5D Library › 复合补剂相互作用、时间疗法给药窗口与代谢酶竞争 · English

第二章 一个载体,以及它之前的损耗

关于共享载体的一条恒等式

上一章那个拥挤的位点有名字,也有序列。Gunshin 等人克隆了小肠的质子偶联二价金属转运体,并证明它把铁、锌、锰、钴、铜等等经由同一条通路搬运,这就是为什么复合维生素里的矿物质彼此并不独立 (Gunshin et al. 1997)。在临床那一侧,Hallberg 等人把分级剂量的钙随测试餐给予并直接测量铁吸收,确立了剂量反应关系,而不只是确立这个效应的存在 (Hallberg et al. 1991)。

证据

已发表。 Gunshin 等人鉴定了二价金属转运体及其宽广的底物范围 (Gunshin et al. 1997)。Hallberg 等人在人体受试者中测量了钙对非血红素铁与血红素铁吸收的剂量依赖性抑制 (Hallberg et al. 1991)。Lonnerdal 综述了支配锌吸收的膳食因素,其中包括植酸与锌的摩尔比 (Lonnerdal 2000)。

把钙剂量在模型里扫过一遍,会翻出一件临床文献通常不会陈述的事,因为它是代数的性质,而不是任何一种矿物质的性质。

推导

# Chapter 2. p03: What one mineral costs another at a shared carrier.
# The divalent metal carrier of the small intestine moves iron, zinc,
# magnesium and more through the same saturable route, so a large dose
# of one arrives as a competitor for the others. Here the calcium and
# magnesium doses are swept while the iron and zinc doses are held, and
# the absorbed milligrams are computed from the Michaelis fraction with
# the apparent affinity raised by the competitors present. The absorbed
# fraction is the carrier fraction times a fixed mucosal efficiency.
MASS = {"iron": 55.85, "zinc": 65.38, "calcium": 40.08,
        "magnesium": 24.305}
KM = {"iron": 0.080, "zinc": 0.150, "calcium": 5.000, "magnesium": 4.000}
EFF = {"iron": 0.18, "zinc": 0.26, "calcium": 0.30, "magnesium": 0.35}
DOSE = {"iron": 18.0, "zinc": 25.0}
SWEEP = (0.0, 100.0, 200.0, 300.0, 500.0, 700.0, 1000.0)
MG_WITH_CA = 0.8          # magnesium swept at this multiple of calcium

def mmol(name, mg):
    return mg / MASS[name]

