5D Library › Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition · 中文

Chapter 4. When the Receptor Is Listening

Why the hour can matter at all

The clock can change an outcome in two ways. It can change how much of a substance reaches the blood, which the previous chapters covered, and it can change how much the body responds to a given amount, which is a different question with a different literature. Smolensky and Peppas review the field, and the mechanism is the same everywhere: a receptor’s density, a transcription programme’s availability or an organ’s own rhythm varies through the day, so a constant concentration does not produce a constant effect (Smolensky and Peppas 2007). Czeisler and colleagues established how precise and how nearly twenty-four-hour the human pacemaker is, which is what makes the timing reproducible enough to plan around (Czeisler et al. 1999). Lewy and colleagues mapped the phase-response curve for melatonin, which is the reason an evening dose and a morning dose of the same hormone move the clock in opposite directions (Lewy et al. 1992).

The clinical stakes are not hypothetical. Hermida and colleagues randomised the time of day at which blood pressure medicines were taken and reported a difference in cardiovascular outcomes, which is the strongest kind of claim chronotherapy has produced (Hermida et al. 2010).

Evidence

Published. Smolensky and Peppas review chronobiology and chronotherapeutics and the mechanisms by which time of administration changes effect (Smolensky and Peppas 2007). Czeisler and colleagues measured the stability and period of the human circadian pacemaker (Czeisler et al. 1999). Lewy and colleagues established the phase-response curve for melatonin administration (Lewy et al. 1992). Hermida and colleagues randomised dosing time for antihypertensive treatment and reported a difference in cardiovascular risk (Hermida et al. 2010).

Note

What this chapter is not. The curves below are illustrative shapes for cortisol and melatonin and an illustrative sensitivity model, not measurements. The purpose is to find out how much the hour can matter in principle and how wide the useful window is, which are structural questions. No reader should infer a dosing time for a medicine from this chapter; the chronotherapy literature for an actual medicine is specific to that medicine.

Calculation

# Chapter 4. p07: When the receptor is listening. Two things vary across
# the day: the concentration a dose produces, which depends only on when
# it was swallowed, and the sensitivity of what it acts on, which does
# not. The effect of a dose is the integral of the product. Cortisol
# rises before waking and peaks in the morning, and the transcriptional
# window that mitochondrial cofactors act in follows it; melatonin rises
# in the late evening, and the inhibitory tone that a calming agent adds
# to follows that. The plasma curve is a one-compartment absorption and
# elimination model with the times below. The day wraps around, so a
# dose late at night is credited with its effect after midnight.
TMAX, HALFLIFE = 1.5, 4.0          # hours
STEP = 1.0 / 60.0                  # one minute
E = 2.718281828459045

def plasma(dt):
    # dt is hours since the dose; a difference of two exponentials
    if dt < 0.0:
        return 0.0
    ka = 2.0 / TMAX
    ke = 0.6931471805599453 / HALFLIFE
    return (E ** (-ke * dt) - E ** (-ka * dt)) * ka / (ka - ke)

def cortisol(t):
    # peak near the eighth hour, trough in the late evening
    x = (t - 8.0) % 24.0
    if x > 12.0:
        x -= 24.0
    return 0.12 + 0.88 * E ** (-(x / 3.6) ** 2)

def melatonin(t):
    x = (t - 3.0) % 24.0
    if x > 12.0:
        x -= 24.0
    return 0.04 + 0.96 * E ** (-(x / 3.2) ** 2)

SENS = {"morning cofactor": cortisol, "evening calmer": melatonin}

def effect(hour, which):
    f = SENS[which]
    total = 0.0
    n = int(round(48.0 / STEP))
    for i in range(n):
        t = i * STEP
        total += plasma(t) * f((hour + t) % 24.0)
    return total * STEP

