What does Lead Triage, Viewings and Mandates conclude, in numbers, about “Bounding the Decoy Effect: an Effect that May Be Positive or Negative, Choice Overload and Compliant Progress to a Close”?
Answer: The decoy effect exists on numerical attribute tables in the laboratory, usually fails to appear in choices that people actually experience and sometimes reverses; with zero occurrences in 19 natural-stimulus studies, the upper bound on how often it appears is 0.1459. In the illustrative account of a viewing day the decoy must exceed +0.1200 to beat a genuine comparable, and it costs buyers 6.0 deals per hundred viewing days. The mean effect of choice overload is close to zero, the prediction interval for a new setting runs from -0.6670 to 0.7070, and its direction cannot be known in advance. Compliant progress to a close gives the client time to consider; under the illustrative model 58.5 hours is best, completing 5.40 more deals than pressing for an immediate signature.
Scope of the numbers: The third needs boundaries: an exclusive mandate serves the owner only up to a commission rate of 0.0287 and a best term of 45 days in the illustrative model. Parameters are illustrative and every number comes from the book's programs.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. printed values that match the answer: 0.1200, 0.1459, 19, 6.0
| 0 of 19 natural-stimulus studies | 95% upper bound on the rate 0.1459 |
| rule of three approximation 3/n | 0.1579 |
| genuine comparable: deals 36.0 per 100 days, fee units 24.30 | |
| delta deals fee units fee gap vs genuine | |
| -0.14 | 30.0 20.40 -3.90 |
| -0.05 | 30.0 21.75 -2.55 |
| +0.00 | 30.0 22.50 -1.80 |
| +0.05 | 30.0 23.25 -1.05 |
| +0.10 | 30.0 24.00 -0.30 |
| +0.20 | 30.0 25.50 +1.20 |
| delta at which the decoy merely matches the genuine slot: +0.1200 | |
| buyers' deals lost per 100 days by the decoy | 6.0 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p51: a staged weak unit against a genuine third comparable.
# Two suitable units T and O are on the day's list; the third slot goes
# either to a deliberately weak unit D (never chosen) or to a genuine
# comparable G. P(deal today) is D2 with two suitable units and D3 with
# three. A decoy can only move T's share among deals by DELTA, which
# may be zero or negative (Frederick, Lee and Baskin 2014 found no
# attraction effect in 19 studies with natural stimuli). The broker
# holds T on its own mandate (full fee share 1.0) and co-brokes O and G
# (share 0.5). D2, D3, Q_G and the shares are illustrative.
D2, D3 = 0.30, 0.36 # P(deal today) with two / three suitable units
SHARE_T = 0.50 # T's share of deals between T and O
Q_G = 0.30 # G's share of deals when G is on the list
OWN, CO = 1.0, 0.5 # broker's fee share: own mandate, co-broke
def with_decoy(delta):
s = min(max(SHARE_T + delta, 0.0), 1.0)
return D2, D2 * (s * OWN + (1 - s) * CO)
def with_genuine():
t = (1 - Q_G) * SHARE_T
o = (1 - Q_G) * (1 - SHARE_T)
return D3, D3 * (t * OWN + o * CO + Q_G * CO)
if __name__ == "__main__":
n0 = 19
print("0 of {} natural-stimulus studies: 95% upper bound on the rate"
" {:.4f}".format(n0, 1.0 - 0.05 ** (1.0 / n0)))
print("rule of three approximation 3/n = {:.4f}".format(3.0 / n0))
dg, fg = with_genuine()
print("genuine comparable: deals {:.1f} per 100 days, fee units {:.2f}"
.format(100 * dg, 100 * fg))
print(" delta deals fee units fee gap vs genuine")
for delta in (-0.14, -0.05, 0.0, 0.05, 0.10, 0.20):
dd, fd = with_decoy(delta)
print("{:+.2f} {:6.1f} {:9.2f} {:+8.2f}".format(
delta, 100 * dd, 100 * fd, 100 * (fd - fg)))
s_need = (fg / D2 - CO) / (OWN - CO)
print("delta at which the decoy merely matches the genuine slot:"
" {:+.4f}".format(s_need - SHARE_T))
print("buyers' deals lost per 100 days by the decoy: {:.1f}".format(
100 * (dg - D2)))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Three-Question Property Lead Qualification, Same-Day Multi-Viewing Closing Kinetics and Exclusive Landlord Mandates (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 5: Bounding the Decoy Effect: an Effect that May Be Positive or Negative, Choice Overload and Compliant Progress to a Close. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-355 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026355,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Three-Question Property Lead Qualification, Same-Day Multi-Viewing Closing Kinetics and Exclusive Landlord Mandates},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · The Information Value of Three Questions: Question Count, Completion and the Stopping Point
- Chapter 2 · The Arithmetic of the Debt Service Ratio: Annuity Instalments, Stress Tests and the Affordable Price
- Chapter 3 · The Cash Threshold: Stamp Duty Bands, Transaction Costs and a Combined Three-Question Score
- Chapter 4 · The Same-Day Viewing: Routes under Time Windows, the Weight of the Anchor and How Many Units to See
- Chapter 6 · Exclusive Mandates: Agent Effort, the Owner's Net Price and Bargaining for an Owner in a Hurry
- Chapter 7 · Classical Sources East and West: the Market-Certificate Office of the Rites of Zhou and Cicero on the Seller's Disclosure
- Chapter 8 · The Empirical Loop and the Pricing and Closing Tool Specification: Ledger, Rhythm, Comparator and Pre-Registered Tests