5D Library › Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition · 中文

Chapter 3. The Handful

Two losses, multiplied

The two previous chapters measured two independent things: how much an item loses to competitors at its own route, and how much it loses to the condition of the gut when it arrives. They multiply, because an item that is both outcompeted and badly timed suffers both. The practice of swallowing everything at one moment guarantees that at most one of the conditions in the cupboard can be the right one, since iron wants an empty acid stomach, the fat-soluble vitamins want fat, and zinc wants an absence of phytate.

One pair runs the other way. Shoba and colleagues gave curcumin with and without piperine to volunteers and measured a large rise in curcumin’s plasma concentration when the two were taken together, which is the only interaction in this cupboard that argues for combining rather than separating (Shoba et al. 1998). The enhancement used in the programs is deliberately far smaller than the figure that paper reports, so that the conclusion does not rest on the most favourable reading of one study. This chapter first counts competition at the shared site and the state of the gut on their own: p05 leaves the piperine enhancement out, and Chapter 6 adds it back as a separate enhancement term when p11 builds the schedule.

Evidence

Published. Shoba and colleagues reported a large increase in the bioavailability of curcumin when piperine was co-administered, in animals and in human volunteers (Shoba et al. 1998).

Calculation

# Chapter 3. p05: What the whole handful actually delivers. Two losses
# are multiplied for each item. The first is competition at a shared
# site, computed as in p02. The second is the condition of the gut when
# the dose arrives: a fat-soluble vitamin needs fat in the meal, iron
# needs an acid stomach and no polyphenol, zinc needs little phytate.
# Taking everything at one moment means at most one of those conditions
# can be right. The comparison is against a schedule that gives each
# item the condition it wants, which is what the rest of the book builds.
ITEMS = (
    # name, dose mg, molar mass, site, Km mmol, needs
    ("magnesium",     400.00,  24.305, "divalent",  4.0000, "plain"),
    ("zinc",           25.00,  65.380, "divalent",  0.1500, "lowphytate"),
    ("calcium",       500.00,  40.080, "divalent",  5.0000, "plain"),
    ("iron",           18.00,  55.850, "divalent",  0.0800, "acid"),
    ("vitamin D3",      0.10, 384.600, "micelle",   0.0004, "fat"),
    ("vitamin K2",      0.18, 444.700, "micelle",   0.0005, "fat"),
    ("NAD precursor", 300.00, 255.200, "nrk",       1.0000, "plain"),
    ("curcumin",      500.00, 368.400, "conjugate", 1.0000, "fat"),
    ("piperine",       10.00, 285.300, "conjugate", 0.0500, "plain"),
    ("theanine",      200.00, 174.200, "amino",     1.0000, "plain"),
    ("caffeine",      100.00, 194.200, "cyp1a2",    0.5000, "plain"),
)
# the one moment everything is taken: a coffee and a slice of toast
AT_ONCE = {"fat_g": 4.0, "phytate_mg": 900.0, "polyphenol_mg": 320.0,
           "ph": 2.1}
# what each condition looks like when the item gets its own slot
IDEAL = {"fat": {"fat_g": 18.0, "phytate_mg": 0.0, "polyphenol_mg": 0.0,
                 "ph": 2.0},
         "acid": {"fat_g": 2.0, "phytate_mg": 0.0, "polyphenol_mg": 0.0,
                  "ph": 1.6},
         "lowphytate": {"fat_g": 6.0, "phytate_mg": 60.0,
                        "polyphenol_mg": 0.0, "ph": 1.8},
         "plain": {"fat_g": 6.0, "phytate_mg": 120.0,
                   "polyphenol_mg": 40.0, "ph": 1.9}}
FAT_HALF, PHY_MASS, ZN_MASS = 9.0, 660.0, 65.38
PH_HALF, PH_HILL = 3.4, 2.4

def mmol(dose_mg, molar_mass):
    return dose_mg / molar_mass

def site_factor(i, together):
    name, dose, mm, site, km, needs = ITEMS[i]
    s = mmol(dose, mm)
    extra = 0.0
    if together:
        for j, other in enumerate(ITEMS):
            if j != i and other[3] == site:
                extra += mmol(other[1], other[2]) / other[4]
    return (s / (km * (1.0 + extra) + s)) / (s / (km + s))

