5D Library › 下丘脑垂体肾上腺轴耦合振荡、皮质醇觉醒反应扁平化与倦怠恢复动力学 · English
第一章 一个带延迟的环
三种激素、一个刹车,以及一段传递时间
这条轴是一串三步的链条,外面裹着一个刹车。下丘脑释放一种激素,垂体以促肾上腺皮质激素作答,肾上腺以皮质醇作答,而皮质醇又回去压制第一步。这段描述里没有任何有争议的东西。值得算的是刹车来得晚所带来的后果,因为带延迟的负反馈不只是收敛得更慢;延迟超过某个值之后,它根本不再收敛,而是开始振荡。
在这个系统里这不是假想。这条轴确实在振荡,脉冲大致相隔一小时,而 Walker、Terry 与 Lightman 追问这些脉冲从何而来,证明一个带延迟的垂体肾上腺环就能产生它们,上游无须另设一个脉冲发生器 (Walker et al. 2010)。本章向这个说法提出的问题是定量的而非定性的:在清除速率被固定在实测值而非拟合值时,这个环能否产生观测到的那个频率的脉冲?
证据
已发表。 Walker、Terry 与 Lightman 证明,垂体与肾上腺之间一个带延迟的反馈环足以产生促肾上腺皮质激素与皮质醇的超日脉冲,并分析了该振荡存在的条件 (Walker et al. 2010)。
下面的模型把每个清除速率取为二的自然对数除以一个已发表的血浆半衰期,所以那里没有可调的东西。反馈是一个希尔项。唯一自由的量是延迟。
推导
# Chapter 1. p01: The three-stage loop with a delay. Releasing hormone
# drives corticotropin, corticotropin drives cortisol, and cortisol
# feeds back to suppress the releasing hormone after a transit delay.
# Each clearance rate below is the natural logarithm of two divided by a
# published plasma half-life, so the time constants are not free
# parameters. The feedback is a Hill term of exponent N. The loop is
# integrated forward by small steps with a history buffer for the delay.
# What is asked is: at what delay does the loop stop settling and start
# oscillating, and what period does it then have?
HL_CORT, HL_ACTH, HL_CRH = 70.0, 15.0, 10.0 # minutes
N, GAIN, K = 8.0, 20.0, 1.0
T, DT = 300.0, 0.002 # hours
LN2 = 0.6931471805599453
BC = LN2 / (HL_CORT / 60.0)
QA = LN2 / (HL_ACTH / 60.0)
MH = LN2 / (HL_CRH / 60.0)
KC, PA, KH = BC * 1.6, QA, MH * GAIN
def simulate(tau, scale=1.0):
bc, qa, mh = BC * scale, QA * scale, MH * scale
kc, pa, kh = bc * 1.6, qa, mh * GAIN
lag = int(round(tau / DT))
c = [1.0] * (lag + 1)
a = h = 0.6
tail = []
steps = int(T / DT)
for i in range(steps):
cl = c[-1 - lag]
f = 1.0 / (1.0 + (cl / K) ** N)
h += DT * (kh * f - mh * h)
a += DT * (pa * h - qa * a)
c.append(c[-1] + DT * (kc * a - bc * c[-1]))
if i * DT > T * 0.6:
tail.append(c[-1])
amp = 0.5 * (max(tail) - min(tail))
mean = sum(tail) / len(tail)
cross = []
for i in range(1, len(tail)):
if (tail[i - 1] - mean) < 0.0 <= (tail[i] - mean):
cross.append(i * DT)
per = ((cross[-1] - cross[0]) / (len(cross) - 1)
if len(cross) > 2 else 0.0)
return amp, per, mean
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" clearance rates per hour from the published half-lives:")
print(" cortisol {:.4f}, corticotropin {:.4f}, releasing hormone"
" {:.4f}".format(BC, QA, MH))
print(" delay h amplitude period h mean")
for tau in (0.00, 0.05, 0.10, 0.15, 0.20, 0.25, 0.33, 0.50):
amp, per, mean = simulate(tau)
print(" {:<10.2f}{:<12.4f}{:<11.3f}{:.4f}"
.format(tau, amp, per, mean))
lo, hi = 0.0, 0.50
for _ in range(34):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if simulate(mid)[0] > 0.01:
hi = mid
else:
lo = mid
crit = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
print(" the loop starts to oscillate at a delay of {:.4f} hours"
.format(crit))
print(" which is {:.1f} minutes".format(crit * 60.0))
amp, per, mean = simulate(0.25)
print(" at a delay of 0.25 hours the period is {:.3f} hours"
.format(per))
print(" which is {:.1f} minutes".format(per * 60.0))
print(" the observed pulse interval in people is 60 to 90 minutes,")
print(" so this loop, built only from plasma half-lives, is about")
print(" {:.2f} times too slow".format(per * 60.0 / 75.0))
print(" amplitude there is {:.4f} about a mean of {:.4f},"
.format(amp, mean))
print(" a relative swing of {:.4f}".format(amp / mean))
