What does Pricing for Lower-Tier Cities conclude, in numbers, about “The Proportional-Discount Fallacy: Why the Ratio of Mean Incomes Misprices Lower-Tier Cities”?

Answer: Chapter 1 quantifies the thesis on four illustrative tiers: the fourth tier's mean income is 0.402 of the first tier's, but its discretionary income at the 95th percentile is 0.532; its optimal price of 508 yuan is 0.592 of the first tier's, and the proportional discount to 345 yuan gives up 0.077 of profit, erring on the low side.

Scope of the numbers: Its city tiers, incomes, price levels, costs and demand parameters are illustrative, and it quotes no specific official statistic; all calculations are generated by its programs; it is not individual business advice. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (20 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.077, 0.402, 0.592, 345, 508

unit cost 90, theta 0.03, taste spread 0.45
tier  p_opt  buy%   prof  | p_mean  loss  | p_q80  loss
T1      857   42.4 325614  |    857  0.000 |    857  0.000
T2      675   39.1 228891  |    606  0.007 |    641  0.002
T3      574   34.0 164362  |    452  0.031 |    502  0.010
T4      508   27.8 116248  |    345  0.077 |    391  0.036
optimal price ratio to T1 versus the two scaling rules:
T2  optimum 0.788  mean-income 0.706  D@q80 0.748
T3  optimum 0.669  mean-income 0.528  D@q80 0.585
T4  optimum 0.592  mean-income 0.402  D@q80 0.456
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p12: proportional discount versus the profit-maximising price.
# Same four illustrative tiers as p11. Willingness to pay for one annual
# package is WTP = THETA * D(x) * tau, where D is discretionary income
# and tau is a lognormal taste factor (median 1, log-spread SIG_T).
# Unit cost C is national (a package delivered online). Buy share S(p)
# is integrated over 400 income quantiles; profit per 1,000 residents
# is 1000 * (p - C) * S(p). The T1 optimum is found first, then each
# lower tier is priced three ways: its own optimum, T1 price scaled by
# the mean-income ratio, and T1 price scaled by D at the 80th percentile.
import math
from statistics import NormalDist

N01 = NormalDist()
TIERS = ["T1", "T2", "T3", "T4"]
MED = [72000, 50000, 36000, 26000]
SIG = [0.55, 0.58, 0.64, 0.72]
P = [1.00, 0.90, 0.82, 0.76]
E = [0.38, 0.34, 0.31, 0.29]
THETA, SIG_T, C, NQ = 0.03, 0.45, 90.0, 400


def engel(x, k):
    w = 0.28 - 0.09 * math.log(x / (P[k] * 72000))
    return min(0.65, max(0.10, w))


def disc(x, k):
    return x * max(0.0, 1.0 - engel(x, k) - E[k])


def quant(q, k):
    return MED[k] * math.exp(SIG[k] * N01.inv_cdf(q))


def grid(k):
    return [disc(quant((i + 0.5) / NQ, k), k) for i in range(NQ)]


def share(p, g):
    t = [1.0 - N01.cdf(math.log(p / (THETA * d)) / SIG_T)
         for d in g if d > 0]
    return math.fsum(t) / NQ


def profit(p, g):
    return 1000.0 * (p - C) * share(p, g)


def best(g, lo=C + 1.0, hi=5000.0):
    a, b = lo, hi
    r = (math.sqrt(5.0) - 1.0) / 2.0
    for _ in range(90):
        x1, x2 = b - r * (b - a), a + r * (b - a)
        if profit(x1, g) < profit(x2, g):
            a = x1
        else:
            b = x2
    return (a + b) / 2.0


G = [grid(k) for k in range(4)]
mean_x = [MED[k] * math.exp(SIG[k] ** 2 / 2.0) for k in range(4)]
p1 = best(G[0])
print("unit cost %d, theta %.2f, taste spread %.2f" % (C, THETA, SIG_T))
print("tier  p_opt  buy%   prof  | p_mean  loss  | p_q80  loss")
for k, t in enumerate(TIERS):
    g = G[k]
    po = best(g)
    pm = p1 * mean_x[k] / mean_x[0]
    pq = p1 * disc(quant(0.8, k), k) / disc(quant(0.8, 0), 0)
    pr = profit(po, g)
    print("%-4s %6.0f  %5.1f %6.0f  | %6.0f  %.3f | %6.0f  %.3f"
          % (t, po, 100 * share(po, g), pr, pm, 1 - profit(pm, g) / pr,
             pq, 1 - profit(pq, g) / pr))
print("optimal price ratio to T1 versus the two scaling rules:")
for k, t in enumerate(TIERS[1:], 1):
    po = best(G[k])
    rq = disc(quant(0.8, k), k) / disc(quant(0.8, 0), 0)
    print("%s  optimum %.3f  mean-income %.3f  D@q80 %.3f"
          % (t, po / p1, mean_x[k] / mean_x[0], rq))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Purchasing-Power Parity across Provinces and Pricing for Lower-Tier Cities: Income Distributions, Engel-Coefficient Calibration and Multi-Tier Package Anchors (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 1: The Proportional-Discount Fallacy: Why the Ratio of Mean Incomes Misprices Lower-Tier Cities. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-275 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026275,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Purchasing-Power Parity across Provinces and Pricing for Lower-Tier Cities: Income Distributions, Engel-Coefficient Calibration and Multi-Tier Package Anchors},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book