def condition_factor(needs, env):
    f = 1.0
    if needs == "fat":
        f *= env["fat_g"] / (FAT_HALF + env["fat_g"]) \
            / (18.0 / (FAT_HALF + 18.0))
    if needs == "acid":
        f *= 1.0 / (1.0 + env["polyphenol_mg"] / 120.0)
        f *= (1.0 / (1.0 + (env["ph"] / PH_HALF) ** PH_HILL)) \
            / (1.0 / (1.0 + (1.6 / PH_HALF) ** PH_HILL))
    if needs == "lowphytate":
        ratio = (env["phytate_mg"] / PHY_MASS) / (25.0 / ZN_MASS)
        f *= 1.0 / (1.0 + 0.55 * ratio)
    return min(1.0, f)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   item           site    condition   together   separated")
    tog, sep = [], []
    for i, (name, dose, mm, site, km, needs) in enumerate(ITEMS):
        a = site_factor(i, True) * condition_factor(needs, AT_ONCE)
        b = site_factor(i, False) * condition_factor(needs, IDEAL[needs])
        tog.append(a)
        sep.append(b)
        print("   {:<15}{:<8.4f}{:<12.4f}{:<11.4f}{:.4f}"
              .format(name, site_factor(i, True),
                      condition_factor(needs, AT_ONCE), a, b))
    mean_t = sum(tog) / len(tog)
    mean_s = sum(sep) / len(sep)
    print("   mean delivered fraction, all at once: {:.4f}".format(mean_t))
    print("   mean delivered fraction, separated:   {:.4f}".format(mean_s))
    print("   loss from taking the handful at one moment: {:.4f}"
          .format(1.0 - mean_t / mean_s))
    worst = min(range(len(ITEMS)), key=lambda i: tog[i] / sep[i])
    print("   worst item: {} keeps {:.4f} of what it could"
          .format(ITEMS[worst][0], tog[worst] / sep[worst]))
    losses = sorted((1.0 - tog[i] / sep[i], ITEMS[i][0])
                    for i in range(len(ITEMS)))
    print("   item           loss from the single moment")
    for l, name in reversed(losses):
        print("   {:<15}{:.4f}".format(name, l))
    big = [l for l, _ in losses if l >= 0.35]
    print("   items losing at least 0.35: {} of {}"
          .format(len(big), len(ITEMS)))
    print("   their losses run from {:.4f} to {:.4f}"
          .format(min(big), max(big)))
#    item           site    condition   together   separated
#    magnesium      0.3605  1.0000      0.3605     1.0000
#    zinc           0.2502  0.3377      0.0845     0.8844
#    calcium        0.2463  1.0000      0.2463     1.0000
#    iron           0.3544  0.2414      0.0856     1.0000
#    vitamin D3     0.6709  0.4615      0.3096     1.0000
#    vitamin K2     0.7357  0.4615      0.3396     1.0000
#    NAD precursor  1.0000  1.0000      1.0000     1.0000
#    curcumin       0.7708  0.4615      0.3557     1.0000
#    piperine       0.5562  1.0000      0.5562     1.0000
#    theanine       1.0000  1.0000      1.0000     1.0000
#    caffeine       1.0000  1.0000      1.0000     1.0000
#    mean delivered fraction, all at once: 0.4853
#    mean delivered fraction, separated:   0.9895
#    loss from taking the handful at one moment: 0.5096
#    worst item: iron keeps 0.0856 of what it could
#    item           loss from the single moment
#    iron           0.9144
#    zinc           0.9045
#    calcium        0.7537
#    vitamin D3     0.6904
#    vitamin K2     0.6604
#    curcumin       0.6443
#    magnesium      0.6395
#    piperine       0.4438
#    theanine       0.0000
#    caffeine       0.0000
#    NAD precursor  0.0000
#    items losing at least 0.35: 8 of 11
#    their losses run from 0.4438 to 0.9144

Taken at one moment with a coffee and a slice of toast, the cupboard delivers a mean fraction of 0.4853 against 0.9895 for a schedule that gives each item what it wants, a loss of 0.5096. The losses are not spread evenly. Eight of the eleven items lose at least 0.35, and those losses run from 0.4438 to 0.9144. Iron keeps only 0.0856 of what it could deliver, and zinc loses 0.9045, since both are hit by competition and by condition at once. Three items lose nothing, because nothing shares their route and they need no particular condition.

The loss for each item from taking the whole cupboard at one moment (p05).

