5D Library › 体制转换分数凯利、最大回撤约束与生命周期杠杆配置 · English

第一章 全凯利与乐观的漂移:好年景为什么催生过度下注

增长曲线

凯利准则选择下注占财富的比例,使财富长期增长最快 (Kelly 1956)。对于超额收益为 μ−r\mu – r、波动率为 σ\sigma 的资产,在连续再平衡的组合中,增长最优的杠杆是 f*=(μ−r)/σ2f^* = (\mu – r)/\sigma^2 (Thorp 2006)。下注 cc 倍的 f*f^*,超额对数增长率为 S2(c−c2/2)S^2 (c – c^2/2),其中 S=(μ−r)/σS = (\mu – r)/\sigma 是夏普比率。这条曲线是一条抛物线:在 c=1c = 1 处达到顶点,到 c=2c = 2 回到零,再往上为负。

实际中要紧的是,cc 并不是直接选出来的。投资者先认定一个超额收益,再从它算出 f*f^*;如果认定值是真实值的两倍,下注就是两倍凯利。p01 取超额收益每年 0.05、波动率 0.16。

推导

# Chapter 1. p01: The Kelly growth curve and what an optimistic drift
# does to it. Excess return mu - r = 0.05 a year, volatility 0.16, so
# full Kelly f* = (mu - r) / sigma^2. An investor who believes the
# excess return is m instead of 0.05 bets c = m / 0.05 times Kelly.
# Excess log growth of wealth: S^2 (c - c^2 / 2), S = Sharpe ratio.
EX, SIG = 0.05, 0.16

if __name__ == "__main__":
    f_star = EX / SIG ** 2
    s2 = (EX / SIG) ** 2
    print("   full Kelly leverage f* = {:.3f}; Sharpe {:.4f}".format(
        f_star, EX / SIG))
    print("   believed excess  multiple c  leverage  wealth vol  growth")
    for m in (0.0125, 0.025, 0.05, 0.075, 0.10, 0.125, 0.15):
        c = m / EX
        g = s2 * (c - c * c / 2)
        print("   {:15.4f}  {:10.2f}  {:8.2f}  {:10.3f}  {:+.4f}".format(
            m, c, c * f_star, c * EX / SIG, g))
    print("   growth at half Kelly / full Kelly: {:.2f}".format(
        (0.5 - 0.125) / 0.5))
    print("   wealth vol at half Kelly / full Kelly: {:.2f}".format(0.5))
#    full Kelly leverage f* = 1.953; Sharpe 0.3125
#    believed excess  multiple c  leverage  wealth vol  growth
#             0.0125        0.25      0.49       0.078  +0.0214
#             0.0250        0.50      0.98       0.156  +0.0366
#             0.0500        1.00      1.95       0.312  +0.0488
#             0.0750        1.50      2.93       0.469  +0.0366
#             0.1000        2.00      3.91       0.625  +0.0000
#             0.1250        2.50      4.88       0.781  -0.0610
#             0.1500        3.00      5.86       0.938  -0.1465
#    growth at half Kelly / full Kelly: 0.75
#    wealth vol at half Kelly / full Kelly: 0.50

这里的全凯利是 1.953 倍杠杆,财富波动率 0.312,每年超额增长 0.0488。认定超额收益为 0.10 的投资者押上 3.91 倍财富,超额增长恰好为零,财富波动率 0.625;认定为 0.15 的投资者押上 5.86 倍,每年对数意义上亏损 0.1465。半凯利保留 0.75 的增长,只承担 0.50 的波动,这就是谨慎的实践者下注凯利分数的原因 (MacLean et al. 2011)。

p01 市场中,按凯利倍数分列的超额对数增长;圆点标出半凯利、全凯利与两倍凯利。

漂移能估计得多准

市场的波动率用几年数据就能估计得不错,均值却不行。用 TT 年数据测得的平均超额收益,标准误是 σ/T\sigma/\sqrt{T},p02 的 (a) 部分说明这意味着什么。(b) 部分加入一个有两种隐藏体制的市场:牛市体制超额收益每年 0.12、波动率 0.13,熊市体制 -0.25、波动率 0.28,两者按马尔可夫链切换 (Hamilton 1989)。

推导

# Chapter 1. p02: How well can the drift be estimated, and what does a
# "tailwind" sample do? (a) i.i.d. world of p01: the standard error of
# a mean excess return estimated from T years is 0.16 / sqrt(T).
# (b) A two-regime market, monthly: bull excess 0.12 a year (vol 0.13),
# bear -0.25 (vol 0.28); a bull month stays bull with chance 0.98, a
# bear month stays bear with 0.92. An investor estimates mean and
# variance from the last 60 months, either at random dates or only
# when a bull run has lasted 36 months or more. Seed 98.
import random
from math import sqrt
from statistics import NormalDist