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   hour   morning cofactor   evening calmer")
    best = {k: (-1.0, None) for k in SENS}
    worst = {k: (1e9, None) for k in SENS}
    for h in range(24):
        row = []
        for k in ("morning cofactor", "evening calmer"):
            v = effect(float(h), k)
            row.append(v)
            if v > best[k][0]:
                best[k] = (v, h)
            if v < worst[k][0]:
                worst[k] = (v, h)
        print("   {:<7d}{:<19.4f}{:.4f}".format(h, row[0], row[1]))
    for k in ("morning cofactor", "evening calmer"):
        b, hb = best[k]
        w, hw = worst[k]
        print("   {}: best hour {}, worst hour {}".format(k, hb, hw))
        print("      effect {:.4f} against {:.4f}, a ratio of {:.2f}"
              .format(b, w, b / w))
        print("      dosing at the worst hour loses {:.4f}"
              .format(1.0 - w / b))
    gap = (best["evening calmer"][1] - best["morning cofactor"][1]) % 24
    print("   hours forward from the first best time to the second: {}"
          .format(gap))
    print("   as a phase angle: {:.1f} degrees".format(360.0 * gap / 24.0))
    print("   the shorter way round is {} hours".format(min(gap, 24 - gap)))
    print("   best hour inside waking hours 6 to 22, and what it costs:")
    for k in ("morning cofactor", "evening calmer"):
        hw = max(range(6, 23), key=lambda h: effect(float(h), k))
        v = effect(float(hw), k)
        print("   {:<20}hour {:<4d}effect {:.4f}, loss {:.4f}"
              .format(k, hw, v, 1.0 - v / best[k][0]))
    both = max(range(24), key=lambda h: effect(float(h), "morning cofactor")
               + effect(float(h), "evening calmer"))
    s_both = (effect(float(both), "morning cofactor")
              + effect(float(both), "evening calmer"))
    s_split = best["morning cofactor"][0] + best["evening calmer"][0]
    print("   best single hour for both at once: {}".format(both))
    print("   its total effect {:.4f} against {:.4f} when split"
          .format(s_both, s_split))
    print("   so taking both together costs {:.4f}"
          .format(1.0 - s_both / s_split))
#    hour   morning cofactor   evening calmer
#    0      2.4732             3.1151
#    1      2.7710             2.9183
#    2      3.0740             2.4915
#    3      3.3398             1.9291
#    4      3.5073             1.3725
#    5      3.5124             0.9384
#    6      3.3170             0.6710
#    7      2.9364             0.5481
#    8      2.4438             0.5202
#    9      1.9437             0.5437
#    10     1.5277             0.5938
#    11     1.2426             0.6602
#    12     1.0868             0.7410
#    13     1.0298             0.8375
#    14     1.0362             0.9522
#    15     1.0796             1.0887
#    16     1.1459             1.2509
#    17     1.2297             1.4432
#    18     1.3309             1.6705
#    19     1.4516             1.9357
#    20     1.5951             2.2367
#    21     1.7655             2.5580
#    22     1.9668             2.8603
#    23     2.2026             3.0746
#    morning cofactor: best hour 5, worst hour 13
#       effect 3.5124 against 1.0298, a ratio of 3.41
#       dosing at the worst hour loses 0.7068
#    evening calmer: best hour 0, worst hour 8
#       effect 3.1151 against 0.5202, a ratio of 5.99
#       dosing at the worst hour loses 0.8330
#    hours forward from the first best time to the second: 19
#    as a phase angle: 285.0 degrees
#    the shorter way round is 5 hours
#    best hour inside waking hours 6 to 22, and what it costs:
#    morning cofactor    hour 6   effect 3.3170, loss 0.0556
#    evening calmer      hour 22  effect 2.8603, loss 0.0818
#    best single hour for both at once: 1
#    its total effect 5.6893 against 6.6275 when split
#    so taking both together costs 0.1416

The effect of a dose is the integral over the day of the concentration it produces multiplied by the sensitivity of what it acts on. Computed hour by hour, the morning cofactor peaks when dosed at hour 5, reaching 3.5124 against 1.0298 at its worst hour, a ratio of 3.41, so dosing at the worst hour loses 0.7068. The evening calmer peaks when dosed at hour 0, at 3.1151 against 0.5202, a ratio of 5.99 and a loss of 0.8330 at the worst hour. These are large numbers for an intervention that costs nothing.

The best hours, however, are 5 in the morning and midnight, and the honest observation is that nobody is awake for the first and few are sensible at the second. Restricted to waking hours, the best times become hour 6 and hour 22, which cost only 0.0556 and 0.0818 against the unconstrained optimum. The practical loss from being a human being with a job is under a tenth, which is the useful finding.

