What does Early Profit-Taking in Options conclude, in numbers, about “The Optimal Closing Boundary Is Not a Fixed Share: the Snell Envelope on a Lattice”?
Answer: Chapter 4 solves for the optimal closing boundary on a trinomial lattice; it varies with the state and the structure and is not a fixed share, and a stand-alone 50% take-profit ranks last under both quoting assumptions.
Scope of the numbers: All prices are in index points, every path is synthetic and the parameters are illustrative; all calculations are generated by the book's programs. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (21 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 50
| sticky marking: debit 1.704, iv at entry 0.1600 | ||
| rule | P&L cost 0.05 | P&L cost 0.15 |
| hold to expiry | -0.1120 | -0.1120 |
| optimal (Snell) | -0.0414 | -0.0987 |
| take 50%, stop 21 | -0.1237 | -0.2237 |
| take 65%, stop 21 | -0.1159 | -0.2159 |
| take 50%, no stop | -0.1645 | -0.2023 |
| stop 21 only | -0.1074 | -0.2074 |
| rational marking: debit 1.773, iv at entry 0.1746 | ||
| rule | P&L cost 0.05 | P&L cost 0.15 |
| hold to expiry | -0.1805 | -0.1805 |
| optimal (Snell) | -0.0500 | -0.1487 |
| take 50%, stop 21 | -0.1427 | -0.2427 |
| take 65%, stop 21 | -0.1417 | -0.2417 |
| take 50%, no stop | -0.2204 | -0.2579 |
| stop 21 only | -0.1387 | -0.2387 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 4. p43: exact values of closing rules for the put debit spread
# (100/95) on the lattice and vol chain of p41 (index points).
# Holder's forecast (illustrative): realized vol 0.14 calm, 0.32 panic;
# calm to panic 0.005 a day with an index jump of three grid steps down,
# panic to calm 0.10 a day; zero drift overall (the index is a
# martingale). Two marking hypotheses: "sticky" (0.16 calm, 0.34 panic)
# and "rational": the square root of 1.10 times the chain's expected
# average variance over the remaining life (a variance premium of ten
# percent, jumps included). Each rule is valued by backward induction,
# so the numbers are exact expectations on the lattice, not samples.
# P&L = value minus the entry debit; closing costs 0.05 or 0.15.
import math
def ncdf(x):
return 0.5 * math.erfc(-x / math.sqrt(2.0))
def bs_put(s, k, t, vol):
if t <= 0.0:
return max(k - s, 0.0)
sd = vol * math.sqrt(t)
d1 = (math.log(s / k) + 0.5 * sd * sd) / sd
return k * ncdf(-(d1 - sd)) - s * ncdf(-d1)
N, DT = 45, 1 / 365
SIG, IV = (0.14, 0.32), (0.16, 0.34)
P_UP, P_DN, JUMP = 0.005, 0.10, -3
DX = 0.34 * math.sqrt(DT)
LO, HI = -4 * N - 4, N + 4
def probs(sig, c):
m = math.log(c) - 0.5 * sig * sig * DT
a = (sig * sig * DT + m * m) / (DX * DX)
pu, pd = 0.5 * a + 0.5 * m / DX, 0.5 * a - 0.5 * m / DX
return pu, 1.0 - pu - pd, pd
PR = (probs(SIG[0], 1.0 / (1 - P_UP + P_UP * math.exp(JUMP * DX))),
probs(SIG[1], 1.0))
def spot(x):
return 100.0 * math.exp(x * DX)
def nxt(F, x, s):
def mix(y, t):
pu, pm, pd = PR[s]
return pu * F[t][y + 1] + pm * F[t][y] + pd * F[t][y - 1]
if s == 0:
return (1 - P_UP) * mix(x, 0) + P_UP * mix(x + JUMP, 1)
return (1 - P_DN) * mix(x, 1) + P_DN * mix(x, 0)
def avg_var():
