What does The Commuting Paradox and Relocation conclude, in numbers, about “The Commuting Paradox: Where the Thirty-Five Per Cent Comes From”?
Answer: Chapter 1 returns to the paper by Stutzer and Frey: its 35.4 % compensation belongs to the mean one-way commute of 22 minutes, not to an hour; extending its coefficients, an hour corresponds to 0.6896 of labour income or 0.3266 of household income, with a 90 % band running from 0.406 to 0.973 and beyond.
Scope of the numbers: Its teams, sites, rents, pay and probabilities are illustrative; all calculations are generated by its programs; it is not individualised business, legal or financial advice. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (19 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.3266, 0.6896, 22, 35.4, 90
| Stutzer-Frey compensation re-run from the printed coefficients | |
| MU of labour income at the means | 0.21817e-3 per euro |
| D min dU 0-10 euros/month share w share y | |
| 10 | -0.0508 232.6 0.1754 0.0831 |
| 22 | -0.1024 469.4 0.3540 0.1676 |
| 30 | -0.1313 601.6 0.4537 0.2149 |
| 45 | -0.1733 794.1 0.5989 0.2836 |
| 60 | -0.1995 914.4 0.6896 0.3266 |
| 77.5 | -0.2102 963.6 0.7267 0.3441 |
| 90 | -0.2048 938.5 0.7078 0.3352 |
| paper, D | 22: 469.19 euros = 0.354 of w (printed: 35.4 %) |
| fitted parabola bottoms out at D | 77.5 min; beyond it the |
| penalty shrinks, an artefact of the quadratic, not a finding |
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p11: Re-running Stutzer and Frey's compensation arithmetic.
# Model (source: Stutzer and Frey 2008, accepted manuscript, sec. 3e):
# life satisfaction (0-10, GSOEP 1985-2003, individual fixed effects)
# changes with one-way commuting minutes D as dU = b1*D + b2*D^2,
# b1 = -5.425e-3, b2 = +0.035e-3. The marginal utility of monthly net
# labour income w at the means w = 1326 and household income y = 2800
# (euros) is g1 + 2*g2*w + g3 + 2*g4*y with the printed income terms.
# Compensation = -dU / MU euros a month. Coefficients are the paper's;
# the extra rows (D other than 22) are our extrapolation of its fit.
# Sample facts quoted in the text: mean one-way commute 22 min (SD 18,
# median 15); 6.8 % commute an hour or more; the paper's own summary is
# 0.103 points lower satisfaction at 22 min and "about 470 euros".
import math
B1, B2 = -5.425e-3, 0.035e-3
G1, G2, G3, G4 = 0.157e-3, -7.80e-9, 0.100e-3, -3.24e-9
W, Y = 1326.0, 2800.0
PAPER_EUROS = 469.19 # as printed in the manuscript
def d_u(d):
return math.fsum([B1 * d, B2 * d * d])
def mu_income():
return math.fsum([G1, 2 * G2 * W, G3, 2 * G4 * Y])
mu = mu_income()
print("Stutzer-Frey compensation re-run from the printed coefficients")
print("MU of labour income at the means: {:.5f}e-3 per euro".format(
mu * 1e3))
print("{:>6} {:>9} {:>12} {:>10} {:>10}".format(
"D min", "dU 0-10", "euros/month", "share w", "share y"))
for d in (10, 22, 30, 45, 60, 77.5, 90):
du = d_u(d)
eur = -du / mu
print("{:>6} {:>9.4f} {:>12.1f} {:>10.4f} {:>10.4f}".format(
d, du, eur, eur / W, eur / Y))
print("paper, D = 22: {} euros = {:.3f} of w (printed: 35.4 %)".format(
PAPER_EUROS, PAPER_EUROS / W))
turn = -B1 / (2 * B2)
print("fitted parabola bottoms out at D = {:.1f} min; beyond it the".format(
turn))
print("penalty shrinks, an artefact of the quadratic, not a finding")Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). The Commuting Paradox, Compensating-Income Equations, Remote-Work Location Choice and the Foolish Old Man's Relocation Decision (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 1: The Commuting Paradox: Where the Thirty-Five Per Cent Comes From. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-204 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026204,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {The Commuting Paradox, Compensating-Income Equations, Remote-Work Location Choice and the Foolish Old Man's Relocation Decision},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 2 · The Case Against: Estimators, Sample Sizes and an Effect That Comes and Goes
- Chapter 3 · The Compensating-Variation Equation: the Price of Time, a Stress Term and Mispredicted Adaptation
- Chapter 4 · Siting a Studio: the Net Present Value of Rent and the Team's Commute
- Chapter 5 · Remote and Hybrid Work: the Marginal Arithmetic of Office Days
- Chapter 6 · Move or Commute: Real Options and the Value of Waiting
- Chapter 7 · The Foolish Old Man and Pascal: Moving Mountains, Moving House and Sitting in a Room
- Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: a Team Commuting Audit, a Siting Tool and a Pre-Registered Test