What does Degrees of Freedom and Motor Synergies conclude, in numbers, about “Internal Forward Models and Efference Copy: Getting Around Sensory Delay”?
Answer: Delays in sensorimotor loops differ by modality: about 10–40 ms for the monosynaptic reflex and about 110–150 ms for visual responses, so "50–200 ms" is only a rough range. A forward model predicts the consequences of an action from the efference copy, and Kalman estimation merges the prediction with late feedback according to their uncertainties: in the illustrative model with a 100 ms delay the error falls from 32.37 mm (late reading alone) to 3.18 mm; an unknown external force leaves a steady bias of about 5 mm that only adaptation of the model itself can remove. The 1995 paper of Wolpert and colleagues concerns an internal model in sensorimotor integration; the cerebellar internal model goes back to Miall and colleagues 1993 and Wolpert and colleagues 1998. Predictive attenuation explains why you cannot tickle yourself (the fMRI of Blakemore and colleagues 1998 and the psychophysics of 1999) and the escalation of force (38 % per turn, corresponding to an attenuation factor of about 0.725). The next chapter turns from joints and senses to muscles: how muscle synergies were "discovered", and whether they really come from the nervous system.
Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (14 programs, all checked), classical sources and the author's hypotheses; all data in the book are fictional or simulated.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 100, 200, 3.18, 32.37, 50
| RMS position error over the 2 s movement (mm), 300 runs; no external force | |
| delay delayed reading forward model Kalman | |
| 50 ms | 17.02 16.46 2.40 |
| 100 ms | 32.37 17.54 3.18 |
| 200 ms | 61.84 17.05 4.57 |
| unknown external force +0.3 N, delay 100 ms: mean error (bias) and SD, mm | |
| time forward model: bias SD Kalman: bias SD | |
| 0.26 s | -8.37 3.10 -5.20 3.18 |
| 0.51 s | -28.33 7.38 -4.83 3.36 |
| 1.01 s | -86.44 15.94 -5.02 3.32 |
| 1.51 s | -155.26 22.98 -5.18 3.08 |
| 2.00 s | -227.25 28.47 -5.61 3.24 |
Show the full program
# State estimation with an internal forward model and delayed feedback (illustrative).
# A 1-D hand (mass 1 kg, viscosity 2 N s/m) moves back and forth for 2 s under a known
# command (efference copy). Proprioception reports position d steps late (dt = 10 ms)
# with SD 5 mm. Motor noise: SD 0.5 N per step. In the "bias" condition an external
# force of +0.3 N acts that the forward model does not know about. Three estimators:
# the latest delayed reading alone; the forward model alone (dead reckoning); and a
# Kalman filter on the delay-augmented state [p, v, p(t-1), ..., p(t-d)].
import math, random
DT, M, VISC, SY, SU, STEPS = 0.01, 1.0, 2.0, 0.005, 0.5, 200
def command(t): # 0.15 m back-and-forth at 0.5 Hz, plus viscosity
w = 2 * math.pi * 0.5
return M * (-0.15 * w * w * math.sin(w * t)) + VISC * 0.15 * w * math.cos(w * t)
def model(d):
n = 2 + d; A = [[0.0] * n for _ in range(n)]
A[0][0] = 1; A[0][1] = DT; A[1][1] = 1 - DT * VISC / M
A[2][0] = 1
for i in range(3, n):
A[i][i - 1] = 1
return A, [0.0, DT / M] + [0.0] * d
def kalman_gains(d):
A, b = model(d); n = len(A); P = [[0.0] * n for _ in range(n)]; gains = []
q = (SU * DT / M) ** 2 * 4 # process noise, inflated for unknown forces
for _ in range(STEPS):
P = [[sum(A[i][k] * sum(P[k][l] * A[j][l] for l in range(n)) for k in range(n))
for j in range(n)] for i in range(n)]
P[1][1] += q
s = P[n - 1][n - 1] + SY ** 2; K = [P[i][n - 1] / s for i in range(n)]
P = [[P[i][j] - K[i] * P[n - 1][j] for j in range(n)] for i in range(n)]
gains.append(K)
return gains
def run(d, gains, bias, rng):
A, b = model(d); n = len(A); x = [0.0] * n; z = [0.0] * n; fm = [0.0, 0.0]
err = {"delayed reading": [], "forward model": [], "Kalman": []}
for t in range(STEPS):
u = command(t * DT)
noise = rng.gauss(0, SU)
x = [sum(a * v for a, v in zip(r, x)) + bi * (u + noise + bias)
for r, bi in zip(A, b)]
y = x[n - 1] + rng.gauss(0, SY)
z = [sum(a * v for a, v in zip(r, z)) + bi * u for r, bi in zip(A, b)]
inn = y - z[n - 1]; z = [zi + k * inn for zi, k in zip(z, gains[t])]
fm = [fm[0] + DT * fm[1], fm[1] + DT * (u - VISC * fm[1]) / M]
err["delayed reading"].append(y - x[0]); err["forward model"].append(fm[0] - x[0])
err["Kalman"].append(z[0] - x[0])
return err
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(1995)
print("RMS position error over the 2 s movement (mm), 300 runs; no external force")
print(" delay delayed reading forward model Kalman")
for d in (5, 10, 20):
g = kalman_gains(d); acc = {}
for _ in range(300):
for k, v in run(d, g, 0.0, rng).items():
acc[k] = acc.get(k, 0.0) + sum(e * e for e in v) / STEPS / 300
print(f" {10 * d:4d} ms {1000 * math.sqrt(acc['delayed reading']):6.2f}"
f" {1000 * math.sqrt(acc['forward model']):6.2f}"
f" {1000 * math.sqrt(acc['Kalman']):6.2f}")
print("unknown external force +0.3 N, delay 100 ms: mean error (bias) and SD, mm")
g = kalman_gains(10); runs = [run(10, g, 0.3, rng) for _ in range(300)]
print(" time forward model: bias SD Kalman: bias SD")
for t in (25, 50, 100, 150, 199):
out = []
for k in ("forward model", "Kalman"):
v = [r[k][t] for r in runs]; m = sum(v) / len(v)
s = math.sqrt(sum((e - m) ** 2 for e in v) / (len(v) - 1))
out.append(f"{1000 * m:+8.2f} {1000 * s:6.2f}")
print(f" {(t + 1) * DT:4.2f} s {out[0]} {out[1]}")Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Embodied Cognition, Bernstein's Degrees-of-Freedom Problem and the Control Theory of Motor Synergies (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 4: Internal Forward Models and Efference Copy: Getting Around Sensory Delay. 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23828057
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23828057 · Read the monograph · 5DL-B-043 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026043,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Embodied Cognition, Bernstein's Degrees-of-Freedom Problem and the Control Theory of Motor Synergies},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23828057},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23828057}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Bernstein's Problem: Redundancy, Abundance and "Repetition without Repetition"
- Chapter 2 · The Uncontrolled Manifold and the Minimal Intervention Principle: Control Only What Matters
- Chapter 3 · Fitts's Law and the Speed–Accuracy Trade-off: The Limits of an Information-Theoretic Analogy
- Chapter 5 · Muscle Synergies: Non-Negative Matrix Factorisation and the Biomechanical-Constraint Dispute
- Chapter 6 · Skill Learning: Freezing and Freeing Degrees of Freedom, External Focus and "Instructions as Costs"
- Chapter 8 · Practice and a Pre-Registered Trial