# A[s][d]: expected summed variance over d days starting in state s
jv = P_UP * (JUMP * DX) ** 2
var = (SIG[0] ** 2 * DT + jv, SIG[1] ** 2 * DT)
A = [[0.0] * (N + 1) for _ in (0, 1)]
for d in range(1, N + 1):
A[0][d] = var[0] + (1 - P_UP) * A[0][d - 1] + P_UP * A[1][d - 1]
A[1][d] = var[1] + (1 - P_DN) * A[1][d - 1] + P_DN * A[0][d - 1]
return [[0.0] + [math.sqrt(1.10 * A[s][d] / (d * DT))
for d in range(1, N + 1)] for s in (0, 1)]
RAT = avg_var()
def make_mark(kind):
def mark(S, d, s):
v = IV[s] if kind == "sticky" else RAT[s][d]
t = d / 365
return bs_put(S, 100.0, t, v) - bs_put(S, 95.0, t, v)
return mark
def value(mark, cost, tp, stop, optimal=False):
size = HI - LO + 1
debit = mark(100.0, N, 0)
mx = 5.0 - debit
W = [[min(max(100.0 - spot(i + LO), 0.0), 5.0) for i in range(size)]
for _ in (0, 1)]
for d in range(1, N + 1):
nW = [[0.0] * size for _ in (0, 1)]
for s in (0, 1):
for i in range(size):
m = mark(spot(i + LO), d, s)
if i < 4 or i > size - 2:
nW[s][i] = m - cost
continue
c = nxt(W, i, s)
if optimal:
nW[s][i] = max(m - cost, c)
elif (m - debit) / mx >= tp or d <= stop:
nW[s][i] = m - cost
else:
nW[s][i] = c
W = nW
return W[0][-LO] - debit, debit
RULES = (("hold to expiry", 9.0, 0, False),
("optimal (Snell)", 9.0, 0, True),
("take 50%, stop 21", 0.50, 21, False),
("take 65%, stop 21", 0.65, 21, False),
("take 50%, no stop", 0.50, 0, False),
("stop 21 only", 9.0, 21, False))
for kind in ("sticky", "rational"):
mk = make_mark(kind)
print("%s marking: debit %.3f, iv at entry %.4f"
% (kind, mk(100.0, N, 0),
IV[0] if kind == "sticky" else RAT[0][N]))
print(" rule P&L cost 0.05 P&L cost 0.15")
for name, tp, stop, opt in RULES:
a = value(mk, 0.05, tp, stop, opt)[0]
b = value(mk, 0.15, tp, stop, opt)[0]
print(" %-18s %+.4f %+.4f" % (name, a, b))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Optimal Early Profit-Taking in Options: Harvesting Volatility Spikes, Twenty-One-Day Decay Cliffs and the Expiration Hold Trap (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 4: The Optimal Closing Boundary Is Not a Fixed Share: the Snell Envelope on a Lattice. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-426 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026426,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Optimal Early Profit-Taking in Options: Harvesting Volatility Spikes, Twenty-One-Day Decay Cliffs and the Expiration Hold Trap},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · "Hold to Expiry to Collect It All" Is a Bookkeeping Error: Continuation Value against Closing Value
- Chapter 2 · There Is No Cliff on the Decay Curve: Where Time Value Speeds Up, and by How Much
- Chapter 3 · Panic Spikes: Jumps, Mean Reversion and the Half-Life of the Volatility Give-Back
- Chapter 5 · Sixty Rules in Four Scenarios: a Simulated Test of Profit-Taking Shares and Time Stops
- Chapter 6 · Three Traps of Holding to Expiry: Give-Back, Pin Risk and the Disposition Effect
- Chapter 7 · "To Hold and Fill It Is Not as Good as to Stop": Stopping and Leaving in Classical Sources of East and West
- Chapter 8 · Field Tools and Checker Specifications: the Closing-Decision Ledger, the Calculator and a Pre-Registered Test