# clearance rates per hour from the published half-lives:
# cortisol 0.5941, corticotropin 2.7726, releasing hormone 4.1589
# delay h amplitude period h mean
# 0.00 0.0000 0.000 1.4621
# 0.05 0.0000 0.000 1.4621
# 0.10 0.0000 0.000 1.4621
# 0.15 0.0001 2.312 1.4621
# 0.20 0.2420 2.539 1.5289
# 0.25 0.4348 2.859 1.6396
# 0.33 0.7305 3.374 1.8467
# 0.50 1.4957 4.441 2.3653
# the loop starts to oscillate at a delay of 0.1630 hours
# which is 9.8 minutes
# at a delay of 0.25 hours the period is 2.859 hours
# which is 171.5 minutes
# the observed pulse interval in people is 60 to 90 minutes,
# so this loop, built only from plasma half-lives, is about
# 2.29 times too slow
# amplitude there is 0.4348 about a mean of 1.6396,
# a relative swing of 0.2652延迟小时这个环会收敛,延迟大时它会振荡,而边界在 9.8 分钟的延迟处。在十五分钟的延迟下,也就是从垂体到肾上腺再回来的传递时间的正确量级,周期是 171.5 分钟,相对摆幅 0.2652,均值 1.6396。而人体脉冲之间的实测间隔是六十到九十分钟,所以这个环慢了 2.29 倍。
这是一处真实的不符,不是一个舍入问题。它也是有用的那一类,因为差距的大小约束了修补的方式。
哪一种修补便宜
有两件事可以弥合这个差距。垂体真正读到的那个信号,可能比血浆总皮质醇周转得更快,那就意味着模型里的清除太慢了。或者整个环连延迟一起运行得更快,那就意味着振荡器根本不是这个全身环,而是某个更紧、更靠中枢的东西。
推导
# Chapter 1. p02: What would have to be true for the period to match.
# p01 found that a loop built from plasma half-lives oscillates with a
# period about twice the observed pulse interval. Two repairs are
# scanned. The first speeds up the clearances only, which is the same as
# saying the signal the pituitary reads turns over faster than total
# plasma cortisol; the delay is left where it is. The second speeds up
# the whole loop, clearances and delay together. Only one of them can
# reach the observed period, and which one it is says something about
# where the pulse generator has to live.
HL_CORT, HL_ACTH, HL_CRH = 70.0, 15.0, 10.0
N, GAIN, K = 8.0, 20.0, 1.0
T, DT = 300.0, 0.002
TARGET = 75.0 # minutes, the middle of the observed band
LN2 = 0.6931471805599453
BC, QA, MH = (LN2 / (HL_CORT / 60.0), LN2 / (HL_ACTH / 60.0),
LN2 / (HL_CRH / 60.0))
def simulate(tau, scale=1.0):
bc, qa, mh = BC * scale, QA * scale, MH * scale
kc, pa, kh = bc * 1.6, qa, mh * GAIN
lag = int(round(tau / DT))
c = [1.0] * (lag + 1)
a = h = 0.6
tail = []
for i in range(int(T / DT)):
cl = c[-1 - lag]
f = 1.0 / (1.0 + (cl / K) ** N)
h += DT * (kh * f - mh * h)
a += DT * (pa * h - qa * a)
c.append(c[-1] + DT * (kc * a - bc * c[-1]))
if i * DT > T * 0.6:
tail.append(c[-1])
amp = 0.5 * (max(tail) - min(tail))
mean = sum(tail) / len(tail)
cross = []
for i in range(1, len(tail)):
if (tail[i - 1] - mean) < 0.0 <= (tail[i] - mean):
cross.append(i * DT)
per = ((cross[-1] - cross[0]) / (len(cross) - 1)
if len(cross) > 2 else 0.0)
return amp, per, mean
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" faster turnover at a delay of 0.25 hours:")
print(" scale period min amplitude effective cortisol half-life")
for s in (1.0, 1.2, 1.4, 1.6, 1.8, 2.0, 2.4):
amp, per, mean = simulate(0.25, s)
print(" {:<8.1f}{:<13.1f}{:<12.4f}{:.1f}"
.format(s, per * 60.0, amp, HL_CORT / s))
print(" pushed much further, the period stops falling:")
for s in (4.0, 8.0, 16.0, 32.0):
amp, per, mean = simulate(0.25, s)
print(" scale {:<7.1f}period {:.1f} minutes".format(s,
per * 60.0))
print(" it is settling near {:.1f} minutes, which is {:.2f} times"
.format(simulate(0.25, 32.0)[1] * 60.0,
simulate(0.25, 32.0)[1] / 0.25))
print(" the delay. The target of {:.0f} minutes is reached near a"
.format(TARGET))
lo, hi = 1.0, 32.0
for _ in range(34):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if simulate(0.25, mid)[1] * 60.0 > TARGET:
lo = mid
else:
hi = mid
sc = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
print(" scale of {:.3f}, an effective cortisol half-life of {:.1f}"
.format(sc, HL_CORT / sc))
print(" minutes, which no measurement of the hormone supports")
