5D Library › 关系断裂生存分析、断联期记忆衰减与复联博弈窗口 · English

第五章 复合能维持多久

两种复合

分开又复合、有时不止一次的伴侣很常见;关于这类分分合合关系的研究报告说,它们的满意度低于从未分开的关系,不确定感也更多 (Dailey et al. 2009)。流行的结论是复合注定失败。一个简单的混合模型说明这个结论下得太快。设复合的伴侣属于两种之一:一种已经处理了分手的原因,每月再次分手的机会很小(0.01);另一种没有处理,机会很大(0.08)。

推导

# Chapter 5. p09: How long do reunions last? A reunited couple is one
# of two kinds: the cause of the rupture was dealt with (share q;
# monthly hazard of a new rupture 0.01) or it was not (monthly hazard
# 0.08). The survival curve of all reunions is the mixture
#   S(t) = q exp(-0.01 t) + (1 - q) exp(-0.08 t),
# and the hazard among couples still together falls over time because
# the unresolved couples leave first. Months 12, 24 and 36.
from math import exp

H_FIX, H_NOT = 0.01, 0.08

def surv(q, t):
    return q * exp(-H_FIX * t) + (1 - q) * exp(-H_NOT * t)

def hazard(q, t):
    a, b = q * exp(-H_FIX * t), (1 - q) * exp(-H_NOT * t)
    return (a * H_FIX + b * H_NOT) / (a + b)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   share resolved q   together at 12   at 24   at 36"
          "   hazard m1   m36")
    for q in (0.2, 0.4, 0.6):
        print("   {:16.1f}   {:14.3f}   {:5.3f}   {:5.3f}   {:9.4f}"
              "   {:5.4f}".format(q, surv(q, 12), surv(q, 24), surv(q, 36),
                                  hazard(q, 1), hazard(q, 36)))
    q = 0.4
    print("   q = 0.4: share of couples together at 36 months who had")
    a = q * exp(-H_FIX * 36)
    print("   resolved the cause: {:.3f}".format(a / surv(q, 36)))
#    share resolved q   together at 12   at 24   at 36   hazard m1   m36
#                 0.2            0.484   0.275   0.184      0.0652   0.0270
#                 0.4            0.585   0.403   0.313      0.0508   0.0175
#                 0.6            0.685   0.531   0.441      0.0368   0.0136
#    q = 0.4: share of couples together at 36 months who had
#    resolved the cause: 0.892

如果五对复合里有一对处理了原因,一年后仍在一起的是 0.484,三年后 0.184。如果五对里有两对,数字是 0.585 与 0.313;三对时是 0.685 与 0.441。仍在一起的伴侣中,风险率随时间下降:五对里有两对处理了原因时,从第一个月的 0.0508 降到第 36 个月的 0.0175,因为没有处理的伴侣先离开。到第三年,仍在一起的伴侣中有 0.892 是处理了原因的那些。平均的复合看起来很脆弱;维持下来的复合大多是同一种。

按处理了分手原因的比例,复合伴侣仍在一起的比例(p09)。

以前的分合说明什么

一对伴侣自己的历史,就是他们属于哪一种的证据。p10 把以前每一次一年内又结束的复合当作一次观察,用贝叶斯法则更新「已处理」的比例。

推导

# Chapter 5. p10: What earlier break-ups say. Use the two kinds of
# p09 (resolved: monthly re-rupture hazard 0.01; not: 0.08) and a prior
# share 0.4 resolved. If a couple has already broken up and reunited k
# times, each earlier reunion that ended within 12 months is evidence:
# chance of that under "resolved" is 1 - exp(-0.12) and under "not"
# 1 - exp(-0.96). Posterior share resolved, and the chance of lasting
# three more years, after k such cycles.
from math import exp

P_RES, P_NOT = 1 - exp(-0.12), 1 - exp(-0.96)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   earlier quick cycles k   P(resolved)   P(together 36 months)")
    for k in range(5):
        a, b = 0.4 * P_RES ** k, 0.6 * P_NOT ** k
        q = a / (a + b)
        s = q * exp(-0.36) + (1 - q) * exp(-2.88)
        print("   {:22d}   {:11.3f}   {:21.3f}".format(k, q, s))
    print("   likelihood ratio per cycle: {:.2f}".format(P_NOT / P_RES))
#    earlier quick cycles k   P(resolved)   P(together 36 months)
#                         0         0.400                   0.313
#                         1         0.109                   0.126
#                         2         0.022                   0.070
#                         3         0.004                   0.059
#                         4         0.001                   0.057
#    likelihood ratio per cycle: 5.46

每一次很快重演的分合,对没有处理的伴侣发生的可能是已处理伴侣的 5.46 倍。经历一次之后,这对伴侣已经处理原因的机会从 0.400 降到 0.109,再维持三年的机会从 0.313 降到 0.126;两次之后是 0.022 与 0.070,四次之后是 0.001 与 0.057。反复出现的模式是原因没有被处理的有力证据。能改变这道算术的不是更强烈的感情,而是一个新的事实:造成以前分手的那些情况发生了具体的改变。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 复合伴侣的存续,用低风险组与高风险组的混合来描述,比用单一的风险率更好;属于低风险组可以由以前分手原因的具体改变来预测。什么会证明它错: 在一个跟踪三年的复合伴侣队列中,单一不变的风险率与两组混合拟合得一样好,或者自述的原因改变不能预测哪些伴侣维持下来。

小结

复合平均而言并非注定失败,但它是一种混合。复合的伴侣维持得越久,越可能属于处理了原因的那一种;而每一次很快重演的分合,都是他们不属于那一种的有力证据。

参考文献

Dailey, René M., Abigail Pfiester, Borae Jin, Gary Beck, and Glenn Clark. 2009. “On-Again/off-Again Dating Relationships: How Are They Different from Other Dating Relationships?” Personal Relationships 16 (1): 23 to 47.

Fan, Y. (2026). Relationship Rupture Survival Analysis, No-Contact Memory Decay and Reconciliation Game Windows: Negative-Affect Dissipation Rates, Dual-Process Nostalgia Peaks and Signaling Equilibria [关系断裂生存分析、断联期记忆衰减与复联博弈窗口] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090241 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).