Falsifying the Catharsis Hypothesis: Two-Factor Arousal Decay and the Optimal Cooling-Off Period in Negotiation: chapter answers
"Let it out or it will eat you up" is among the most widespread beliefs about emotion. This book writes it as a prediction that can lose: anger and aggression after venting should be lower than without venting. Randomized experiments give the opposite answer, and the book then uses three kinds of mathematics, first-order decay, excitation transfer and optimal stopping, to show that what works is bringing arousal down and waiting, and how long to wait. Its parameters are illustrative; all calculations are generated by its programs; the book is not psychological, medical or legal advice, nor pe…
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-200 · 中文版
- Chapter 1 · The Punching-Bag Ledger: Recomputing Bushman (2002) and the Arousal Meta-Analysis
Chapter 1 recomputes Table 1 of Bushman (2002): hitting a bag while dwelling on the provoker has an aggression effect of 0.298, with the whole interval above zero, and the meta-analysis of Kjærvik and Bushman (2024) fin… - Chapter 2 · Hydraulics versus Rehearsal: an Order-Restricted Test of Two Venting Models
Chapter 2 compares a hydraulic and a rehearsal model by isotonic regression, with a likelihood ratio of 164.5 on anger, and sets out the conditions under which venting might seem to work, with the counter-evidence. - Chapter 3 · First-Order Decay: Time Constants, Thresholds and Shot Noise
Chapter 3 uses first-order decay to compute the wait until a threshold: 16.9 minutes of plain waiting for someone provoked to 7 with a 20-minute time constant, and treats repeated provocations with Campbell's theorem. - Chapter 4 · Two Clocks: the Excitation-Transfer Window and the Two-Factor Label
Chapter 4 computes the excitation-transfer window from Zillmann's two clocks, peaking at 10.75 minutes under illustrative parameters, and reports the controversy over two-factor theory. - Chapter 5 · Optimal Stopping: How Long a Cooling-Off Period Should Be
Chapter 5 calibrates acceptance to delay experiments in the ultimatum game; at moderate withdrawal risk the best pause is 14.7 minutes, worth 3.09 times deciding at once. - Chapter 6 · Displayed Is Not Felt: Anger as a Signal, Power and the Price of Impatience
Chapter 6 reports the value of anger as a signal, argues for selective display after calming down, and prices impatience: doubling it costs 0.1665 of the share. - Chapter 7 · Classics East and West: the Zhongyong's Measure and Seneca's Delay
Chapter 7 examines the Zhongyong's "hitting the measure" and Seneca's delay in On Anger; expressing at once after a provocation hits the measure with probability 0.011, rising to 0.752 after 20 minutes. - Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: Complaint Cooling Rules, an Owner's Emotion-Decision Log and Pre-Registration
Chapter 8 gives complaint cooling rules (acknowledge first, with a best substantive delay of about 35.5 minutes), an owner's emotion-decision log, the Cooling-Off Calculator and a pre-registered test (176 events per gro…
Illustrative model calculation, not a live quote