What does The 85% Rule and Deliberate Practice conclude, in numbers, about “The Timing and Grain of Feedback”?

Answer: The guidance hypothesis holds that external feedback on every trial improves performance in practice but may weaken the learner's processing of its own errors; Winstein and Schmidt found that reduced feedback frequency helped retention, but a later meta-analysis did not give stable support. Kluger and DeNisi found an average effect of feedback interventions of d = 0.41, with more than a third making performance worse; feedback directed at the self is especially likely to harm. The model suggests that the key may be not the frequency of feedback but whether the learner processes its own error information. Immediate correction suits safety, errors that would be repeated many times, and the beginning; delayed or reduced feedback suits the stage at which self-assessment is to be developed. The next chapter reads this modern research beside classical Chinese thought on learning.

Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate evidence, runnable Python calculations (15 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.41

Part 1: mean d0.41, one third below zero -> SD of effects about 0.95
share below -0.226%; between 0 and 0.4: 16%; above 0.8: 34%
Part 2: mean absolute error (ms), last 40 practice trials / one-day retention test
KR schedule | engage0.1 (strong guidance) | engage = 0.9 (learner self-estimates)
100 % |34.7 / 43.2 | 34.7 / 36.6
50 % |36.1 / 37.7 | 35.5 / 36.8
faded |37.3 / 37.6 | 36.2 / 36.9
Show the full program
# Part 1: Kluger & DeNisi (1996) mean d = 0.41, a third negative: implied spread if normal.
# Part 2 (author's toy model): 500 ms timing task, bias +120, motor SD 40; KR corrects 30 % of
# error; own estimate noise 120/sqrt(1 + n/8), n = trials attending to own feedback (always
# without KR, with prob. "engage" with KR). Retention: drift SD 30, own-estimate correction.
import math, random
from statistics import NormalDist, fmean

mu, frac = 0.41, 1 / 3
sd = mu / -NormalDist().inv_cdf(frac)
D = NormalDist(mu, sd)
print(f"Part 1: mean d = {mu}, one third below zero -> SD of effects about {sd:.2f}")
print(f"   share below -0.2: {D.cdf(-0.2):.0%}; between 0 and 0.4: {D.cdf(0.4) - D.cdf(0):.0%};"
      f" above 0.8: {1 - D.cdf(0.8):.0%}")

def schedule(name, n=120):
    if name == "100 %":
        return [True] * n
    if name == "50 %":
        return [i % 2 == 0 for i in range(n)]
    return [random.Random(i).random() < max(0.0, 1 - i / (0.8 * n)) for i in range(n)]

def learner(sched, engage, seed):
    rng = random.Random(seed)
    bias, n_att, acq = 120.0, 0, []
    for kr in sched:
        err = bias + rng.gauss(0, 40)
        acq.append(abs(err))
        own = err + rng.gauss(0, 120 / math.sqrt(1 + n_att / 8))
        if kr:
            bias -= 0.3 * err
            n_att += rng.random() < engage
        else:
            bias -= 0.3 * own
            n_att += 1
    bias += rng.gauss(0, 30)
    ret = []
    for _ in range(30):
        err = bias + rng.gauss(0, 40)
        ret.append(abs(err))
        bias -= 0.3 * (err + rng.gauss(0, 120 / math.sqrt(1 + n_att / 8)))
    return fmean(acq[-40:]), fmean(ret)

print("Part 2: mean absolute error (ms), last 40 practice trials / one-day retention test")
print("KR schedule | engage = 0.1 (strong guidance) | engage = 0.9 (learner self-estimates)")
for name in ("100 %", "50 %", "faded"):
    cells = []
    for engage in (0.1, 0.9):
        r = [learner(schedule(name), engage, s) for s in range(2000)]
        cells.append(f"{fmean(a for a, _ in r):5.1f} / {fmean(b for _, b in r):5.1f}")
    print(f"{name:11s} |        {cells[0]}         |          {cells[1]}")

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). The 85% Rule for Optimal Learning, Myelination Kinetics and Deliberate Practice (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 6: The Timing and Grain of Feedback. 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23761339

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23761339 · Read the monograph · 5DL-B-023 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026023,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {The 85% Rule for Optimal Learning, Myelination Kinetics and Deliberate Practice},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23761339},
  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23761339}
}

Other chapter answers in this book