The figure 0.5096 is worth comparing with what is usually claimed. Advertisements for timed-release formulations and for “optimised stacks” quote losses of a third to two thirds from taking supplements together. That range is about right, which is the unusual case of a marketing claim surviving contact with the arithmetic. What does not survive is the implied remedy: the loss comes from competition and gut condition, and a capsule that releases its contents slowly does not change either one.

How much does separating actually recover

If the loss is real, the next question is what it costs to fix. Splitting a pile into groups is not free in attention, and the right question is the marginal value of each additional group rather than the value of a perfect schedule.

Calculation

# Chapter 3. p06: How much separating the handful can recover. The items
# of p05 are split into one, two or three groups. Everything inside a
# group is swallowed together, so it competes for shared sites, and the
# group is taken under one condition, chosen from the four the previous
# program defines by whichever suits that group's members best. Every
# assignment is enumerated; the first item is fixed in the first group
# and the group labels are forced into canonical order, which removes
# the relabellings without removing any genuinely different split. The
# answer is therefore the true optimum for one, two and three groups.
ITEMS = (
    ("magnesium",     400.00,  24.305, "divalent",  4.0000, "plain"),
    ("zinc",           25.00,  65.380, "divalent",  0.1500, "lowphytate"),
    ("calcium",       500.00,  40.080, "divalent",  5.0000, "plain"),
    ("iron",           18.00,  55.850, "divalent",  0.0800, "acid"),
    ("vitamin D3",      0.10, 384.600, "micelle",   0.0004, "fat"),
    ("vitamin K2",      0.18, 444.700, "micelle",   0.0005, "fat"),
    ("NAD precursor", 300.00, 255.200, "nrk",       1.0000, "plain"),
    ("curcumin",      500.00, 368.400, "conjugate", 1.0000, "fat"),
    ("piperine",       10.00, 285.300, "conjugate", 0.0500, "plain"),
    ("theanine",      200.00, 174.200, "amino",     1.0000, "plain"),
    ("caffeine",      100.00, 194.200, "cyp1a2",    0.5000, "plain"),
)
IDEAL = {"fat": (18.0, 0.0, 0.0, 2.0),
         "acid": (2.0, 0.0, 0.0, 1.6),
         "lowphytate": (6.0, 60.0, 0.0, 1.8),
         "plain": (6.0, 120.0, 40.0, 1.9)}
TYPES = tuple(sorted(IDEAL))
FAT_HALF, PHY_MASS, ZN_MASS = 9.0, 660.0, 65.38
PH_HALF, PH_HILL = 3.4, 2.4

def mmol(dose_mg, molar_mass):
    return dose_mg / molar_mass

def site_in_group(i, group):
    name, dose, mm, site, km, needs = ITEMS[i]
    s = mmol(dose, mm)
    extra = sum(mmol(ITEMS[j][1], ITEMS[j][2]) / ITEMS[j][4]
                for j in group if j != i and ITEMS[j][3] == site)
    return (s / (km * (1.0 + extra) + s)) / (s / (km + s))

def condition(needs, env):
    fat_g, phytate, polyphenol, ph = env
    f = 1.0
    if needs == "fat":
        f *= (fat_g / (FAT_HALF + fat_g)) / (18.0 / (FAT_HALF + 18.0))
    if needs == "acid":
        f *= 1.0 / (1.0 + polyphenol / 120.0)
        f *= (1.0 / (1.0 + (ph / PH_HALF) ** PH_HILL)) \
            / (1.0 / (1.0 + (1.6 / PH_HALF) ** PH_HILL))
    if needs == "lowphytate":
        ratio = (phytate / PHY_MASS) / (25.0 / ZN_MASS)
        f *= 1.0 / (1.0 + 0.55 * ratio)
    return min(1.0, f)

def score(assign, k):
    total = 0.0
    for g in range(k):
        group = [i for i, a in enumerate(assign) if a == g]
        if not group:
            continue
        site = {i: site_in_group(i, group) for i in group}
        best = None
        for ty in TYPES:
            env = IDEAL[ty]
            v = sum(site[i] * condition(ITEMS[i][5], env) for i in group)
            if best is None or v > best:
                best = v
        total += best
    return total / len(ITEMS)

