What does Context-Parametric Rule Distillation and Online Calibration conclude, in numbers, about “Simpson's Reversal: Why a Rule Without Its Context Can Point the Wrong Way”?

Answer: Chapter 1 prices the single-sentence rule: on an illustrative decision table, "always B" is wrong for 0.5433 of traffic.

Scope of the numbers: Parameters are illustrative and all calculations are generated by the book's programs. This is general business analysis, not investment, legal or medical advice, and it describes no real customer or sale.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python only

A. admission rate by department (men vs women)
  dept  men n  men rate  women n  women rate  women - men
   A     825   0.621      108     0.824      +0.203
   B     560   0.630       25     0.680      +0.050
   C     325   0.369      593     0.341      -0.029
   D     417   0.331      375     0.349      +0.018
   E     191   0.277      393     0.239      -0.038
   F     373   0.059      341     0.070      +0.011
B. pooled over the six departments
  men   2,691 applied, 1,198 admitted, rate 0.445
  women 1,835 applied, 557 admitted, rate 0.304
  departments where women do better: 4 of 6
C. odds ratio of admission, women vs men
  crude (pooled) 0.543   Mantel-Haenszel 1.105
D. share applying to the four harder departments C to F
  men 0.485   women 0.928
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p11: Simpson reversal in the Berkeley 1973 admissions table.
# Data: the six largest departments as published in the R dataset
# UCBAdmissions (Bickel, Hammel and O'Connell 1975). Public counts.
# For each department: men admitted, men rejected, women admitted,
# women rejected. We compare the pooled rates with the stratified ones
# and with the Mantel-Haenszel common odds ratio.
import math

DATA = [("A", 512, 313, 89, 19), ("B", 353, 207, 17, 8),
        ("C", 120, 205, 202, 391), ("D", 138, 279, 131, 244),
        ("E", 53, 138, 94, 299), ("F", 22, 351, 24, 317)]


def rate(a, r):
    return a / (a + r)


def main():
    print("A. admission rate by department (men vs women)")
    print("  dept  men n  men rate  women n  women rate  women - men")
    favour = 0
    for d, ma, mr, wa, wr in DATA:
        diff = rate(wa, wr) - rate(ma, mr)
        favour += 1 if diff > 0 else 0
        print("   {}   {:>5,}   {:.3f}    {:>5,}     {:.3f}      {:+.3f}"
              .format(d, ma + mr, rate(ma, mr), wa + wr, rate(wa, wr),
                      diff))
    men_a = int(math.fsum(r[1] for r in DATA))
    men_n = int(math.fsum(r[1] + r[2] for r in DATA))
    wom_a = int(math.fsum(r[3] for r in DATA))
    wom_n = int(math.fsum(r[3] + r[4] for r in DATA))
    print("B. pooled over the six departments")
    print("  men   {:,} applied, {:,} admitted, rate {:.3f}".format(
        men_n, men_a, men_a / men_n))
    print("  women {:,} applied, {:,} admitted, rate {:.3f}".format(
        wom_n, wom_a, wom_a / wom_n))
    print("  departments where women do better: {} of 6".format(favour))
    # odds ratio women : men, crude and Mantel-Haenszel
    crude = (wom_a * (men_n - men_a)) / ((wom_n - wom_a) * men_a)
    num = math.fsum(wa * mr / (ma + mr + wa + wr)
                    for _, ma, mr, wa, wr in DATA)
    den = math.fsum(wr * ma / (ma + mr + wa + wr)
                    for _, ma, mr, wa, wr in DATA)
    print("C. odds ratio of admission, women vs men")
    print("  crude (pooled) {:.3f}   Mantel-Haenszel {:.3f}".format(
        crude, num / den))
    hard = ("C", "D", "E", "F")
    m_h = int(math.fsum(r[1] + r[2] for r in DATA if r[0] in hard))
    w_h = int(math.fsum(r[3] + r[4] for r in DATA if r[0] in hard))
    print("D. share applying to the four harder departments C to F")
    print("  men {:.3f}   women {:.3f}".format(m_h / men_n, w_h / wom_n))


if __name__ == "__main__":
    main()

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Next-Generation Knowledge Distillation, Context-Parametric Compilation and Live-Conversion Feedback Calibration (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 1: Simpson's Reversal: Why a Rule Without Its Context Can Point the Wrong Way. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-377 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026377,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Next-Generation Knowledge Distillation, Context-Parametric Compilation and Live-Conversion Feedback Calibration},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book