Dissolving Entrenched Priors, Shattering the Illusion of Explanatory Depth and Anti-Backfire Persuasion Mechanics: chapter answers
A popular saying holds that the more evidence you show people, the more firmly they hold their view: the backfire effect. This book refutes it first. Corrections to the blueprint: Nyhan and Reifler reported backfire, but Wood and Porter found none across 52 issues and more than ten thousand participants, Swire-Thompson and colleagues pointed to unreliable measurement, and Nyhan himself revised the conclusion; direct correction works on average, and the real obstacles are motivated discounting, which shrinks updates, and rebound after a correction. On the illusion of explanatory depth the book…
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-387 · 中文版
- Chapter 1 · Bounding the Backfire Effect: Corrections Work on Average, Reversals Are Rare
Chapter 1 shows that when nobody truly backfires, a scale with reliability 0.50 still makes 0.351 of people appear to backfire, and 0.179 at reliability 0.95; that chance alone yields 2.60 significant backfires among fi… - Chapter 2 · Motivated Discounting: Beta Priors, Pseudo-Samples and Evidence Weights
Stubbornness comes in two kinds, a strong prior and a heavy discount. On a single person's trajectory they cannot be told apart, because the mean depends only on $w/n_0$. For a person with a pseudo-sample of 80 who keep… - Chapter 3 · Rebound and Softening: the Decay of Corrections, Spacing and Half-Life
Corrections work, but they fade. With a half-life of 3 days, a single correction in four weeks reduces the average by only 0.0484; daily corrections give the largest total reduction, but each buys only 0.0185. When the… - Chapter 4 · The Illusion of Explanatory Depth: the Drop on a Seven-Point Scale and the Small Attitude Effect
Chapter 4 uses a seven-point scale and a price chain: a felt markup of 0.4980 against a true margin of 0.0700, the gap lying in links customers never considered. - Chapter 5 · Self-Affirmation and Benign Thought Experiments: Affirm First, Then Evidence, with an Exit Always Open
Chapter 5: under high threat, affirming first and then giving four items lowers confidence by 0.0730, more than 0.0439 from five items; a benign thought experiment states its exit, and the best length for mockery is zer… - Chapter 6 · Question Sequences as a Decision Process: a Simulated Optimum under Illustrative Parameters and Its Sensitivity
Chapter 6 casts the four moves as a Markov decision process: from the hardest start the expected value is 10.555, the full path survives two thousand perturbations in a share of 0.8270, and keeping the baseline policy c… - Chapter 7 · Classical Sources: the Frog in the Well and Knowing What One Knows, Bacon's Aphorism 46 and Socrates' Knowledge of His Ignorance
The respondent answers 23 of the forty questions correctly, a share of 0.575. With no pull-back, average confidence is 0.8115, which is 0.2365 above the actual hit rate, and the Brier score is 0.2908, worse than the 0.2… - Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: the Prior-Dissolving Ledger, Field Tools and Checker Specifications
Chapter 8 gives the ledger, the distilled Stubborn-Prior and Question-Sequence Calculator, four-kit checker specifications and pre-registered tests: the reliable change index is 22.31 points and the backfire-rate test n…
Illustrative model calculation, not a live quote