5D Library › 节律声刺激、听觉稳态反应与双耳等时调制工程 · English

第二章 听觉稳态反应与阿诺德舌

「夹带」的两种意思

说一个节律声「夹带」了脑波,可以指两件很不同的事。弱的意思是诱发反应:每个周期的声音都诱发一个小的神经反应,这些反应叠加起来,在脑电的刺激频率处形成一条谱线,即听觉稳态反应(ASSR)。40 Hz 附近的稳态反应尤其明显 (Galambos et al. 1981),在听力学中已是成熟的客观测听手段 (Picton et al. 2003)。强的意思是同步:一个本来就存在的内在节律被外部驱动拉到驱动的频率上,并在驱动停止后仍保持一段时间。后者需要一个振荡器,前者不需要。

阿诺德舌

同步的最简单模型是 Adler 方程 (Adler 1946):设内在节律与驱动之间的相位差为 φ\varphi,失谐为 ν\nu,耦合强度为 KK,则 φ̇=2πν−Ksin⁡φ\dot\varphi = 2\pi\nu – K\sin\varphi。没有噪声时,当且仅当 |2πν|≤K|2\pi\nu| \le K 时相位差停在一个固定值上,这就是锁定;在失谐与耦合构成的平面上,锁定区是一个从零失谐处张开的「舌」(Kuramoto 1984; Pikovsky et al. 2001)。加入噪声后,锁定变成程度问题,用锁相值(PLV)度量 (Lachaux et al. 1999)。

推导

# Chapter 2. p03: The Arnold tongue of a noisy phase oscillator.
# Adler's equation for the phase difference phi between an intrinsic
# rhythm and a periodic drive, with detuning nu (Hz) and coupling K
# (rad/s), plus white phase noise of strength D:
#     dphi = (2 pi nu - K sin phi) dt + sqrt(2 D dt) N(0, 1).
# Without noise the rhythm locks exactly when |2 pi nu| <= K (the
# tongue). With noise, locking is graded; we measure it by the phase
# locking value PLV = |mean exp(i phi)| over 60 s after a 5 s burn-in.
# Euler-Maruyama step 1 ms, fixed seed. D = 2 rad^2/s throughout.
import cmath
import math
import random

def plv(nu, K, D=2.0, T=60.0, dt=0.001, seed=7):
    rng = random.Random(seed)
    phi, acc, n = 0.0, 0j, 0
    burn = int(5.0 / dt)
    sd = math.sqrt(2 * D * dt)
    w = 2 * math.pi * nu
    for i in range(burn + int(T / dt)):
        phi += (w - K * math.sin(phi)) * dt + sd * rng.gauss(0, 1)
        if i >= burn and i % 10 == 0:
            acc += cmath.exp(1j * phi)
            n += 1
    return abs(acc) / n

if __name__ == "__main__":
    nus = (0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0)
    Ks = (2.0, 6.0, 12.0, 25.0)
    print("   PLV after 60 s; rows: coupling K (rad/s); cols: detuning nu")
    print("   K \\ nu  " + "".join("{:>9.1f}".format(v) for v in nus))
    for K in Ks:
        row = [plv(v, K) for v in nus]
        print("   {:6.1f}  ".format(K) + "".join(
            "{:9.3f}".format(r) for r in row))
    print("\n   noiseless tongue edge |nu| = K / (2 pi):")
    for K in Ks:
        print("     K = {:5.1f}  ->  |nu| <= {:.3f} Hz".format(
            K, K / (2 * math.pi)))
    print("\nReading: a weak drive locks a rhythm only if it is almost")
    print("at the same frequency already; the tongue widens in")
    print("proportion to the coupling. Outside the tongue the PLV")
    print("falls towards the chance floor for 6,000 samples.")
#    PLV after 60 s; rows: coupling K (rad/s); cols: detuning nu
#    K \ nu        0.0      0.5      1.0      2.0      4.0
#       2.0      0.544    0.287    0.146    0.077    0.043
#       6.0      0.838    0.736    0.496    0.251    0.115
#      12.0      0.921    0.917    0.880    0.588    0.244
#      25.0      0.962    0.962    0.960    0.954    0.690
#
#    noiseless tongue edge |nu| = K / (2 pi):
#      K =   2.0  ->  |nu| <= 0.318 Hz
#      K =   6.0  ->  |nu| <= 0.955 Hz
#      K =  12.0  ->  |nu| <= 1.910 Hz
#      K =  25.0  ->  |nu| <= 3.979 Hz
#
# Reading: a weak drive locks a rhythm only if it is almost
# at the same frequency already; the tongue widens in
# proportion to the coupling. Outside the tongue the PLV
# falls towards the chance floor for 6,000 samples.