The effect of a dose against the hour at which it is taken, for both classes (p07).

How wide is the window

An optimum located to the hour is not actionable if the curve around it is sharp, and is barely worth computing if the curve is flat. p08 puts the same model on a one-minute grid and measures the width.

Calculation

# Chapter 4. p08: The optimal phase, and how wide the window is. The
# same two sensitivity curves and the same plasma curve as p07, now on a
# one-minute grid, so the best moment is located to the minute rather
# than to the hour. What matters in practice is not the peak but the
# width of the window around it inside which little is lost, because a
# schedule nobody can keep is worth nothing. Two widths are reported:
# the window that costs less than one part in twenty, and the one that
# costs less than one part in ten.
TMAX, HALFLIFE = 1.5, 4.0
STEP = 1.0 / 60.0
E = 2.718281828459045
TOL = (0.05, 0.10)

def plasma(dt):
    if dt < 0.0:
        return 0.0
    ka = 2.0 / TMAX
    ke = 0.6931471805599453 / HALFLIFE
    return (E ** (-ke * dt) - E ** (-ka * dt)) * ka / (ka - ke)

def cortisol(t):
    x = (t - 8.0) % 24.0
    if x > 12.0:
        x -= 24.0
    return 0.12 + 0.88 * E ** (-(x / 3.6) ** 2)

def melatonin(t):
    x = (t - 3.0) % 24.0
    if x > 12.0:
        x -= 24.0
    return 0.04 + 0.96 * E ** (-(x / 3.2) ** 2)

SENS = (("morning cofactor", cortisol), ("evening calmer", melatonin))
GRID = 24 * 60

def curve(f):
    n = int(round(48.0 / STEP))
    weights = [plasma(i * STEP) for i in range(n)]
    out = []
    for m in range(GRID):
        hour = m / 60.0
        total = 0.0
        for i in range(n):
            total += weights[i] * f((hour + i * STEP) % 24.0)
        out.append(total * STEP)
    return out

def clock(minutes):
    return "{:02d}:{:02d}".format(int(minutes) // 60, int(minutes) % 60)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    peaks = {}
    for name, f in SENS:
        c = curve(f)
        best = max(range(GRID), key=lambda m: c[m])
        peaks[name] = (best, c[best], c)
        print("   {}: best moment {}, effect {:.4f}"
              .format(name, clock(best), c[best]))
        for tol in TOL:
            thr = c[best] * (1.0 - tol)
            lo = best
            while c[(lo - 1) % GRID] >= thr:
                lo = (lo - 1) % GRID
            hi = best
            while c[(hi + 1) % GRID] >= thr:
                hi = (hi + 1) % GRID
            width = ((hi - lo) % GRID) / 60.0
            print("      within {:.2f} of the peak: {} to {}, {:.2f} hours"
                  .format(tol, clock(lo), clock(hi), width))
    a, b = peaks["morning cofactor"], peaks["evening calmer"]
    gap = ((b[0] - a[0]) % GRID) / 60.0
    print("   phase difference: {:.2f} hours, {:.1f} degrees"
          .format(gap, 360.0 * gap / 24.0))
    print("   cost of an error, as a share of the peak effect:")
    print("   error h   morning cofactor   evening calmer")
    for err in (0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 6.0, 12.0):
        row = []
        for name, _ in SENS:
            m0, peak, c = peaks[name]
            k = int(round(err * 60.0))
            late = c[(m0 + k) % GRID]
            early = c[(m0 - k) % GRID]
            row.append(1.0 - min(late, early) / peak)
        print("   {:<10.1f}{:<19.4f}{:.4f}".format(err, row[0], row[1]))
    print("   a six-hour error costs {:.4f} on the cofactor and {:.4f}"
          .format(1.0 - min(peaks["morning cofactor"][2][
              (peaks["morning cofactor"][0] + 360) % GRID],
              peaks["morning cofactor"][2][
                  (peaks["morning cofactor"][0] - 360) % GRID])
              / peaks["morning cofactor"][1],
              1.0 - min(peaks["evening calmer"][2][
                  (peaks["evening calmer"][0] + 360) % GRID],
                  peaks["evening calmer"][2][
                      (peaks["evening calmer"][0] - 360) % GRID])
              / peaks["evening calmer"][1]))
    print("   on the calmer, which is the price of one schedule slip")
#    morning cofactor: best moment 04:32, effect 3.5337
#       within 0.05 of the peak: 03:05 to 05:51, 2.77 hours
#       within 0.10 of the peak: 02:23 to 06:24, 4.02 hours
#    evening calmer: best moment 23:42, effect 3.1259
#       within 0.05 of the peak: 22:27 to 00:49, 2.37 hours
#       within 0.10 of the peak: 21:50 to 01:17, 3.45 hours
#    phase difference: 19.17 hours, 287.5 degrees
#    cost of an error, as a share of the peak effect:
#    error h   morning cofactor   evening calmer
#    0.5       0.0069             0.0097
#    1.0       0.0283             0.0391
#    2.0       0.1132             0.1556
#    3.0       0.2412             0.3270
#    6.0       0.6156             0.7652
#    12.0      0.6637             0.7712
#    a six-hour error costs 0.6156 on the cofactor and 0.7652
#    on the calmer, which is the price of one schedule slip