def absorbed(name, mg, competitors):
    s = mmol(name, mg)
    extra = sum(mmol(c, d) / KM[c] for c, d in competitors.items() if d > 0.0)
    return mg * EFF[name] * s / (KM[name] * (1.0 + extra) + s)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   iron {:.0f} mg and zinc {:.0f} mg held; calcium swept, with"
          .format(DOSE["iron"], DOSE["zinc"]))
    print("   magnesium at {:.1f} times the calcium dose".format(MG_WITH_CA))
    print("   calcium mg   iron mg   zinc mg   iron share   zinc share")
    base_fe = absorbed("iron", DOSE["iron"], {"zinc": DOSE["zinc"]})
    base_zn = absorbed("zinc", DOSE["zinc"], {"iron": DOSE["iron"]})
    for ca in SWEEP:
        comp_fe = {"zinc": DOSE["zinc"], "calcium": ca,
                   "magnesium": ca * MG_WITH_CA}
        comp_zn = {"iron": DOSE["iron"], "calcium": ca,
                   "magnesium": ca * MG_WITH_CA}
        fe = absorbed("iron", DOSE["iron"], comp_fe)
        zn = absorbed("zinc", DOSE["zinc"], comp_zn)
        print("   {:<13.0f}{:<10.4f}{:<10.4f}{:<13.4f}{:.4f}"
              .format(ca, fe, zn, fe / base_fe, zn / base_zn))
    print("   iron absorbed with no calcium or magnesium: {:.4f} mg"
          .format(base_fe))
    print("   zinc absorbed with no calcium or magnesium: {:.4f} mg"
          .format(base_zn))
    worst = 0.0
    for name, base, dose, other in (("iron", base_fe, DOSE["iron"], "zinc"),
                                    ("zinc", base_zn, DOSE["zinc"], "iron")):
        lo, hi = 0.0, 5000.0
        for _ in range(60):
            mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
            comp = {other: DOSE[other], "calcium": mid,
                    "magnesium": mid * MG_WITH_CA}
            if absorbed(name, dose, comp) > 0.5 * base:
                lo = mid
            else:
                hi = mid
        worst = max(worst, abs(0.5 * (lo + hi)))
        print("   calcium dose that halves {} absorption: {:.1f} mg"
              .format(name, 0.5 * (lo + hi)))
    print("   the two doses agree, as the algebra above requires")
    comp = {"zinc": DOSE["zinc"], "calcium": 500.0,
            "magnesium": 400.0}
    print("   at calcium 500 mg and magnesium 400 mg, the usual evening")
    print("   handful, iron keeps {:.4f} of what it would have absorbed"
          .format(absorbed("iron", DOSE["iron"], comp) / base_fe))
    print("   and the absorbed iron falls from {:.4f} to {:.4f} mg"
          .format(base_fe, absorbed("iron", DOSE["iron"], comp)))
#    iron 18 mg and zinc 25 mg held; calcium swept, with
#    magnesium at 0.8 times the calcium dose
#    calcium mg   iron mg   zinc mg   iron share   zinc share
#    0            1.7225    2.1866    1.0000       1.0000
#    100          1.4667    1.8618    0.8515       0.8515
#    200          1.2770    1.6211    0.7414       0.7414
#    300          1.1308    1.4354    0.6565       0.6565
#    500          0.9200    1.1679    0.5341       0.5341
#    700          0.7755    0.9845    0.4502       0.4502
#    1000         0.6276    0.7968    0.3644       0.3644
#    iron absorbed with no calcium or magnesium: 1.7225 mg
#    zinc absorbed with no calcium or magnesium: 2.1866 mg
#    calcium dose that halves iron absorption: 573.3 mg
#    calcium dose that halves zinc absorption: 573.3 mg
#    the two doses agree, as the algebra above requires
#    at calcium 500 mg and magnesium 400 mg, the usual evening
#    handful, iron keeps 0.5341 of what it would have absorbed
#    and the absorbed iron falls from 1.7225 to 0.9200 mg

右边那两列完全相同,而程序开头的注释解释了原因:把米氏表达式的分母除以该项自身的亲和常数之后,剩下的是一加上该位点上每一项「剂量除以自身常数」之和,而这个数对每个占位者都是同一个。因此,当多个既有占位者同时在场、共用同一个载体时,一个新的竞争者把它们每一个的吸收都乘以完全相同的因子,无论它们各自的剂量是多少。使铁吸收减半的钙剂量与使锌吸收减半的钙剂量同为 573.3 毫克。

这是一件值得知道的事,也是一件容易被过度解读的事。它说的是共享载体并不偏心,而不是说后果不偏心。在通常的夜间钙与镁剂量下,吸收的铁从 1.7225 毫克落到 0.9200 毫克,保住了它本应有的 0.5341。而把一种谁都不缺的矿物质的吸收减半,减掉的是没人会注意的东西。算术是对称的,临床的分量不是。

吸收的铁与锌对钙剂量,图中标出减半点(p03)。

根本到不了载体的那一部分

第二类损耗发生得更早,在肠腔里,与争夺载体毫无关系。一种矿物质可以被与它同食的东西结合掉,或者它所需要的化学条件根本不在。Hurrell、Reddy 与 Cook 测量了茶、咖啡及其他含多酚饮料对非血红素铁吸收的抑制,发现在普通份量下效应已大到值得在意 (Hurrell et al. 1999)。Lonnerdal 的综述把植酸与锌的摩尔比当作锌的组织性变量,这就是程序计算那个比值而不是植酸质量的原因 (Lonnerdal 2000)。