print(" the whole loop faster, delay included:")
print(" scale delay min period min amplitude")
for s in (1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.29, 3.0):
amp, per, mean = simulate(0.25 / s, s)
print(" {:<8.2f}{:<12.1f}{:<13.1f}{:.4f}"
.format(s, 0.25 / s * 60.0, per * 60.0, amp))
lo, hi = 1.0, 6.0
for _ in range(34):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if simulate(0.25 / mid, mid)[1] * 60.0 > TARGET:
lo = mid
else:
hi = mid
s = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
print(" the factor that reproduces a {:.0f} minute period: {:.4f}"
.format(TARGET, s))
print(" which is far more modest than the {:.3f} the first repair"
.format(sc))
print(" needed, so the pulse generator is better placed above the")
print(" pituitary than in the clearance of the hormone")
print(" it needs an effective cortisol half-life of {:.1f} minutes"
.format(HL_CORT / s))
print(" and a delay of {:.1f} minutes".format(0.25 / s * 60.0))
print(" scaling the whole loop leaves the shape untouched, so the")
print(" relative swing stays at {:.4f}"
.format(simulate(0.25 / s, s)[0] / simulate(0.25 / s, s)[2]))
print(" against {:.4f} at the published rates"
.format(simulate(0.25, 1.0)[0] / simulate(0.25, 1.0)[2]))
# faster turnover at a delay of 0.25 hours:
# scale period min amplitude effective cortisol half-life
# 1.0 171.5 0.4348 70.0
# 1.2 158.9 0.6160 58.3
# 1.4 149.9 0.8073 50.0
# 1.6 143.0 1.0153 43.8
# 1.8 137.5 1.2425 38.9
# 2.0 132.9 1.4899 35.0
# 2.4 125.3 2.0418 29.2
# pushed much further, the period stops falling:
# scale 4.0 period 103.7 minutes
# scale 8.0 period 74.4 minutes
# scale 16.0 period 53.8 minutes
# scale 32.0 period 42.0 minutes
# it is settling near 42.0 minutes, which is 2.80 times
# the delay. The target of 75 minutes is reached near a
# scale of 7.866, an effective cortisol half-life of 8.9
# minutes, which no measurement of the hormone supports
# the whole loop faster, delay included:
# scale delay min period min amplitude
# 1.00 15.0 171.5 0.4348
# 1.50 10.0 113.8 0.4291
# 2.00 7.5 85.0 0.4233
# 2.29 6.6 74.8 0.4362
# 3.00 5.0 56.9 0.4335
# the factor that reproduces a 75 minute period: 2.2767
# which is far more modest than the 7.866 the first repair
# needed, so the pulse generator is better placed above the
# pituitary than in the clearance of the hormone
# it needs an effective cortisol half-life of 30.7 minutes
# and a delay of 6.6 minutes
# scaling the whole loop leaves the shape untouched, so the
# relative swing stays at 0.2632
# against 0.2652 at the published rates只加快清除最终也行得通,但代价荒谬。周期从公开速率下的 171.5 分钟,落到四倍速率下的 103.7 分钟,再落到三十二倍下的 42.0 分钟;它在 7.866 倍附近达到七十五分钟的目标,而那意味着一个 8.9 分钟的有效皮质醇半衰期。对这种激素的任何测量都不支持这一点。而且随着倍数升高,周期会停止下落,稳定在延迟的 2.80 倍附近,因为延迟固定时,延迟最终会主导。
把整个环加快则便宜得多。清除与延迟一起缩放时周期精确地随之缩放,所以所需的倍数就是那处不符本身:2.2767,它要求一个 30.7 分钟的有效皮质醇半衰期与一个 6.6 分钟的延迟。两者都落在一个更紧、更靠中枢的环所可能具有的范围之内;而整个环的缩放不改变形状,所以相对摆幅停在 0.2632,对公开速率下的 0.2652。
假说 · 尚未验证
作者的诠释(尚未验证): 超日脉冲发生器位于垂体之上,在一个延迟与清除都比全身环快约 2.2767 倍的环路里,而不在全身的垂体肾上腺环里;全身环是被它驱动的,不是节律的产生者。什么会证明它错: 如果在一个去掉了下丘脑贡献、只剩垂体肾上腺环的制备中,相同周期的脉冲依然存在,而血浆半衰期未变,那么全身环毕竟是充分的,这一读法就是错的。
小结
一个只用公开半衰期搭成的环,在延迟超过 9.8 分钟后开始振荡,而在十五分钟的延迟下周期为 171.5 分钟,比实测脉冲间隔慢 2.29 倍。只靠加快清除来弥合这个差距需要 7.866 倍与一个 8.9 分钟的有效半衰期;靠加快整个环来弥合只需要 2.2767 倍。第二章问这些脉冲是为了什么。
参考文献
Fan, Y. (2026). HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics: Glucocorticoid Receptor Downregulation, Ultradian Pulsatility and Allostatic Load Reset [下丘脑垂体肾上腺轴耦合振荡、皮质醇觉醒反应扁平化与倦怠恢复动力学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090252 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).