What does Paywall Recall and Upsell Ratchets conclude, in numbers, about “The Decay of Intent: Three Recall Waves at Fifteen Minutes, Twenty-Four Hours and Seventy-Two Hours”?
Answer: Part B moves only the first wave. At one minute the first wave wins back only 0.00609, worth +0.0677 net, and the three waves together 0.7938. At five minutes it wins back 0.02284 and the total is 1.4113; at fifteen minutes 0.03732 and 1.9419; at twenty-five minutes 0.03869, worth +1.2823 net, with a total of 1.9941, the highest in the table; at one hour it falls back to 0.03301 with a total of 1.7972; at six hours it is only 0.01412 with a total of 1.1494. The curve peaks between fifteen and twenty-five minutes and falls on both sides: too early, and novelty is lacking, self-returners are many and unsubscriptions high; too late, and the intent of impulse visitors has dispersed.
Scope of the numbers: The site is treated as a paid report product, with no claim of predictive accuracy and no fear; all visitor and order data are synthetic or illustrative. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (25 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.00609, 0.01412, 0.02284, 0.03301, 0.03732, 0.03869
| value of one recovered buyer: RM 35.92 | |
| A. 15 min / 24 h / 72 h, then two extra waves at 7 and 14 days | |
| wave time recovered unsubscribed net RM per leaver | |
| 1 | 15 min 0.03732 0.01389 +1.2293 |
| 2 | 24 h 0.01517 0.00505 +0.5047 |
| 3 | 72 h 0.00668 0.00399 +0.2080 |
| 4 | 7 d 0.00220 0.00445 +0.0432 |
| 5 | 14 d 0.00084 0.00529 -0.0121 |
| first three waves recover 0.05917; shares 0.631, 0.256, 0.113 | |
| net of three waves RM 1.9419; of five RM 1.9731 | |
| B. moving only the first wave (waves 2 and 3 stay at 24 h and 72 h) | |
| first wave wave-1 recovered wave-1 net RM net of three RM | |
| 1 min | 0.00609 +0.0677 0.7938 |
| 5 min | 0.02284 +0.6921 1.4113 |
| 15 min | 0.03732 +1.2293 1.9419 |
| 25 min | 0.03869 +1.2823 1.9941 |
| 1 h | 0.03301 +1.0834 1.7972 |
| 6 h | 0.01412 +0.4352 1.1494 |
| 'as soon as possible' 1 min / 10 min / 1 h: net RM 1.1790, unsubscribed 0.06416 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 2. p23: marginal recovery and net value of each recall wave.