def enumerate_assignments(k):
    n = len(ITEMS)
    assign = [0] * n

    def go(i, used):
        if i == n:
            yield tuple(assign)
            return
        for g in range(min(used + 1, k)):
            assign[i] = g
            yield from go(i + 1, max(used, g + 1))
    yield from go(1, 1)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   groups   best mean delivered fraction   splits tried")
    best_by_k = {}
    for k in (1, 2, 3):
        best, arg, n = -1.0, None, 0
        for a in enumerate_assignments(k):
            n += 1
            v = score(a, k)
            if v > best:
                best, arg = v, a
        best_by_k[k] = (best, arg)
        print("   {:<9d}{:<31.4f}{}".format(k, best, n))
    one = best_by_k[1][0]
    for k in (2, 3):
        v, arg = best_by_k[k]
        print("   {} groups recover {:+.4f} over one, a gain of {:.4f}"
              .format(k, v - one, v / one - 1.0))
    print("   the best three-group split:")
    v, arg = best_by_k[3]
    for g in range(3):
        group = [ITEMS[i][0] for i, a in enumerate(arg) if a == g]
        if group:
            print("   group {}:".format(g + 1))
            line = "   "
            for nm in group:
                if len(line) + len(nm) + 2 > 72:
                    print(line)
                    line = "   "
                line += "  " + nm
            print(line)
    print("   mean delivered fraction with three groups: {:.4f}".format(v))
    print("   remaining shortfall against a perfect schedule: {:.4f}"
          .format(1.0 - v))
    print("   the gain from the second group is {:.4f} and from the"
          .format(best_by_k[2][0] - one))
    print("   third only {:.4f}, so most of the money is in the first"
          .format(best_by_k[3][0] - best_by_k[2][0]))
    print("   split, which is the practical conclusion")
#    groups   best mean delivered fraction   splits tried
#    1        0.6284                         1
#    2        0.8386                         1024
#    3        0.9241                         29525
#    2 groups recover +0.2102 over one, a gain of 0.3345
#    3 groups recover +0.2957 over one, a gain of 0.4705
#    the best three-group split:
#    group 1:
#      magnesium  vitamin D3  NAD precursor  curcumin  theanine  caffeine
#    group 2:
#      zinc  calcium  vitamin K2  piperine
#    group 3:
#      iron
#    mean delivered fraction with three groups: 0.9241
#    remaining shortfall against a perfect schedule: 0.0759
#    the gain from the second group is 0.2102 and from the
#    third only 0.0855, so most of the money is in the first
#    split, which is the practical conclusion

Taking everything together but choosing the single best condition for the whole pile already scores 0.6284, which is above the 0.4853 of p05 because p05 fixed the condition at a coffee and toast rather than letting it be chosen. Two groups reach 0.8386 and three reach 0.9241. The gain from the second group is 0.2102 and the gain from the third only 0.0855, and the remaining shortfall against a perfect schedule is 0.0759.

That is the practical conclusion of this chapter, and it is a conclusion about attention rather than about biochemistry. The first split is worth two and a half times the second, so a reader who will reliably do one thing should split the pile once, putting iron and the bulk minerals on opposite sides of the day, and stop there. The third group buys less than a tenth and introduces the slot that Chapter 8 shows people miss.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): the marginal value of each additional dosing group falls faster than adherence does, so for almost every real cupboard the two-group schedule maximises delivered nutrient and the three-group schedule does not, despite scoring higher on paper. What would show it wrong: in a trial measuring both adherence and a nutrient status marker, if a three-group schedule produced higher measured status than a two-group one over three months, the paper ranking would be the right one after all.

Summary

Competition and gut condition multiply, so taking the cupboard at one moment loses 0.5096 against a schedule that suits each item, with eight of eleven items losing at least 0.35 and iron keeping only 0.0856. Splitting into two groups recovers 0.2102 and a third group only 0.0855, leaving a shortfall of 0.0759. Chapter 4 asks what else the clock buys, beyond keeping items out of each other’s way.

References

Shoba, Guido, David Joy, Thangam Joseph, Muhammed Majeed, Rajagopalan Rajendran, and P. S. S. R. Srinivas. 1998. “Influence of Piperine on the Pharmacokinetics of Curcumin in Animals and Human Volunteers.” Planta Medica 64 (4): 353 to 356.

Fan, Y. (2026). Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition: Michaelis-Menten Inhibition Matrices, Chelation Absorption Losses and Circadian Receptor Sensitivity [复合补剂相互作用、时间疗法给药窗口与代谢酶竞争] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090250 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).