推导

# Chapter 2. p04: Losses that happen before the carrier is reached. Some
# of a dose never arrives at a transporter at all, because it has been
# bound in the gut lumen or because the chemistry it needs has been
# removed. Three such losses are costed here: phytate binding of zinc,
# read off the molar ratio of phytate to zinc that the nutrition
# literature uses; polyphenol binding of non-haem iron, as happens when
# a mineral is taken with tea or coffee; and the loss of iron solubility
# when an antacid or a large carbonate dose raises the stomach's pH.
# The multipliers are illustrative fits to the published shapes.
ZN_MASS, FE_MASS, PHYTATE_MASS = 65.38, 55.85, 660.0
ZN_DOSE, FE_DOSE = 25.0, 18.0
MEALS = (
    # name, phytate mg, polyphenol mg, stomach pH
    ("water, empty stomach",       0.0,    0.0, 1.6),
    ("eggs and spinach",         180.0,   40.0, 1.8),
    ("oat porridge",             900.0,   30.0, 2.0),
    ("wholemeal bread and tea", 1100.0,  320.0, 2.1),
    ("with a proton pump pill",    0.0,    0.0, 5.0),
    ("carbonate antacid too",      0.0,    0.0, 6.2),
)
PH_HALF, PH_HILL = 3.4, 2.4        # iron solubility against pH

def zinc_factor(phytate_mg):
    ratio = (phytate_mg / PHYTATE_MASS) / (ZN_DOSE / ZN_MASS)
    return 1.0 / (1.0 + 0.55 * ratio)

def polyphenol_factor(mg):
    return 1.0 / (1.0 + mg / 120.0)

def ph_factor(ph):
    return 1.0 / (1.0 + (ph / PH_HALF) ** PH_HILL)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   setting                   phytate  zinc    iron    iron")
    print("   ratio to zinc             factor   polyph  pH      total")
    rows = []
    for name, phy, pol, ph in MEALS:
        ratio = (phy / PHYTATE_MASS) / (ZN_DOSE / ZN_MASS)
        zf = zinc_factor(phy)
        pf = polyphenol_factor(pol)
        hf = ph_factor(ph)
        rows.append((name, ratio, zf, pf, hf, pf * hf))
        print("   {:<26}{:<9.3f}{:<8.4f}{:<8.4f}{:<8.4f}"
              .format(name, ratio, zf, pf, hf))
    print("   iron surviving both the polyphenol and the pH loss:")
    for name, ratio, zf, pf, hf, tot in rows:
        print("   {:<26}{:.4f}".format(name, tot))
    best = max(rows, key=lambda r: r[5])
    worst = min(rows, key=lambda r: r[5])
    print("   best setting for iron: {} at {:.4f}".format(best[0], best[5]))
    print("   worst: {} at {:.4f}".format(worst[0], worst[5]))
    print("   ratio between them: {:.2f}".format(best[5] / worst[5]))
    print("   zinc: best {:.4f}, worst {:.4f}, ratio {:.2f}"
          .format(max(r[2] for r in rows), min(r[2] for r in rows),
                  max(r[2] for r in rows) / min(r[2] for r in rows)))
    print("   milligrams of iron reaching the carrier from an {:.0f} mg"
          " dose:".format(FE_DOSE))
    for name, ratio, zf, pf, hf, tot in rows:
        print("   {:<26}{:.4f}".format(name, FE_DOSE * tot))
    print("   the pH term alone costs {:.4f} of the dose on a proton"
          " pump pill".format(1.0 - ph_factor(5.0) / ph_factor(1.6)))
    lo, hi = 1.0, 8.0
    for _ in range(60):
        mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
        if ph_factor(mid) / ph_factor(1.6) > 0.5:
            lo = mid
        else:
            hi = mid
    print("   stomach pH at which iron solubility halves: {:.3f}"
          .format(0.5 * (lo + hi)))
#    setting                   phytate  zinc    iron    iron
#    ratio to zinc             factor   polyph  pH      total
#    water, empty stomach      0.000    1.0000  1.0000  0.8592
#    eggs and spinach          0.713    0.7182  0.7500  0.8215
#    oat porridge              3.566    0.3377  0.8000  0.7813
#    wholemeal bread and tea   4.359    0.2944  0.2727  0.7607
#    with a proton pump pill   0.000    1.0000  1.0000  0.2838
#    carbonate antacid too     0.000    1.0000  1.0000  0.1913
#    iron surviving both the polyphenol and the pH loss:
#    water, empty stomach      0.8592
#    eggs and spinach          0.6161
#    oat porridge              0.6251
#    wholemeal bread and tea   0.2075
#    with a proton pump pill   0.2838
#    carbonate antacid too     0.1913
#    best setting for iron: water, empty stomach at 0.8592
#    worst: carbonate antacid too at 0.1913
#    ratio between them: 4.49
#    zinc: best 1.0000, worst 0.2944, ratio 3.40
#    milligrams of iron reaching the carrier from an 18 mg dose:
#    water, empty stomach      15.4665
#    eggs and spinach          11.0899
#    oat porridge              11.2513
#    wholemeal bread and tea   3.7342
#    with a proton pump pill   5.1088
#    carbonate antacid too     3.4426
#    the pH term alone costs 0.6697 of the dose on a proton pump pill
#    stomach pH at which iron solubility halves: 3.826

