n0 | 290 visitors |
| belief mean 0.03 sd 0.02 -> n0 | 72 visitors |
Show the full program
# Chapter 3. p35: Merging the zero-history sources into a normal prior on log price and Beta priors per arm.
# (a) Each source's estimate of the revenue-best launch price, with an analyst-assigned log sd (ASSUMED):
# NMS revenue maximum 140 (p23), sd 0.20; Gabor-Granger ladder maximum 119 (p32), sd 0.20;
# pooled experts 142.0 (p34), sd 0.472; competitor geometric mean 117.5 (p31), sd 0.419;
# adjacent-category anchor 126.7 (p31), sd 0.35. Precision-weighted on the log scale; because the
# sources share errors, the sd is also shown inflated as if only 2 of the 5 sources were independent.
# The cost floor at a 40% target margin, 65.00 (p30), is a hard lower bound, not a source.
# (b) Beta priors for four price arms. Shape from the NMS trial curve of p23 (same fictional survey,
# base weights), scaled so the 129-yuan arm has prior mean 0.030 (an ASSUMED page conversion, to be
# replaced by the shop's own funnel data); prior strength n0 = 60 visitors. Week-one data are invented:
# 300 visitors per arm, sales drawn from invented true rates (seed 3503).
# Moment matching: a belief "mean m, sd s" is a Beta with n0 = m (1 - m) / s^2 - 1.
import math
import random
SEED, N, CENTER, SIGMA = 13302, 300, 150.0, 0.28
def r5(x):
return max(5, 5 * round(x / 5))
def survey(n=N, seed=SEED):
rng = random.Random(seed)
rows = []
for _ in range(n):
m = math.exp(rng.gauss(math.log(CENTER), SIGMA))
tc, ch = r5(m * rng.uniform(0.40, 0.60)), r5(m * rng.uniform(0.70, 0.88))
ex, te = r5(m * rng.uniform(1.12, 1.35)), r5(m * rng.uniform(1.45, 1.95))
if rng.random() < 0.07:
ch, ex = ex, ch
rows.append((tc, ch, ex, te))
return [r for r in rows if r[0] < r[1] < r[2] < r[3]]
def intents(rows, seed=2301):
rng = random.Random(seed)
out = []
for _ in rows:
u = rng.random()
a = 5 if u < 0.22 else 4 if u < 0.52 else 3 if u < 0.78 else 2 if u < 0.93 else 1
v = rng.random()
drop = 0 if v < 0.25 else 1 if v < 0.70 else 2 if v < 0.95 else 3
out.append((a, max(1, a - drop)))
return out
def prob(row, w_c, w_e, p):
tc, ch, ex, te = row
if p < tc or p >= te:
return 0.0
if p <= ch:
return w_c
if p <= ex:
return w_c + (w_e - w_c) * (p - ch) / (ex - ch)
return w_e * (te - p) / (te - ex)
def curve(rows, ans, weights, grid):
t = []
for p in grid:
t.append(math.fsum(prob(r, weights[a], weights[b], p) for r, (a, b) in zip(rows, ans)) / len(rows))
return t
BASE = {5: 0.70, 4: 0.30, 3: 0.10, 2: 0.0, 1: 0.0}
SOURCES = [("NMS revenue max", 140.0, 0.20), ("Gabor-Granger max", 119.0, 0.20),
("pooled experts", 142.0, 0.472), ("competitor band", 117.5, 0.419),
("adjacent anchor", 126.7, 0.35)]
ARMS, REF, C_REF, N0 = (99, 129, 149, 179), 129, 0.030, 60
TRUE_RATES, VISITORS = (0.034, 0.030, 0.026, 0.016), 300
def best_share(params, rng, draws=20000):
wins = [0] * len(params)
for _ in range(draws):
rev = [p * rng.betavariate(a, b) for p, (a, b) in zip(ARMS, params)]
wins[rev.index(max(rev))] += 1
return [w / draws for w in wins]
if __name__ == "__main__":
w = [1 / sd ** 2 for _, _, sd in SOURCES]
mu = math.fsum(wi * math.log(m) for wi, (_, m, _) in zip(w, SOURCES)) / math.fsum(w)