耦合为 6 rad/s 时,零失谐的锁相值为 0.838,失谐 2 Hz 时降到 0.251;无噪声的舌边在 0.955 Hz。耦合 25 rad/s 时舌边在 3.979 Hz,失谐 4 Hz 处锁相值仍有 0.690。舌的宽度与耦合成正比:弱驱动只能锁定频率本来就很接近的节律。这对节律音频的含义是:要把一个 10 Hz 的内在节律拉到 6 Hz,驱动必须非常强;而第一章表明,双耳拍恰恰是弱驱动。

四种耦合强度下锁相值随失谐的变化。虚线为无噪声时的舌边。

需要记录多长

即使只要求「诱发反应」,也要问它能否被看见。设反应幅度在 40 Hz 附近最大,背景脑电的功率谱密度按 1/f1/f 下降。时长为 TT 的傅里叶变换把反应放进宽度为 1/T1/T 的一个频点,噪声功率随 TT 减小,于是功率信噪比与 TT 成正比,幅度信噪比与 T\sqrt{T} 成正比。程序要求信噪比达到 10 dB,并至少包含十个完整周期。

推导

# Chapter 2. p04: How long must a rhythm play before EEG can see it?
# Illustrative model of an auditory steady-state response (ASSR):
#   response amplitude a(fm) = 0.15 + 0.35 exp(-((fm - 40) / 10)^2) uV
#     for a fully modulated (isochronic) drive, scaled by the drive;
#   background EEG power density P(f) = 4 / f uV^2/Hz (a 1/f law).
# A DFT of T seconds puts the response in one bin of width 1/T, so the
# power SNR is (a^2 / 2) T / P(fm): it grows in proportion to T and the
# amplitude SNR as sqrt(T). We ask for 10 dB and also for at least ten
# full cycles. Binaural drive = 0.13116 (carrier 400 Hz, from p02).
# Then: the drive of a static tone, wavelengths of 432 and 528 Hz,
# and the chance level of the phase locking value over M epochs.
import math

def amp(fm):
    return 0.15 + 0.35 * math.exp(-((fm - 40.0) / 10.0) ** 2)

def t_needed(fm, drive, target_db=10.0):
    a = amp(fm) * drive
    snr_per_s = (a * a / 2.0) / (4.0 / fm)
    t_snr = 10 ** (target_db / 10.0) / snr_per_s
    return max(t_snr, 10.0 / fm)

def fmt(t):
    if t < 60:
        return "{:8.1f} s".format(t)
    if t < 3600:
        return "{:8.1f} m".format(t / 60)
    return "{:8.1f} h".format(t / 3600)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   rate Hz   a (uV)   isochronic T   binaural T   ratio")
    for fm in (0.1, 2.0, 6.0, 10.0, 40.0):
        ti, tb = t_needed(fm, 1.0), t_needed(fm, 0.13116)
        print("   {:7.1f} {:8.3f}   {}   {}  {:6.1f}".format(
            fm, amp(fm), fmt(ti), fmt(tb), tb / ti))
    print("\n   amplitude SNR at 40 Hz, isochronic, as T grows:")
    for T in (1, 4, 16, 64):
        s = (amp(40) ** 2 / 2) * T / (4.0 / 40)
        print("     T = {:3d} s   power {:7.2f}   amplitude {:6.2f}".format(
            T, s, math.sqrt(s)))
    print("\n   static tones: modulation depth 0, so drive 0 and a")
    print("   response of 0 uV at every rate and every duration.")
    for f in (432, 528):
        print("   {} Hz: wavelength {:.3f} m in air, {:.3f} m in water,"
              .format(f, 343.0 / f, 1480.0 / f))
        print("           {:.2f} billion times the 2 nm width of DNA"
              .format(1480.0 / f / 2e-9 / 1e9))
    print("\n   chance PLV for M random-phase epochs, sqrt(pi / (4 M)):")
    for M in (10, 40, 160, 640):
        print("     M = {:4d}   {:.4f}".format(M, math.sqrt(math.pi / 4 / M)))
#    rate Hz   a (uV)   isochronic T   binaural T   ratio
#        0.1    0.150        9.9 h      574.1 h    58.1
#        2.0    0.150       29.6 m       28.7 h    58.1
#        6.0    0.150        9.9 m        9.6 h    58.1
#       10.0    0.150        5.9 m        5.7 h    58.1
#       40.0    0.500        8.0 s        7.8 m    58.1
#
#    amplitude SNR at 40 Hz, isochronic, as T grows:
#      T =   1 s   power    1.25   amplitude   1.12
#      T =   4 s   power    5.00   amplitude   2.24
#      T =  16 s   power   20.00   amplitude   4.47
#      T =  64 s   power   80.00   amplitude   8.94
#
#    static tones: modulation depth 0, so drive 0 and a
#    response of 0 uV at every rate and every duration.
#    432 Hz: wavelength 0.794 m in air, 3.426 m in water,
#            1.71 billion times the 2 nm width of DNA
#    528 Hz: wavelength 0.650 m in air, 2.803 m in water,
#            1.40 billion times the 2 nm width of DNA
#
#    chance PLV for M random-phase epochs, sqrt(pi / (4 M)):
#      M =   10   0.2802
#      M =   40   0.1401
#      M =  160   0.0701
#      M =  640   0.0350