The best moment is 04:32 for the morning cofactor and 23:42 for the evening calmer, and the phase difference between them is 19.17 hours, or 287.5 degrees. The window inside which less than one part in twenty is lost is 2.77 hours wide for the cofactor, from 03:05 to 05:51, and 2.37 hours for the calmer, from 22:27 to 00:49. Widening the tolerance to one part in ten gives 4.02 and 3.45 hours.

The error table is the part to remember. Half an hour costs 0.0069 and 0.0097, an hour costs 0.0283 and 0.0391, two hours cost 0.1132 and 0.1556, and six hours cost 0.6156 and 0.7652. Being an hour late is almost free; being six hours late throws most of the dose away. Since a six-hour error is exactly what happens when an evening dose is taken at lunch because it was forgotten the night before, the rule that follows is to skip rather than to shift.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): for agents whose sensitivity varies across the day, a missed dose taken more than three hours off schedule delivers less than skipping it and taking the next one on time, so dosing instructions should say skip rather than take as soon as remembered. What would show it wrong: if, for a given agent, a pharmacodynamic endpoint measured after a deliberately shifted dose were no worse than after a skipped one, the skip rule would be unnecessary for that agent.

Summary

Dosing at the worst hour rather than the best costs 0.7068 for the morning class and 0.8330 for the evening class, but confining the choice to waking hours costs only 0.0556 and 0.0818. The optima are 04:32 and 23:42, a phase difference of 19.17 hours or 287.5 degrees, and the windows that cost under one part in twenty are 2.77 and 2.37 hours wide. A one-hour error costs under 0.04, and a six-hour error costs 0.6156 and 0.7652. Chapter 5 turns to the liver, where the clock and the interactions meet.

References

Czeisler, Charles A., Jeanne F. Duffy, Theresa L. Shanahan, et al. 1999. “Stability, Precision, and near-24-Hour Period of the Human Circadian Pacemaker.” Science 284 (5423): 2177 to 2181.
Hermida, Ramon C., Diana E. Ayala, Artemio Mojon, and Jose R. Fernandez. 2010. “Influence of Circadian Time of Hypertension Treatment on Cardiovascular Risk: Results of the MAPEC Study.” Chronobiology International 27 (8): 1629 to 1651.
Lewy, Alfred J., Saeeduddin Ahmed, Jeanne M. Jackson, and Robert L. Sack. 1992. “Melatonin Shifts Human Circadian Rhythms According to a Phase-Response Curve.” Chronobiology International 9 (5): 380 to 392.
Smolensky, Michael H., and Nicholas A. Peppas. 2007. “Chronobiology, Drug Delivery, and Chronotherapeutics.” Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews 59 (9 to 10): 828 to 851.

Fan, Y. (2026). Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition: Michaelis-Menten Inhibition Matrices, Chelation Absorption Losses and Circadian Receptor Sensitivity [复合补剂相互作用、时间疗法给药窗口与代谢酶竞争] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090250 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).