BULL, BEAR = (0.12 / 12, 0.13 / sqrt(12)), (-0.25 / 12, 0.28 / sqrt(12))
STAY = (0.98, 0.92)

def chain(rng, n):
    s, run, out = 0, 0, []
    for _ in range(n):
        if rng.random() > STAY[s]:
            s, run = 1 - s, 0
        run += 1
        m, sd = BULL if s == 0 else BEAR
        out.append((s, run, rng.gauss(m, sd)))
    return out

def kelly(xs):
    m = sum(xs) / len(xs)
    v = sum((x - m) ** 2 for x in xs) / (len(xs) - 1)
    return m * 12, v * 12, m / v

if __name__ == "__main__":
    z = NormalDist()
    print("   (a) years  std error  P(estimate >= 2 x true)")
    for t in (5, 10, 30, 100):
        se = 0.16 / sqrt(t)
        print("   {:9d}  {:9.4f}  {:23.3f}".format(
            t, se, 1 - z.cdf(0.05 / se)))
    rng = random.Random(98)
    xs = chain(rng, 600000)
    allx = [x for _, _, x in xs]
    m_all, v_all, f_all = kelly(allx)
    print("   (b) whole history: excess {:.4f}, vol {:.4f}, Kelly {:.2f}"
          .format(m_all, sqrt(v_all), f_all))
    for name, cond in (("random dates", lambda s, r: True),
                       ("bull run >= 36 months", lambda s, r: s == 0
                        and r >= 36)):
        fs = []
        for i in range(60, len(xs), 7):
            s, r, _ = xs[i - 1]
            if cond(s, r):
                fs.append(kelly(allx[i - 60:i])[2])
        fs.sort()
        q = lambda a: fs[int(a * (len(fs) - 1))]
        print("   {:<22} n {:5d}  median f {:5.2f}  10%-90% {:5.2f} to "
              "{:5.2f}".format(name, len(fs), q(0.5), q(0.1), q(0.9)))
        print("   {:<22} share with f >= 2 x whole-history Kelly: {:.3f}"
              .format("", sum(f >= 2 * f_all for f in fs) / len(fs)))
#    (a) years  std error  P(estimate >= 2 x true)
#            5     0.0716                    0.242
#           10     0.0506                    0.162
#           30     0.0292                    0.043
#          100     0.0160                    0.001
#    (b) whole history: excess 0.0452, vol 0.1759, Kelly 1.46
#    random dates           n 85706  median f  2.42  10%-90% -2.27 to  9.24
#                           share with f >= 2 x whole-history Kelly: 0.460
#    bull run >= 36 months  n 34037  median f  5.69  10%-90%  0.41 to 11.32
#                           share with f >= 2 x whole-history Kelly: 0.740

用十年数据,标准误是 0.0506,与超额收益本身一样大,因此一个诚实的估计至少高出真实值一倍的机会是 0.162;用五年数据是 0.242。要有一百年的数据,这个机会才降到 0.001。

在两体制市场中,全历史超额收益是 0.0452、波动率 0.1759,单一体制的凯利杠杆是 1.46。在随机日期用最近六十个月估计,中位数是 2.42,因为大多数六十个月的窗口主要由牛市月份组成;其中 0.460 达到全历史凯利的两倍以上。只在牛市已持续三年之后才估计的投资者,也就是人们通常加杠杆的时刻,得到的中位数是 5.69,其中 0.740 落在两倍凯利以上。过度下注不是某些投资者的性格缺陷,而是长期顺风的数据本身造成的。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 散户承担的杠杆随此前牛市的长度上升,大致与用滚动窗口估计的凯利同步。什么会证明它错: 在覆盖多个周期的券商或融资余额数据中,融资相对于权益的比例不随此前上涨的长度上升,或其上升幅度小于滚动五年凯利估计的变化所隐含的幅度。

小结

凯利增长曲线宽容下注不足而惩罚下注过度:到两倍凯利时增长已经消失。决定凯利的漂移,用十年数据也只能估计到每年约 0.05 的精度,而在长牛市中取得的样本会高估它,因此顺风时算出的「全凯利」通常是真实凯利的数倍。

参考文献

Hamilton, James D. 1989. “A New Approach to the Economic Analysis of Nonstationary Time Series and the Business Cycle.” Econometrica 57 (2): 357 to 384.
Kelly, Jr., John L. 1956. “A New Interpretation of Information Rate.” Bell System Technical Journal 35 (4): 917 to 926.
MacLean, Leonard C., Edward O. Thorp, and William T. Ziemba, eds. 2011. The Kelly Capital Growth Investment Criterion: Theory and Practice. World Scientific.
Thorp, Edward O. 2006. “The Kelly Criterion in Blackjack, Sports Betting, and the Stock Market.” In Handbook of Asset and Liability Management, Volume 1, edited by Stavros A. Zenios and William T. Ziemba. North-Holland.

Fan, Y. (2026). Regime-Switching Fractional Kelly, Maximum-Drawdown Constraints and Lifecycle Leverage Allocation: Cyclical Drift Estimation Errors, Ruin-Bounded Bet Sizing and Human-Capital Amortization [体制转换分数凯利、最大回撤约束与生命周期杠杆配置] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090256 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).