满深度的 40 Hz 等时音只需 8.0 s;同频率的双耳拍需要 7.8 min,长 58.1 倍。在 10 Hz,等时音需要 5.9 min,双耳拍需要 5.7 h;在 0.1 Hz,即使等时音也要 9.9 h,此时「十个周期」本身就要 100 s,而低频的脑电背景噪声极大。幅度信噪比随时长按平方根增长:1 s 时为 1.12,16 s 时为 4.47。

静态的 432 Hz 或 528 Hz 纯音调制深度为 0,驱动为 0,任何时长都不会产生节律反应。它们在空气中的波长分别为 0.794 m 与 0.650 m,在水中为 3.426 m 与 2.803 m,分别是 DNA 双螺旋宽度(约 2 nm)的 1.71×1091.71\times10^{9} 倍与 1.40×1091.40\times10^{9} 倍。声波在这种尺度上对分子只是一个均匀的压力变化,谈不上「共振修复」。

最后,锁相值本身有机会水平:MM 段随机相位的单位向量,其平均长度约为 π/(4M)\sqrt{\pi/(4M)}。10 段时为 0.2802,640 段时为 0.0350。报告锁相值而不报告段数,等于不报告任何东西。

假说 · 尚未验证

可检验的推论。 若 432 Hz 与 528 Hz 纯音对脑电有频率特异的作用,则在双盲条件下,与 440 Hz 纯音相比,二者应在预先指定的频段与电极上产生不同的功率或锁相。什么会证明这一推论错:若在足够的样本与预先登记的分析下,三个纯音的脑电指标没有差别,则「特殊频率」的说法没有生理基础。

小结

可以测量的「夹带」是稳态反应,它在 40 Hz 附近最强,需要几秒到几分钟的记录才能被看见;双耳拍需要的时间长得多。真正的同步受阿诺德舌约束:弱驱动只能锁定频率接近的节律。静态纯音没有节律可供诱发或同步。

参考文献

Adler, Robert. 1946. “A Study of Locking Phenomena in Oscillators.” Proceedings of the IRE 34 (6): 351–57.
Galambos, Robert, Scott Makeig, and Peter J. Talmachoff. 1981. “A 40-Hz Auditory Potential Recorded from the Human Scalp.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 78 (4): 2643–47.
Kuramoto, Yoshiki. 1984. Chemical Oscillations, Waves, and Turbulence. Springer.
Lachaux, Jean-Philippe, Eugenio Rodriguez, Jacques Martinerie, and Francisco J. Varela. 1999. “Measuring Phase Synchrony in Brain Signals.” Human Brain Mapping 8 (4): 194–208.
Picton, Terence W., M. Sasha John, Andrew Dimitrijevic, and David Purcell. 2003. “Human Auditory Steady-State Responses.” International Journal of Audiology 42 (4): 177–219.
Pikovsky, Arkady, Michael Rosenblum, and Jürgen Kurths. 2001. Synchronization: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences. Cambridge University Press.

Fan, Y. (2026). Rhythmic Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Steady-State Responses and Modulation Signal Engineering: Binaural versus Isochronic Envelope Depth, 40-Hz Phase-Locking Bounds and Pink-Noise Spectral Masking [节律声刺激、听觉稳态反应与双耳等时调制工程] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090211 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).