5D Library › 玄空飞星置换代数、二十四山罗盘离散化与骨相比例计量 · English

第四章 三停五眼、黄金比例与自拍的透视

理想比例的基础比率

相术常以「三停」与「五眼」描述理想的面部比例:发际至眉、眉至鼻底、鼻底至颏三段等长;面宽等于五个眼宽。流行的说法还把黄金比例 φ\varphi 当作美与贵的标准。人体测量学用标准化的特征点测量这些尺寸,个体之间的差异相当可观 (Farkas 1994);而黄金比例在自然与人体中的普遍性,常被夸大 (Livio 2002)。

一个理想比例有多少人符合?程序设一个示意的人群:上、中、下三停的均值为 6.0、6.0、6.5 厘米,变异系数为 cc;面宽与眼宽之比均值 4.6、标准差 0.3;面长与面宽之比均值 1.35、标准差 0.08。「三停均等」指最长一停不超过最短一停的 1.05 倍,「五眼」指比值在 5 ± 0.1 之内,「黄金脸」指面长面宽比在 φ\varphi 的 2% 以内。

推导

# Chapter 4. p07: How rare are "ideal" thirds, fifths and golden faces?
# Illustrative population of faces (lengths in cm, independent normal):
#   upper third (hairline to brow) mean 6.0, middle third (brow to
#   nose base) mean 6.0, lower third (nose base to chin) mean 6.5,
#   each with coefficient of variation c;
#   face width / eye width ("five eyes") mean 4.6, sd 0.3;
#   face height / face width mean 1.35, sd 0.08.
# "Equal thirds" means the longest third is at most 5 % longer than
# the shortest; "five eyes" means the ratio is within 5 +/- 0.1;
# "golden" means height / width within 2 % of phi = 1.618.
# 200,000 simulated faces, fixed seed.
import math
import random

PHI = (1 + math.sqrt(5)) / 2

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(1618)
    n = 200000
    print("   phi = {:.6f}".format(PHI))
    print("   CV of thirds   equal thirds   five eyes   golden   all three")
    for c in (0.06, 0.08, 0.10):
        eq = fe = go = al = 0
        for _ in range(n):
            t = [rng.gauss(m, m * c) for m in (6.0, 6.0, 6.5)]
            a = max(t) / min(t) <= 1.05
            b = abs(rng.gauss(4.6, 0.3) - 5) <= 0.1
            g = abs(rng.gauss(1.35, 0.08) / PHI - 1) <= 0.02
            eq += a
            fe += b
            go += g
            al += a and b and g
        print("   {:12.2f} {:14.4f} {:11.4f} {:8.4f} {:11.5f}".format(
            c, eq / n, fe / n, go / n, al / n))
    z = (PHI * 0.98 - 1.35) / 0.08
    print("   golden band starts {:.2f} sd above the mean height / width"
          .format(z))
    print("\nReading: under these illustrative spreads, equal thirds")
    print("are uncommon, the five-eye proportion is met by about one")
    print("face in ten, and a golden face is almost absent. An ideal")
    print("that almost nobody meets labels nearly everyone a deviation,")
    print("which leaves room to read meaning into any face.")
#    phi = 1.618034
#    CV of thirds   equal thirds   five eyes   golden   all three
#            0.06         0.0988      0.1122   0.0014     0.00002
#            0.08         0.0711      0.1104   0.0014     0.00001
#            0.10         0.0508      0.1114   0.0015     0.00001
#    golden band starts 2.95 sd above the mean height / width
#
# Reading: under these illustrative spreads, equal thirds
# are uncommon, the five-eye proportion is met by about one
# face in ten, and a golden face is almost absent. An ideal
# that almost nobody meets labels nearly everyone a deviation,
# which leaves room to read meaning into any face.

变异系数为 0.06 时,三停均等者只占 0.0988,变异系数为 0.10 时为 0.0508;五眼约占九分之一;黄金脸只有 0.0014 左右,因为黄金区间的下限在人群均值以上 2.95 个标准差。三者兼备的人约为十万分之一至十万分之二。一个几乎无人符合的理想,会把几乎所有人都标为「偏离」,从而为任何解读留下空间。

自拍放大了鼻子

针孔相机对距离为 dd 的物体成像,比例尺与 1/d1/d 成正比。鼻尖比两眼外眦所在的参考平面靠前约 2.5 厘米,颧点靠后约 5 厘米(示意深度),因此照片中鼻宽对颧宽的比例被放大 (d+5)/(d−2.5)(d + 5)/(d – 2.5) 倍。已发表的研究用模型计算了同一现象:在约 12 英寸处拍摄的自拍,鼻基底看起来比在约 5 英尺处拍摄宽约三成 (Ward et al. 2018)。

