5D Library › Relationship Rupture Survival Analysis, No-Contact Memory Decay and Reconciliation Game Windows · 中文
Chapter 2. Two Memories Fading at Two Speeds
The model
Studies that follow people through the weeks after a break-up find that sadness and anger usually ease within weeks, with large differences between people (Sbarra and Emery 2005). The positive side of the relationship, the shared memories that later return as nostalgia (Wildschut et al. 2006), seems to fade more slowly. A simple way to write this down is with two exponentials. Defensive negative arousal is with about 14 to 21 days, and positive attachment memory is with about 60 to 90 days. The net pull towards the former partner is
Setting gives the day of the peak,
which exists only when . If the negative side starts larger than the positive (), the net pull first turns positive on day , where
Calculation
# Chapter 2. p03: The two-exponential model and its peak. After a
# rupture, negative defensive arousal N(t) = A exp(-t / tn) fades fast
# and positive attachment memory P(t) = B exp(-t / tp) fades slowly.
# Net pull f(t) = P(t) - N(t). Setting f'(t) = 0 gives the peak
# t* = tn tp / (tp - tn) * ln(A tp / (B tn)),
# which exists only when A tp > B tn. Net pull turns positive at
# t0 = tn tp / (tp - tn) * ln(A / B) (when A > B).
# Grid: tn 14 to 21 days, tp 60 to 90 days, A / B = 1.5, B = 1.
from math import exp, log
def peak(tn, tp, a, b=1.0):
if a * tp <= b * tn:
return None
return tn * tp / (tp - tn) * log(a * tp / (b * tn))
def pull(t, tn, tp, a, b=1.0):
return b * exp(-t / tp) - a * exp(-t / tn)
if __name__ == "__main__":
a = 1.5
print(" tn tp t0 (days) t* (days) f(t*) P(t*)")
for tn in (14, 17.5, 21):
for tp in (60, 75, 90):
t0 = tn * tp / (tp - tn) * log(a)
ts = peak(tn, tp, a)
print(" {:4.1f} {:3d} {:9.1f} {:9.1f} {:5.3f} {:5.3f}"
.format(tn, tp, t0, ts, pull(ts, tn, tp, a),
exp(-ts / tp)))
grid = [peak(tn, tp, a) for tn in (14, 17.5, 21) for tp in (60, 75, 90)]
print(" t* across the grid: {:.1f} to {:.1f} days".format(
min(grid), max(grid)))
# tn tp t0 (days) t* (days) f(t*) P(t*)
# 14.0 60 7.4 34.0 0.435 0.568
# 14.0 75 7.0 35.9 0.504 0.620
# 14.0 90 6.7 37.6 0.556 0.659
# 17.5 60 10.0 40.5 0.361 0.510
# 17.5 75 9.3 42.5 0.435 0.568
# 17.5 90 8.8 44.4 0.492 0.611
# 21.0 60 13.1 47.0 0.297 0.457
# 21.0 75 11.8 49.0 0.375 0.521
# 21.0 90 11.1 51.0 0.435 0.568
# t* across the grid: 34.0 to 51.0 daysWith , and , the net pull turns positive on day 9.3 and peaks on day 42.5, when positive memory still stands at 0.568 of its starting value and the net pull at 0.435. Across the grid of typical values the peak lies between days 34.0 and 51.0. Both time constants push it later: a slower fade of anger and a slower fade of good memory both delay the best moment.
How sure is the window?
The grid hides the largest source of variation: how bitter the rupture was. p04 lets the starting ratio of negative to positive vary widely between people.
Calculation
# Chapter 2. p04: How sure is the "golden window"? Draw tn uniform on
# 14 to 21 days, tp uniform on 60 to 90, and the ratio A / B from a
# lognormal law with median 1.5 and log-sd 0.8 (people differ a lot in
# how bitter the rupture was). Report the spread of t*, how often the
# peak of net pull is still negative (N still stronger than P at its
# best moment), how often it falls before day 21 or after day 60,
# and how often A tp <= B tn (no interior peak at all:
# net pull is highest on day 0 and only falls). 20,000 draws, seed 92.
import random
from math import exp, log
def one(rng):
tn, tp = rng.uniform(14, 21), rng.uniform(60, 90)
a = 1.5 * exp(rng.gauss(0, 0.8))
if a * tp <= tn:
return None, None
ts = tn * tp / (tp - tn) * log(a * tp / tn)
return ts, exp(-ts / tp) - a * exp(-ts / tn)
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(92)
res = [one(rng) for _ in range(20000)]
peaks = sorted(t for t, _ in res if t is not None)
q = lambda p: peaks[int(p * (len(peaks) - 1))]
print(" draws with no interior peak: {:.4f}".format(
sum(1 for t, _ in res if t is None) / len(res)))
print(" t* median {:.1f} days; 10% {:.1f}; 90% {:.1f}".format(
q(0.5), q(0.1), q(0.9)))
neg = sum(1 for t, f in res if t is not None and f < 0) / len(peaks)
print(" peaks where net pull is still negative: {:.3f}".format(neg))
print(" peaks before day 21: {:.3f}; after day 60: {:.3f}".format(
sum(1 for t in peaks if t < 21) / len(peaks),
sum(1 for t in peaks if t > 60) / len(peaks)))
inside = sum(1 for t in peaks if 30 <= t <= 60) / len(peaks)
print(" peaks inside days 30 to 60: {:.3f}".format(inside))
# draws with no interior peak: 0.0103
# t* median 41.9 days; 10% 19.5; 90% 67.0
# peaks where net pull is still negative: 0.000
# peaks before day 21: 0.119; after day 60: 0.174
# peaks inside days 30 to 60: 0.571The median peak is day 41.9, close to the grid, but eight in ten peaks fall anywhere between days 19.5 and 67.0; 0.119 come before day 21 and 0.174 after day 60. Only 0.571 lie inside the popular “days 30 to 60”. In 0.0103 of draws there is no interior peak at all: when the rupture left little bitterness, net pull is highest at once and only falls, so waiting gains nothing. The “golden window” is a property of a model with assumed numbers, not a date on a calendar.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): in people’s daily ratings after a rupture, negative arousal toward the former partner fades with a time constant several times shorter than positive memories of the relationship, so that the gap between them peaks some weeks later. What would show it wrong: in a pre-registered diary study, the two ratings fade at similar rates, or their difference shows no peak after the first week.
Summary
Two fading processes with different speeds produce a peak in net pull, and its day can be written down. But the day depends on three quantities that vary between people, and the spread is wide: a model gives a range of weeks, not an appointment.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Relationship Rupture Survival Analysis, No-Contact Memory Decay and Reconciliation Game Windows: Negative-Affect Dissipation Rates, Dual-Process Nostalgia Peaks and Signaling Equilibria [关系断裂生存分析、断联期记忆衰减与复联博弈窗口] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090241 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).