What does Rent, Buy or Redeem conclude, in numbers, about “Two Ledgers on One Budget: NPV and Break-Even Growth for Renting-and-Investing against Mortgaged Buying”?
Answer: Extending the one-year comparison into a multi-year ledger on equal budgets, the renter-investor leads by 58.07 after 20 years under the illustrative parameters, and the lead widens with time. The break-even growth \(g^*\) is a more useful indicator than the price-to-rent ratio because it states plainly the bet that a purchase implies. The sensitivity analysis shows that the outcome is driven mainly by price growth, the fund return and the rent yield, with interest rates and transaction costs behind them. The deterministic ledger still assumes that every year's return equals its average; the next chapter lets the house and the fund move along random paths and asks how large the "large share of scenarios" really is.
Scope of the numbers: Chapter 1 uses user cost to show that in an illustrative city with a rent yield of 0.016 the rent does not even cover the landlord's interest and taxes, and that the verdict is most sensitive to the opportunity cost of funds. Chapter 8 presents the distilled Rent-or-Buy Comparison Calculator, under whose Kuala-Lumpur-like illustrative parameters the renter leads with probability of only 0.2116, together with a pre-registered test and the conditions that would overturn the book.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 20, 58.07
| Taipei-like illustrative case: yield 0.016, mortgage 0.022, | ||||
| house growth 0.02, index fund 0.06, LTV 0.8 | ||||
| years | W_buy | W_rent | rent-buy | PV(rent-buy) |
| 5 | 35.98 | 45.17 | 9.19 | 6.87 |
| 10 | 58.14 | 75.53 | 17.39 | 9.71 |
| 15 | 82.73 | 115.45 | 32.72 | 13.65 |
| 20 | 110.02 | 168.09 | 58.07 | 18.11 |
| 25 | 140.30 | 237.65 | 97.36 | 22.68 |
| 30 | 173.89 | 329.79 | 155.90 | 27.14 |
| both start with 22.0; PV discounts at the fund rate |
Show the full program
# Chapter 2. p21: Buy with a mortgage or rent and invest: one ledger.
# Model: two households with the same yearly budget. The buyer pays the
# down payment and purchase costs, then the annuity and holding costs;
# the renter invests the same lump sum and pays rent (yield x price).
# Whoever spends less in a year invests the difference in an index
# fund. At the horizon the buyer sells (selling costs deducted) and
# repays the balance. Deterministic growth rates; all illustrative.
import math
BASE = {"price": 100.0, "yield": 0.016, "rate": 0.022, "ltv": 0.8,
"term": 30, "buy_cost": 0.02, "sell_cost": 0.04, "hold": 0.006,
"g": 0.02, "equity": 0.06}
def annuity(principal, rate, years):
if rate == 0:
return principal / years
return principal * rate / (1.0 - (1.0 + rate) ** -years)
def run_path(p, gh, gs):
"""gh, gs: yearly gross factors of house price and index fund."""
price = p["price"]
loan = p["ltv"] * price
pay = annuity(loan, p["rate"], p["term"])
bal = loan
port_b = 0.0
port_r = (1.0 - p["ltv"] + p["buy_cost"]) * price
for t in range(len(gh)):
c_b = math.fsum([pay if t < p["term"] else 0.0,
p["hold"] * price])
c_r = p["yield"] * price
port_b = (port_b + max(c_r - c_b, 0.0)) * gs[t]
port_r = (port_r + max(c_b - c_r, 0.0)) * gs[t]
if t < p["term"]:
bal = bal * (1.0 + p["rate"]) - pay
price = price * gh[t]
w_b = price * (1.0 - p["sell_cost"]) - max(bal, 0.0) + port_b
return w_b, port_r
def deterministic(p, years):
return run_path(p, [1.0 + p["g"]] * years, [1.0 + p["equity"]] * years)
if __name__ == "__main__":
print("Taipei-like illustrative case: yield {:.3f}, mortgage {:.3f},"
.format(BASE["yield"], BASE["rate"]))
print("house growth {:.2f}, index fund {:.2f}, LTV {:.1f}"
.format(BASE["g"], BASE["equity"], BASE["ltv"]))
print("years W_buy W_rent rent-buy PV(rent-buy)")
for n in (5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30):
wb, wr = deterministic(BASE, n)
pv = (wr - wb) / (1.0 + BASE["equity"]) ** n
print("{:>4} {:8.2f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f}"
.format(n, wb, wr, wr - wb, pv))
down = (1.0 - BASE["ltv"] + BASE["buy_cost"]) * BASE["price"]
print("both start with {:.1f}; PV discounts at the fund rate"
.format(down))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Price-to-Rent Ratios and Holding-Cost NPV, Non-Ergodic Leveraged Home Buying and the Redemption Option in Chinese Dian Tenure (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 2: Two Ledgers on One Budget: NPV and Break-Even Growth for Renting-and-Investing against Mortgaged Buying. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-219 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026219,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Price-to-Rent Ratios and Holding-Cost NPV, Non-Ergodic Leveraged Home Buying and the Redemption Option in Chinese Dian Tenure},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Rent Does Not Pay the Landlord's Mortgage: Holding Costs, User Cost and the Price-to-Rent Ratio
- Chapter 3 · How Large Is "a Large Share of Scenarios"? A Monte Carlo of Linked House and Fund Paths
- Chapter 4 · The Non-Ergodicity of Leveraged Home Buying: Ensemble Averages, Time Averages and an Absorbing Barrier
- Chapter 5 · The Fine Print of Holding Costs: Floating Rates, Building Depreciation and the Land Share
- Chapter 6 · Dian Tenure as a Redemption Call: Binomial Pricing and the Fair Dian Price
- Chapter 7 · Sources East and West: the Song Penal Code on Dian Sales, Qing Dian Deeds and Ricardo's Theory of Rent
- Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: a Rent-or-Buy Calculator for a Taipei-like and a Kuala-Lumpur-like City, a Pre-Registered Test and Conditions for Refutation