What does Paywall Breakpoints and Unlock Interfaces conclude, in numbers, about “Endowed Progress: Where the Bar Starts, What It Counts, How Fast It Moves and Whether It Tells the Truth”?
Answer: The progress bar decides how many people reach the paywall. Three classic pieces of evidence point the way: endowed progress raises completion, people move faster near the finish, and the middle is where effort sags. In Starbalance's simulated log, p31 reads both a goal gradient of 0.956 per question and a mid-course bump around question 13, which gives the display rule "report answered in the first half, report remaining in the second". The unit of the bar should be time: counting questions while putting the open questions last makes the bar overstate by 0.202. The starting point may count only steps really completed: the p30 model gives the same 0.6470 for real and padded endowment, and only the log separates them. The pace curve must stay inside the 0.05 honest band: the fast-to-slow bar does most to cut breakoff and overstates by 0.250 at the midpoint, and this book does not use it. A fake "analysing" animation shows every reader the same flaw and, under p34's settings, is all but certain to be exposed within a month; p35's four audits make every tick of progress match the log. The progress bar is the easiest interface variable to test, but tests run only between versions that pass the audit. The next chapter takes up how the time and answers readers invest in the questionnaire should be treated at the paywall.
Scope of the numbers: It is not legal advice; pricing economics is left to earlier volumes. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations, classical sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it; the "hook and clamp" of the Guiguzi chapter Feiqian is examined in Chapter 1.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.6470, 30, 34, 35
A. two loyalty cards, eight purchases still needed on each
8 needed, 0 given start shows 0 = 0.000; remaining steps 8
10 needed, 2 given start shows 1/5 = 0.200; remaining steps 8
toy model q0 0.80, slope 0.17: completion 0.337 vs 0.403, ratio 1.195
ratio of the published completion shares, 34% over 19%: 1.789
B. Starbalance questionnaire, 24 questions
solved Q0 = 0.96594 with SLOPE = 0.03
0 bar: 0/24 start 0.000 completion 0.6200 vs plain +0.0000
R real: 3/27 (sign-up, imported shop profile, consent) start 0.111 completion 0.6470 vs plain +0.0270
F padded: 3/27 ('preparing your profile') start 0.111 completion 0.6470 vs plain +0.0270
R and F are identical to the model: only the event log can tell them apart (p35)
3 endowed steps on a 27-step bar: start 0.111, completion 0.6470
6 endowed steps on a 30-step bar: start 0.200, completion 0.6694
9 endowed steps on a 33-step bar: start 0.273, completion 0.6883Show the full program
# Chapter 3. p30: Endowed progress as arithmetic: same remaining work, different displayed start.
# Part A mirrors the design of Nunes and Dreze (2006): 8-stamp card versus 10-stamp card with 2 stamps given.
# Part B is the fictional Starbalance questionnaire (24 questions, completion 0.62 as in p10).
# Model (ASSUMED, not from any study): before each remaining step the reader continues with probability
# q(p) = Q0 + SLOPE * p, p = share of the bar already filled. Q0 is solved so that the plain bar gives 0.62.
from fractions import Fraction
def completion(given, total, q0, slope):
prob = 1.0
for k in range(given, total):
prob *= q0 + slope * k / total
return prob
def solve_q0(target, total, slope):
lo, hi = 0.5, 1.0 - slope
for _ in range(80):
mid = (lo + hi) / 2
if completion(0, total, mid, slope) < target:
lo = mid
else:
hi = mid
return (lo + hi) / 2
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" A. two loyalty cards, eight purchases still needed on each")
for label, given, total in (("8 needed, 0 given", 0, 8), ("10 needed, 2 given", 2, 10)):
p0 = Fraction(given, total)
print(" {:20s} start shows {} = {:.3f}; remaining steps {}".format(
label, p0, float(p0), total - given))
q0a, sa = 0.80, 0.17
a = completion(0, 8, q0a, sa)
b = completion(2, 10, q0a, sa)
print(" toy model q0 {:.2f}, slope {:.2f}: completion {:.3f} vs {:.3f}, ratio {:.3f}".format(
q0a, sa, a, b, b / a))
print(" ratio of the published completion shares, 34% over 19%: {:.3f}".format(34 / 19))
print(" B. Starbalance questionnaire, 24 questions")
slope = 0.03
q0 = solve_q0(0.62, 24, slope)
print(" solved Q0 = {:.5f} with SLOPE = {:.2f}".format(q0, slope))
plain = completion(0, 24, q0, slope)
rows = [("0 bar: 0/24", 0, 24), ("R real: 3/27 (sign-up, imported shop profile, consent)", 3, 27),
("F padded: 3/27 ('preparing your profile')", 3, 27)]
for label, given, total in rows:
c = completion(given, total, q0, slope)
print(" {:55s} start {:.3f} completion {:.4f} vs plain {:+.4f}".format(
label, given / total, c, c - plain))
print(" R and F are identical to the model: only the event log can tell them apart (p35)")
for given in (3, 6, 9):
c = completion(given, 24 + given, q0, slope)
print(" {} endowed steps on a {}-step bar: start {:.3f}, completion {:.4f}".format(
given, 24 + given, given / (24 + given), c))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Suspense Breakpoints in Multi-Tier Diagnostic Paywalls, Sunk-Progress Ratchets and Frictionless Unlock Interface Design (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 3: Endowed Progress: Where the Bar Starts, What It Counts, How Fast It Moves and Whether It Tells the Truth. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-139 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026139,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Suspense Breakpoints in Multi-Tier Diagnostic Paywalls, Sunk-Progress Ratchets and Frictionless Unlock Interface Design},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {0.1.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Method: Four Interface Variables, Four Indicators, Evidence Grades and Honest Previews
- Chapter 2 · The Truncation Breakpoint: Which Screen, Which Pixel
- Chapter 4 · Sunk-Progress Ratchets: Saved Progress, Personalised Results and the Ethical Edge of the Ratchet
- Chapter 5 · Previewing Locked Content: Blur, Truncation, Card Titles, Sample Sections and the Truth of "Already Computed"
- Chapter 6 · One-Screen Checkout: Fields, Wallets, Trust Marks, Error Messages, Latency and the Edge of Dark Patterns
- Chapter 7 · The Paywall Playbook: Pages for Four Report Tiers, Honest Status Labels and the Distillation Spec for the Four Kits
- Chapter 8 · Practice: Starbalance's Unlock Page from Audit to Rebuild and a Pre-Registered Test