有三种情境值得注意。全麦面包配茶给出 4.359 的植酸锌摩尔比,使锌留在 0.2944,而多酚那一项使铁留在 0.2727,于是铁的存活率为 0.2075,一份 18 毫克的剂量里只有 3.7342 毫克到达载体。一粒质子泵抑制剂根本没有改变任何食物,却仅凭酸度这一项就让铁损失 0.6697;再加上一剂碳酸盐抗酸药,铁的存活率为 0.1913。在表中最好与最差的情境之间,铁相差 4.49 倍,锌相差 3.40 倍。铁溶解度减半处的 pH 是 3.826,而这正落在一种抑酸药物日常所造成的范围之内。

注

为什么这一节比载体那一节更要紧。 本节的损耗比第一章的竞争损耗更大,而且更容易修,因为它们取决于胃里还有什么以及在什么时候,而不取决于每种矿物质买了多少。一个长期抑酸又在补铁的人,每天都处在这张表最差的那一格,而对铁剂量的任何调整都不解决这件事。这是要和医生谈的话题,不是要靠排程解决的话题。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 对一个在抑酸的人来说,腔内损耗主导一切载体层面的相互作用,所以只要抑酸在继续,把他的矿物质剂量在时间上分开就不会产生可测量的好处。什么会证明它错: 在一项对服用质子泵抑制剂者的交叉研究里,如果在时间上分开矿物质所提高的吸收铁量,与在未服该药者身上一样多,那么腔内那一项就不是主导的。

小结

共享载体对它的占位者一视同仁:一个新的竞争者把每个既有占位者的吸收乘以同一个因子,所以使铁减半与使锌减半的钙剂量同为 573.3 毫克,而在通常的夜间剂量下铁保住 0.5341。载体之前的损耗更大:面包配茶时铁的存活率为 0.2075,加抗酸药时为 0.1913,服抑酸药物时仅酸度一项就花掉 0.6697,而溶解度在 pH 3.826 处减半。第三章把这两类损耗相乘。

参考文献

Gunshin, Hiromi, Bryan Mackenzie, Urs V. Berger, et al. 1997. “Cloning and Characterization of a Mammalian Proton-Coupled Metal-Ion Transporter.” Nature 388 (6641): 482 to 488.
Hallberg, Leif, Mats Brune, Monica Erlandsson, Ann-Sofie Sandberg, and Lena Rossander-Hulthen. 1991. “Calcium: Effect of Different Amounts on Nonheme- and Heme-Iron Absorption in Humans.” The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 53 (1): 112 to 119.
Hurrell, Richard F., Manju Reddy, and James D. Cook. 1999. “Inhibition of Non-Haem Iron Absorption in Man by Polyphenolic-Containing Beverages.” British Journal of Nutrition 81 (4): 289 to 295.
Lonnerdal, Bo. 2000. “Dietary Factors Influencing Zinc Absorption.” The Journal of Nutrition 130 (5): 1378S to 1383S.

Fan, Y. (2026). Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition: Michaelis-Menten Inhibition Matrices, Chelation Absorption Losses and Circadian Receptor Sensitivity [复合补剂相互作用、时间疗法给药窗口与代谢酶竞争] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090250 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).