推导

# Chapter 4. p08: A selfie enlarges the nose: perspective magnification.
# A pinhole camera at distance d (cm) from a reference plane through
# the outer corners of the eyes images a point at depth z (cm, toward
# the camera positive) with scale f / (d - z). The nose tip lies about
# 2.5 cm in front of that plane, the cheekbones (zygion) about 5 cm
# behind it (illustrative depths). The apparent ratio of nose width to
# cheekbone width is inflated by the factor (d + 5) / (d - 2.5).
# Ratios read from the photo are compared with the true ratio, and the
# distance needed to keep the distortion under 2 % is solved exactly:
#   (d + 5) / (d - 2.5) <= 1.02  <=>  d >= (5 + 1.02 x 2.5) / 0.02.

def factor(d):
    return (d + 5.0) / (d - 2.5)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   camera distance (cm)   nose / cheek ratio inflated by")
    for d in (25, 30, 45, 60, 100, 150, 200, 300):
        print("   {:20d} {:22.3f}".format(d, factor(d)))
    print("\n   distance for distortion under 2 %: {:.1f} cm".format(
        (5 + 1.02 * 2.5) / 0.02))
    true_ratio = 0.27
    print("   a true nose / cheek ratio of {:.2f} reads {:.3f} at 30 cm"
          .format(true_ratio, true_ratio * factor(30)))
    print("   and {:.3f} at 200 cm".format(true_ratio * factor(200)))
    print("\nReading: an arm's-length selfie inflates the nose against")
    print("the cheekbones by more than a quarter. Any proportion read")
    print("from a phone photo mixes the face with the camera distance;")
    print("only photos taken from a few metres compare faces fairly.")
#    camera distance (cm)   nose / cheek ratio inflated by
#                      25                  1.333
#                      30                  1.273
#                      45                  1.176
#                      60                  1.130
#                     100                  1.077
#                     150                  1.051
#                     200                  1.038
#                     300                  1.025
#
#    distance for distortion under 2 %: 377.5 cm
#    a true nose / cheek ratio of 0.27 reads 0.344 at 30 cm
#    and 0.280 at 200 cm
#
# Reading: an arm's-length selfie inflates the nose against
# the cheekbones by more than a quarter. Any proportion read
# from a phone photo mixes the face with the camera distance;
# only photos taken from a few metres compare faces fairly.

相机在 30 厘米处时放大 1.273 倍,25 厘米处为 1.333 倍;200 厘米处仍有 1.038 倍。要把畸变压到 2% 以内,相机须在 377.5 厘米以外。真实比值为 0.27 的脸,在 30 厘米的自拍中读为 0.344,在 200 厘米处读为 0.280。

鼻宽对颧宽比例的透视放大倍数随相机距离的变化。点线为 2% 与 377.5 厘米。

假说 · 尚未验证

可检验的推论。 若面相解读确实来自面部结构,那么同一个人在 30 厘米与 4 米处拍摄的两张照片,应得到相同的解读。什么会证明这一推论错:若解读随拍摄距离系统性地改变(例如近拍时更常被判为「鼻大」),那么解读至少部分来自镜头,而不是脸。

小结

三停均等、五眼与黄金脸都是少数人才符合的理想,黄金脸几乎不存在;理想越罕见,越容易把任何人解读为「有特点」。手机自拍会把鼻子相对颧骨放大四分之一以上,从照片读比例时必须控制拍摄距离。

参考文献

Farkas, Leslie G., ed. 1994. Anthropometry of the Head and Face. 2nd ed. Raven Press.
Livio, Mario. 2002. The Golden Ratio: The Story of Phi, the World’s Most Astonishing Number. Broadway Books.
Ward, Brittany, Max Ward, Ohad Fried, and Boris Paskhover. 2018. “Nasal Distortion in Short-Distance Photographs: The Selfie Effect.” JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery 20 (4): 333–35.

Fan, Y. (2026). Xuankong Flying-Star Permutations, Twenty-Four-Mountain Compass Discretization and Craniofacial Ratio Metrology: Lo-Shu Orbit Cycles, Magnetic Declination Flip Rates and Landmark Measurement Error Propagation [玄空飞星置换代数、二十四山罗盘离散化与骨相比例计量] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090215 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).