5D Library › 体制转换分数凯利、最大回撤约束与生命周期杠杆配置 · English

第八章 实践:十年杠杆表、跳空风险与回撤预警规则

注

不是投资建议。 本章把前面的算术整理成供讨论的表格与规则。其中的市场都是参数为示意的模型;唯一的历史数字是 1987 年 10 月 19 日的单日跌幅。这里的任何内容都不是使用杠杆、买卖任何证券或遵循任何规则的建议。

十年凯利杠杆表

p14 对夏普比率 0.2 至 0.5、波动率 0.16 的情形,在没有体制切换的对数正态市场中,给出十年最大回撤超过界限的机会不超过 0.05 的最大凯利比例。

推导

# Chapter 8. p14: A ten-year Kelly leverage table. Continuously
# rebalanced portfolio, log-normal market with volatility 0.16, cash at
# 0.02; Sharpe ratios 0.2 to 0.5. For each limit D on the maximum
# drawdown, the largest fraction k of Kelly (steps of 0.025) whose
# ten-year maximum drawdown, checked monthly, exceeds D with chance at
# most 0.05; leverage = k * Kelly. 3,000 paths per Sharpe, seed 98.
import random
from math import sqrt

SIG, RF = 0.16, 0.02
KS = [i / 40 for i in range(1, 33)]

def mdd(zs, lev, ex):
    mu = (RF + lev * ex - 0.5 * (lev * SIG) ** 2) / 12
    sd = lev * SIG / sqrt(12)
    x = peak = dd = 0.0
    for z in zs:
        x += mu + sd * z
        if x > peak:
            peak = x
        elif peak - x > dd:
            dd = peak - x
    return 1 - 2.718281828459045 ** (-dd)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(98)
    print("   Sharpe  Kelly   k (D=15%)  lev   k (D=20%)  lev   "
          "k (D=30%)  lev")
    for sh in (0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5):
        ex = sh * SIG
        kelly = ex / SIG ** 2
        zs = [[rng.gauss(0, 1) for _ in range(120)] for _ in range(3000)]
        row = []
        for D in (0.15, 0.2, 0.3):
            best = 0.0
            for k in KS:
                bad = sum(mdd(z, k * kelly, ex) > D for z in zs) / 3000
                if bad <= 0.05:
                    best = k
            row += [best, best * kelly]
        print("   {:6.1f}  {:5.2f}   {:9.3f}  {:4.2f}  {:9.3f}  {:4.2f}  "
              " {:9.3f}  {:4.2f}".format(sh, kelly, *row))
#    Sharpe  Kelly   k (D=15%)  lev   k (D=20%)  lev   k (D=30%)  lev
#       0.2   1.25       0.225  0.28      0.275  0.34       0.400  0.50
#       0.3   1.88       0.150  0.28      0.200  0.38       0.275  0.52
#       0.4   2.50       0.125  0.31      0.150  0.38       0.225  0.56
#       0.5   3.12       0.100  0.31      0.125  0.39       0.200  0.62

有两点值得注意。凯利比例随夏普比率上升而下降(20% 界限下从夏普 0.2 时的 0.275 降到 0.5 时的 0.125),而由此得到的杠杆却落在一个很窄的区间:20% 界限下是 0.34 至 0.39,15% 时 0.28 至 0.31,30% 时 0.50 至 0.62。回撤界限主要是对波动率的限制;对于波动率 0.16 的资产,20% 的界限大约只允许把三分之一的财富放在其中,不论认定的优势有多大。在有熊市体制的市场里,界限还要更紧(第四章)。

跳空风险

本书的每个公式都假定财富连续地或按月变动。1987 年 10 月 19 日,标普 500 一天之内下跌 20.47%。p15 显示这样一天对带杠杆的账户意味着什么。

推导

# Chapter 8. p15: Gap risk that no Kelly formula sees. On 19 October 1987
# the S&P 500 fell 20.47% in one day. For a portfolio with leverage L
# (assets / equity): the loss of equity that day; the one-day fall that
# triggers a margin call at 25% maintenance, (1 - 0.25 L) / (0.75 L);
# and the fall that wipes out the equity, 1 / L.
CRASH = 0.2047

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   leverage  loss on 19 Oct 1987  margin-call fall  wipe-out fall")
    for L in (0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0):
        loss = min(L * CRASH, 1.0)
        call = (1 - 0.25 * L) / (0.75 * L)
        print("   {:8.1f}  {:19.3f}  {:16.3f}  {:13.3f}".format(
            L, loss, min(call, 1.0), min(1 / L, 1.0)))
    print("   leverage at which that day alone wipes out: {:.2f}".format(
        1 / CRASH))
#    leverage  loss on 19 Oct 1987  margin-call fall  wipe-out fall
#         0.5                0.102             1.000          1.000
#         1.0                0.205             1.000          1.000
#         1.5                0.307             0.556          0.667
#         2.0                0.409             0.333          0.500
#         3.0                0.614             0.111          0.333
#         4.0                0.819             0.000          0.250
#    leverage at which that day alone wipes out: 4.89

