What does Puts in Low-Volatility Windows conclude, in numbers, about “Delta-Vega Dual Convexity: Taylor Decomposition, Skew Rules and Spot-Volatility Correlation”?

Answer: Program p41 splits the result of a put into six terms. In scenario A, delta, gamma, vega and vanna pull together and the full revaluation shows a gain of 70.12 points. In scenario B the Taylor approximation overstates the gain by about twelve points, so large scenarios must be fully revalued. The short-squeeze rally of scenario C loses -17.84 points as direction and volatility strike together, and scenario E, a fall with falling volatility, gains only 50.12 points. Program p42 revalues the put under Derman's three rules: for the same 200-point fall, sticky delta and the sticky implied tree differ by twenty points. Program p43 shows that with a correlation of -0.7 the vega part averages +11.43 points on falling paths, while with zero correlation it becomes -1.75 points. Dual convexity is real, but its second half depends on the market's regime and is not built into the option.

Scope of the numbers: "Shorting" here means only bearish exposure with bounded loss, buying puts and put debit spreads; all prices are in index points of a synthetic index, and no historical market data are used. The book is financial education, not personal investment advice, with no promise of returns; it gives no trade signals and recommends no contract, institution or trading strategy, and options can lose their entire premium.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: -17.84, 50.12, 70.12

put K 3,800, 45 days, iv 0.16: price 18.96
A fall, vol up      dS -200 dv +0.03  5d: full  +70.12 taylor  +69.65
  delta +31.40 gamma +21.39 vega +10.12 theta -2.73 vanna +8.57 volga +0.91
B deep fall, vol up dS -400 dv +0.08 10d: full +210.08 taylor +222.02
  delta +62.79 gamma +85.54 vega +27.00 theta -5.47 vanna +45.69 volga +6.46
C squeeze rally     dS +150 dv -0.02 10d: full  -17.84 taylor  -19.05
  delta -23.55 gamma +12.03 vega -6.75 theta -5.47 vanna +4.28 volga +0.40
D time only         dS   +0 dv +0.00 15d: full   -8.35 taylor   -8.20
  delta -0.00 gamma +0.00 vega +0.00 theta -8.20 vanna -0.00 volga +0.00
E fall, vol sold    dS -200 dv -0.01  5d: full  +50.12 taylor  +43.92
  delta +31.40 gamma +21.39 vega -3.37 theta -2.73 vanna -2.86 volga +0.10
Show the full program
# Chapter 4. p41: second-order Taylor split of a long put's P&L.
#   dP ~ delta dS + 1/2 gamma dS^2 + vega dv + theta dt
#        + vanna dS dv + 1/2 volga dv^2,
# with dv in vol points, dt in calendar days, compared with a full
# Black-Scholes revaluation. Put: 45 days, strike 3,800 on a synthetic
# index at 4,000, implied vol 0.16 at the strike, r = 0.03. Scenario
# moves are illustrative; vega and delta pull the same way only when
# the index falls while implied vol rises.
import math

S, K, R, T, IV = 4000.0, 3800.0, 0.03, 45.0 / 365.0, 0.16


def ncdf(x):
    return 0.5 * (1.0 + math.erf(x / math.sqrt(2.0)))


def npdf(x):
    return math.exp(-0.5 * x * x) / math.sqrt(2.0 * math.pi)


def put_price(s, k, t, r, sig):
    sq = sig * math.sqrt(t)
    d1 = (math.log(s / k) + (r + 0.5 * sig * sig) * t) / sq
    return k * math.exp(-r * t) * ncdf(-(d1 - sq)) - s * ncdf(-d1)


def greeks(s, k, t, r, sig):
    sq = sig * math.sqrt(t)
    d1 = (math.log(s / k) + (r + 0.5 * sig * sig) * t) / sq
    d2 = d1 - sq
    nd1 = npdf(d1)
    vega = s * nd1 * math.sqrt(t)
    theta = (-s * nd1 * sig / (2.0 * math.sqrt(t))
             + r * k * math.exp(-r * t) * ncdf(-d2)) / 365.0
    return (ncdf(d1) - 1.0, nd1 / (s * sq), vega / 100.0, theta,
            -nd1 * d2 / sig / 100.0, vega * d1 * d2 / sig / 1.0e4)


P0 = put_price(S, K, T, R, IV)
dl, gm, vg, th, va, vo = greeks(S, K, T, R, IV)
print("put K 3,800, 45 days, iv 0.16: price {:.2f}".format(P0))
SCEN = (("A fall, vol up", -200.0, 0.03, 5),
        ("B deep fall, vol up", -400.0, 0.08, 10),
        ("C squeeze rally", 150.0, -0.02, 10),
        ("D time only", 0.0, 0.0, 15),
        ("E fall, vol sold", -200.0, -0.01, 5))
for name, ds, dv, dd in SCEN:
    pts = dv * 100.0
    terms = [dl * ds, 0.5 * gm * ds * ds, vg * pts, th * dd,
             va * ds * pts, 0.5 * vo * pts * pts]
    taylor = math.fsum(terms)
    full = put_price(S + ds, K, T - dd / 365.0, R, IV + dv) - P0
    print("{:<19} dS {:+4.0f} dv {:+.2f} {:>2}d: full {:+7.2f}"
          " taylor {:+7.2f}".format(name, ds, dv, dd, full, taylor))
    print("  delta {:+.2f} gamma {:+.2f} vega {:+.2f} theta {:+.2f}"
          " vanna {:+.2f} volga {:+.2f}".format(*terms))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Shorting Low-Implied-Volatility Windows in Macro Downturns: Delta-Vega Dual Convexity, Bear-Rally Compression and Thirty-Day Hit-Rate Bounds (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 4: Delta-Vega Dual Convexity: Taylor Decomposition, Skew Rules and Spot-Volatility Correlation. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-425 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026425,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Shorting Low-Implied-Volatility Windows in Macro Downturns: Delta-Vega Dual Convexity, Bear-Rally Compression and Thirty-Day Hit-Rate Bounds},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book