What does Whitelisting, Attribution and Dual-Track Fees conclude, in numbers, about “Attribution Stacking: Double Counting On and Off the Platform, Deduplication Rules and the Sum of ROAS”?
Answer: In the synthetic week, the orders claimed by three dashboards add up to 1.112 times the orders actually placed, while the true increment is only 0.312 of the orders placed. Deduplication brings the total down to 8,556 and removes the double counting, yet it is still more than twice the true increment of 3,549, and last touch credits the off-site ads with 3.16 times their true increment. In money, the summed dashboard ROAS is 4.81, the blended ROAS 4.33 and the true incremental ROAS only 1.35, below the break-even line of 2.884. The dashboards say the week made RM 100,176; the experiment says it lost RM 79,835. The book's central proposition has been tested in this world: the sum of the dashboards is not the true return.
Scope of the numbers: Chapter 1 takes apart an illustrative order priced at RM 59.90: the goods margin is 0.6837, but after platform fees, returns and refused cash-on-delivery parcels the contribution rate is 0.3467. The book is not financial, legal or tax advice and promises no income or return.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 1.35, 100176, 2.884, 4.33, 4.81
channel spend reported iROAS rep profit true profit in-app ad 90,000 4.12 1.14 38,562 -54,511 creator link 19,847 10.00 3.58 48,962 4,773 off-site ad 40,000 3.80 0.71 12,652 -30,097 total spend 149,847; actual GMV 648,774; sum of attributed GMV 721,151 summed platform ROAS 4.81 | blended ROAS 4.33 | true incremental ROAS 1.35 all-ads increment check: 202,507 GMV from 3,559 orders profit the dashboards imply 100,176; profit the experiment implies -79,835 break-even ROAS 2.884: summed ROAS clears it by 1.93, true ROAS misses it by 1.54
Show the full program
# Chapter 4. p43: "the sum of platform-reported ROAS is the true return" - tested on the synthetic
# week of p41. Claimed and causal orders are p41's output; spends are illustrative (RM a week).
# The creator channel costs a 0.10 commission on the GMV it claims. m = 0.3467 (p21).
import math
NET, M = 56.90, 0.3467
ACTUAL, NO_ADS = 11402, 7843
CH = [("in-app ad", 6517, 1799, 90000.0), ("creator link", 3488, 1248, None),
("off-site ad", 2669, 502, 40000.0)]
rows = []
for name, claimed, causal, spend in CH:
if spend is None:
spend = 0.10 * claimed * NET
rows.append((name, claimed * NET, causal * NET, spend))
print("{:<13}{:>9}{:>10}{:>8}{:>12}{:>12}".format("channel", "spend", "reported", "iROAS",
"rep profit", "true profit"))
for name, rep, inc, s in rows:
print("{:<13}{:>9,.0f}{:>10.2f}{:>8.2f}{:>12,.0f}{:>12,.0f}".format(
name, s, rep / s, inc / s, M * rep - s, M * inc - s))
spend = math.fsum(r[3] for r in rows)
rep_gmv = math.fsum(r[1] for r in rows)
inc_gmv = math.fsum(r[2] for r in rows)
print("total spend {:,.0f}; actual GMV {:,.0f}; sum of attributed GMV {:,.0f}".format(
spend, ACTUAL * NET, rep_gmv))
print("summed platform ROAS {:.2f} | blended ROAS {:.2f} | true incremental ROAS {:.2f}".format(
rep_gmv / spend, ACTUAL * NET / spend, inc_gmv / spend))
print("all-ads increment check: {:,.0f} GMV from {:,} orders".format((ACTUAL - NO_ADS) * NET,
ACTUAL - NO_ADS))
print("profit the dashboards imply {:,.0f}; profit the experiment implies {:,.0f}".format(
M * rep_gmv - spend, M * inc_gmv - spend))
print("break-even ROAS {:.3f}: summed ROAS clears it by {:.2f}, true ROAS misses it by {:.2f}".format(
1.0 / M, rep_gmv / spend - 1.0 / M, 1.0 / M - inc_gmv / spend))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Southeast Asian Social-Commerce Whitelist Amplification, Cross-Channel Attribution and Dual-Track Commission Growth (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 4: Attribution Stacking: Double Counting On and Off the Platform, Deduplication Rules and the Sum of ROAS. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-351 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026351,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Southeast Asian Social-Commerce Whitelist Amplification, Cross-Channel Attribution and Dual-Track Commission Growth},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · The Account of One Order: Platform Fees, Returns and Cash on Delivery
- Chapter 2 · The Break-Even Point of Advertising: Contribution Rate, Sensitivity and Four Routes
- Chapter 3 · Whitelist Amplification: Paid-to-Organic Spillover, Mega-Sale Confounding and Marginal Return
- Chapter 5 · Incrementality Experiments: Holdouts, Geographic Tests and the Shapley Split
- Chapter 6 · The Dual-Track Contract: Fixed Licensing Fee, Tiered Commission and the Arithmetic of Principal and Agent
- Chapter 7 · The Classics Examined: Bai Gui, the Fair Merchant, the Commenda and Adam Smith
- Chapter 8 · The Conversion Tool: Break-Even, Attribution Dedup and Dual-Track Contract Calculator, with a Pre-Registered Test