sd = math.sqrt(1 / math.fsum(w))
wide = sd * math.sqrt(len(SOURCES) / 2)
for (name, m, s), wi in zip(SOURCES, w):
print(" {:<18} {:6.1f} yuan log sd {:.3f} weight {:.3f}".format(name, m, s, wi / math.fsum(w)))
print(" prior on log price: centre {:.1f} yuan, sd {:.3f} -> 80% {:.1f} .. {:.1f}".format(
math.exp(mu), sd, math.exp(mu - 1.2816 * sd), math.exp(mu + 1.2816 * sd)))
print(" if only 2 sources were independent: sd {:.3f} -> 80% {:.1f} .. {:.1f}; floor 65.00 stays"
.format(wide, math.exp(mu - 1.2816 * wide), math.exp(mu + 1.2816 * wide)))
rows = survey()
ans = intents(rows)
t = {p: curve(rows, ans, BASE, [p])[0] for p in ARMS}
params = []
print(" arm NMS trial prior mean Beta a Beta b revenue/visitor")
for p in ARMS:
m = C_REF * t[p] / t[REF]
params.append((m * N0, (1 - m) * N0))
print(" {:3d} {:10.3f} {:11.4f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f} {:12.2f}".format(
p, t[p], m, m * N0, (1 - m) * N0, p * m))
rng = random.Random(3502)
print(" prior P(arm is revenue-best): " + " ".join(
"{} {:.3f}".format(p, x) for p, x in zip(ARMS, best_share(params, rng))))
data = random.Random(3503)
post = []
print(" arm visitors sales posterior mean prior weight")
for p, (a, b), r in zip(ARMS, params, TRUE_RATES):
s = sum(1 for _ in range(VISITORS) if data.random() < r)
post.append((a + s, b + VISITORS - s))
print(" {:3d} {:9d} {:6d} {:15.4f} {:13.3f}".format(p, VISITORS, s, (a + s) / (a + b + VISITORS),
N0 / (N0 + VISITORS)))
print(" invented true revenue/visitor: " + " ".join(
"{} {:.3f}".format(p, p * r) for p, r in zip(ARMS, TRUE_RATES)))
print(" posterior P(arm is revenue-best): " + " ".join(
"{} {:.3f}".format(p, x) for p, x in zip(ARMS, best_share(post, rng))))
for m, s in ((0.03, 0.01), (0.03, 0.02)):
print(" belief mean {:.2f} sd {:.2f} -> n0 = {:.0f} visitors".format(
m, s, m * (1 - m) / s ** 2 - 1))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Zero-History Cold-Start Price Testing, Van Westendorp Sensitivity Bounds and Bayesian Adaptive Repricing (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 3: Priors Without History: Six Sources and One Synthesis. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-133 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026133,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Zero-History Cold-Start Price Testing, Van Westendorp Sensitivity Bounds and Bayesian Adaptive Repricing},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {0.1.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Method: The Structure of Cold-Start Pricing, Evidence Grades, Four Stages and Regret
- Chapter 2 · Van Westendorp Price Sensitivity: Four Questions, Four Crossings and What They Cannot Tell You
- Chapter 4 · Prices as Arms: Discrete Price Ladders, Epsilon-Greedy, UCB1 and Revenue Sampling
- Chapter 5 · Contextual Bandits: Market, Channel, New versus Returning, and the Limits of Segment Pricing
- Chapter 6 · Bayesian Adaptive Repricing: Elasticity, Stock, Cooldowns, Reference Prices and Stop-Loss Lines
- Chapter 7 · The Launch Playbook: Four Kinds of Product, the Ethics of Price Testing and the Distillation Spec
- Chapter 8 · Practice: The Mistharbour Deck from Zero to Week Six