# Illustrative model per consented leaver (all parameters synthetic):
# self-returners, share 0.03, pay anyway (lognormal return, median
# 25 min, log-sd 1.6); a message to them earns nothing, costs risk.
# the rest split into impulse visitors (0.6) whose intent decays as a
# power law (1 + t/30 min)^-0.45 and deliberators (0.4) whose
# readiness rises over 12 h and fades over 3 days.
# a message read within minutes repeats what is still on screen:
# novelty factor 1 - exp(-t / 8 min).
# time-of-day factor 0.6 + 0.4 cos(2 pi t / 24 h); fatigue 0.75 per
# earlier message.
# unsubscribe risk 0.002 x (1 + 0.5 per earlier message) x (1 +
# 3 exp(-t / 5 min) + 6 exp(-gap / 12 h)); complaints = 0.1 x that.
# value of a recovered buyer RM 35.93 (RM 19.90 plus a 0.10 chance of
# the RM 179.10 upgrade, after 0.05 fees and refunds); a lost
# subscriber costs RM 4.00 of list value; a complaint RM 40.00.
import math
from statistics import NormalDist
ND = NormalDist()
P = dict(rho=0.03, wa=0.6, tau=30.0, beta=0.45, ka=0.09, theta=8.0, kb=0.05,
ready=720.0, fade=4320.0, fat=0.75, u0=0.002, a1=3.0, phi=5.0, a2=6.0,
psi=720.0, g=0.5, cpu=0.1, list_value=4.0, complaint=40.0)
MARGIN = 0.95 * (19.90 + 0.10 * (199.0 - 19.90))
def diurnal(t):
return 0.6 + 0.4 * math.cos(2.0 * math.pi * t / 1440.0)
def run(times, p=P):
a = b = srs = 1.0
rows = []
prev = None
for n, t in enumerate(times, 1):
gap = t if prev is None else t - prev
d = diurnal(t) * p["fat"] ** (n - 1)
qa = p["ka"] * (1 + t / p["tau"]) ** -p["beta"] * (1 - math.exp(-t / p["theta"])) * d
qb = p["kb"] * (1 - math.exp(-t / p["ready"])) * math.exp(-t / p["fade"]) * d
u = p["u0"] * (1 + (n - 1) * p["g"]) * (
1 + p["a1"] * math.exp(-t / p["phi"]) + p["a2"] * math.exp(-gap / p["psi"]))
left = 1.0 - ND.cdf(math.log(t / 25.0) / 1.6)
rest = 1.0 - p["rho"]
rec = rest * (p["wa"] * a * qa + (1 - p["wa"]) * b * qb)
reach = rest * (p["wa"] * a + (1 - p["wa"]) * b) + p["rho"] * srs * left
uns = reach * u
val = MARGIN * rec - p["list_value"] * uns - p["complaint"] * p["cpu"] * uns
rows.append((n, t, rec, uns, val))
a, b, srs = a * (1 - qa) * (1 - u), b * (1 - qb) * (1 - u), srs * (1 - u)
prev = t
return rows
def label(t):
if t < 60:
return "{:g} min".format(t)
if t <= 4320:
return "{:g} h".format(t / 60)
return "{:g} d".format(t / 1440)
if __name__ == "__main__":
print("value of one recovered buyer: RM {:.2f}".format(MARGIN))
print("A. 15 min / 24 h / 72 h, then two extra waves at 7 and 14 days")
print(" wave time recovered unsubscribed net RM per leaver")
rows = run([15, 1440, 4320, 10080, 20160])
for n, t, rec, uns, val in rows:
print(" {} {:<7} {:.5f} {:.5f} {:+.4f}".format(n, label(t), rec, uns, val))
three = rows[:3]
tot = math.fsum(r[2] for r in three)
print(" first three waves recover {:.5f}; shares {}".format(
tot, ", ".join("{:.3f}".format(r[2] / tot) for r in three)))
print(" net of three waves RM {:.4f}; of five RM {:.4f}".format(
math.fsum(r[4] for r in three), math.fsum(r[4] for r in rows)))
print("B. moving only the first wave (waves 2 and 3 stay at 24 h and 72 h)")
print(" first wave wave-1 recovered wave-1 net RM net of three RM")
for t1 in (1, 5, 15, 25, 60, 360):
r = run([t1, 1440, 4320])
print(" {:<11} {:.5f} {:+.4f} {:.4f}".format(
label(t1), r[0][2], r[0][4], math.fsum(x[4] for x in r)))
r = run([1, 10, 60])
print(" 'as soon as possible' 1 min / 10 min / 1 h: net RM {:.4f}, unsubscribed {:.5f}".format(
math.fsum(x[4] for x in r), math.fsum(x[3] for x in r)))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Paywall Abandonment Recovery Timing, Personalised Curiosity Recall and High-Ticket Upsell Ratchets (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 2: The Decay of Intent: Three Recall Waves at Fifteen Minutes, Twenty-Four Hours and Seventy-Two Hours. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-349 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026349,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Paywall Abandonment Recovery Timing, Personalised Curiosity Recall and High-Ticket Upsell Ratchets},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · The 95 Per Cent Leak: The Cash Arithmetic of an RM 5,000 Daily Target
- Chapter 3 · The Dose of the Information Gap: Curiosity Recalls Written Only from the Visitor's Own Free Result
- Chapter 4 · The Red Lines of Unsubscription and Complaint: A Stopping Rule, a Complaint Brake and the Consent Law of Three Jurisdictions
- Chapter 5 · The Upgrade Ratchet: Expected Value and Refund Risk of Crediting a First RM 19.90 Toward RM 199
- Chapter 6 · Testing Message Variants: Sequential Tests, Multi-Armed Bandits and the False Discovery Rate
- Chapter 7 · A Study of Classics East and West: The Han Feizi on the Difficulties of Persuasion and Aristotle's Rhetoric
- Chapter 8 · The Recall Scheduler and Upsell Trigger: Integration Spec, Example Runs and a Pre-Registered Refutation Plan