杠杆 2 时那一天损失 0.409 的权益,杠杆 3 时损失 0.614。维持保证金要求为 25% 时,杠杆 3 的账户下跌 0.111 就会收到追加保证金通知,杠杆 4 则任何下跌都会。杠杆在 4.89 或以上的账户,仅这一天就会归零。(表中的 1.000 表示任何跌幅都不会触发追保或归零。)由月度回撤算出的表格对这样的一天一无所知,表中的杠杆必须为它留出余地。

回撤预警规则

不用模型而近似体制感知凯利的一种实用办法是预警规则:账户处于回撤时降低敞口,恢复后再还原。p16 在两体制市场中把它与体制滤波警报以及固定敞口比较。

推导

# Chapter 8. p16: A drawdown warning rule. In the two-regime market of
# p02 (ten years, started from its long-run mix, cash at 0.02), the
# base exposure is 0.20 of the whole-history Kelly 1.46. "Drawdown
# alarm" halves it while the drawdown from the peak exceeds 10%, until
# it is back under 5%. "Regime alarm" halves it while the Hamilton
# filter (p05) gives bear a chance above 0.5. Compared with constant
# 0.10 and 0.20 of Kelly. An alarm month in a bull regime counts as a
# false alarm. 5,000 paths, seed 98.
import random
from math import exp, pi, sqrt

R12 = sqrt(12)
REG = ((0.12 / 12, 0.13 / R12), (-0.25 / 12, 0.28 / R12))
STAY, RF, KELLY = (0.98, 0.92), 0.02 / 12, 1.46

def dens(x, m, sd):
    return exp(-0.5 * ((x - m) / sd) ** 2) / (sd * sqrt(2 * pi))

RULES = ("constant 0.10", "constant 0.20", "drawdown alarm",
         "regime alarm")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(98)
    res = {r: [[], [], 0, 0] for r in RULES}
    for _ in range(5000):
        s = 0 if rng.random() < 0.8 else 1
        p = 0.2
        st = {r: [1.0, 1.0, 0.0, False] for r in RULES}
        for _ in range(120):
            if rng.random() > STAY[s]:
                s = 1 - s
            x = rng.gauss(*REG[s])
            for r in RULES:
                v = st[r]
                k = 0.10 if r == "constant 0.10" else 0.20
                if r == "drawdown alarm":
                    d = 1 - v[0] / v[1]
                    v[3] = d > 0.10 or (v[3] and d > 0.05)
                elif r == "regime alarm":
                    v[3] = p > 0.5
                if v[3]:
                    k /= 2
                    res[r][2] += 1
                    res[r][3] += s == 0
                v[0] *= 1 + RF + k * KELLY * x
                v[1] = max(v[1], v[0])
                v[2] = max(v[2], 1 - v[0] / v[1])
            q = p * STAY[1] + (1 - p) * (1 - STAY[0])
            a, b = q * dens(x, *REG[1]), (1 - q) * dens(x, *REG[0])
            p = a / (a + b)
        for r in RULES:
            res[r][0].append(st[r][0])
            res[r][1].append(st[r][2])
    print("   rule            median W  P(MDD>20%)  alarm share  false")
    for r in RULES:
        w = sorted(res[r][0])
        n = res[r][2]
        print("   {:<14}  {:8.3f}  {:10.3f}  {:11.3f}  {:5.3f}".format(
            r, w[2500], sum(d > 0.2 for d in res[r][1]) / 5000,
            n / 600000, res[r][3] / n if n else 0.0))
#    rule            median W  P(MDD>20%)  alarm share  false
#    constant 0.10      1.318       0.007        0.000  0.000
#    constant 0.20      1.414       0.226        0.000  0.000
#    drawdown alarm     1.403       0.050        0.206  0.607
#    regime alarm       1.450       0.039        0.165  0.235

固定凯利 0.20 倍突破 20% 界限的机会是 0.226;固定 0.10 倍是 0.007,但增长较少(中位数 1.318 对 1.414)。回撤警报在回撤超过 10% 时把敞口减半,把机会降到 0.050,中位数仍有 1.403;它在 0.206 的月份处于警报状态,其中 0.607 是牛市月份,所以它的警报大多是误报。体制警报稍好(0.039 与 1.450),但它使用的是真实的模型参数,没有任何投资者拥有这些参数。回撤警报只用账户自身的历史。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 对散户账户而言,在回撤 10% 后把杠杆减半的规则,能把 20% 以上回撤的频率降低一半以上,而十年收益中位数每年的代价不到一个百分点。什么会证明它错: 在多个国家长期股指历史上按月再平衡的回测中,这条规则使此类回撤的频率降低不到一半,或每年代价超过一个百分点。

小结

十年 20% 的回撤界限,对于波动率 0.16 的资产大约只允许三分之一的财富,不论认定的夏普比率是多少。1987 年的那一天说明杠杆必须在月度算术之外留出余地。一条简单的回撤预警规则在体制市场中几乎不损失增长中位数就守住了 20% 的界限,尽管它的警报大多是误报。

Fan, Y. (2026). Regime-Switching Fractional Kelly, Maximum-Drawdown Constraints and Lifecycle Leverage Allocation: Cyclical Drift Estimation Errors, Ruin-Bounded Bet Sizing and Human-Capital Amortization [体制转换分数凯利、最大回撤约束与生命周期杠杆配置] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090256 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).