Down-Weighting Non-Independent Evidence across Twelve Symbolic Systems: Spurious Resonance from a Shared Birth Input and Orthogonal Latent-Variable Synthesis: chapter answers
When one moment of birth is handed to several symbolic systems at once and most of them "point the same way", people often take it as very strong evidence. This book refutes the premise behind that belief: the systems are not independent witnesses, because they all read one input. It writes twelve systems as deterministic maps of one moment of birth and uses information theory and probability to compute how many bits they read together, how much they repeat one another, how far agreement is spurious resonance, and how correlated evidence should be combined. The book analyses only the structur…
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-283 · 中文版
- Chapter 1 · One Moment of Birth: the Information of Twelve Systems and Their Mutual-Information Matrix
Chapter 1 finds that the nominal information of the twelve systems adds to 44.676 bits while their joint entropy is only 18.005 bits, the same as the input itself; in 56 of the 66 pairs of the mutual-information matrix… - Chapter 2 · The Illusion of "Pointing the Same Way": Spurious Resonance and the Double-Blind Test
Chapter 2 shows that a shared input inflates agreement only when the reader aligns the verdicts: the chance of ten or more agreeing rises to 0.1196, 3.1 times the independent baseline of 0.0385; it also rereads Carlson'… - Chapter 3 · The Effective Number of Independent Pieces of Evidence: Design Effect, Eigenvalues and Participation Ratio
Chapter 3 estimates the effective number of independent pieces of evidence, from 7.55 by participation ratio to 11.41 by Nyholt's formula. - Chapter 4 · Bayesian Combination of Correlated Evidence: Down-Weighting the Log-Odds
Chapter 4 derives the Bayesian combination of correlated evidence: at a correlation of 0.5 the log-likelihood ratio of twelve pieces falls from 1.5000 to 0.2308; with a shared latent factor the naive posterior climbs to… - Chapter 5 · One Latent Factor, and Orthogonal Synthesis
Chapter 5 finds that a one-factor model fails and instead groups the twelve systems by shared cycles into 5 blocks for orthogonal synthesis. - Chapter 6 · The Data-Processing Inequality: No Number of Systems Can Exceed the Moment of Birth
Chapter 6 uses the data-processing inequality to show that in an illustrative model the twelve systems know exactly the 0.5769 millibits that the day of birth itself knows about an outcome, and not a fraction more; fitt… - Chapter 7 · Classical Sources East and West: Wang Chong on Day Selection and Cicero On Divination
The many day books that Wang Chong criticised all read one stem-branch table. Program p71 shows that five day books together hold only 2.765 bits against 3.141 bits added separately, and no number of day books can excee… - Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: a Down-Weighting Proposal for Synthesis, and Pre-Registered Tests
Chapter 8 gives a read-only down-weighting proposal for synthesis engines, the distilled Shared-Input Evidence Down-Weighter and a pre-registered test plan; in the demonstration a naive probability of 0.917 is down-weig…
Illustrative model calculation, not a live quote