5D Library › Horary Dignity Scoring, Sidereal Nakshatra Precession and Vimshottari Dasha Chains · 中文
Chapter 8. The Base Rate of “Something Notable” and Two Pre-Registered Studies
There is always something to say about a chart
Calculation
# Chapter 8. p15: How often is something "notable" in a chart?
# Over random moments 1900-2049 (p02, p03, p05 rules):
# - at least one of Mercury ... Saturn retrograde
# - at least one planet in its domicile or exaltation
# - at least one mutual reception by domicile
# - at least one planet combust (within 8 deg 30' of the Sun)
# - the Moon "void of course": no Ptolemaic aspect to the Sun or to
# Mercury ... Saturn before it leaves its sign (linear motion)
import importlib.util
import random
def load(name):
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(name, name + ".py")
m = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
spec.loader.exec_module(m)
return m
eph = load("p02_ephemeris")
dig = load("p01_dignity_tables")
rec = load("p03_receptions")
pro = load("p04_prohibition")
OTHERS = ("Sun", "Mercury", "Venus", "Mars", "Jupiter", "Saturn")
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(73015)
N = 15000
hits = {"retrograde": 0, "dom/exalt": 0, "mutual": 0, "combust": 0,
"void Moon": 0, "any of these": 0}
for _ in range(N):
jd = rng.uniform(2415020.5, 2469807.5)
pos = eph.positions(jd)
w = {b: eph.speed(jd, b) for b in OTHERS + ("Moon",)}
f = {"retrograde": any(w[p] < 0 for p in OTHERS[1:]),
"dom/exalt": any(int(pos[p] // 30) in dig.DOM[p] or
int(pos[p] // 30) == dig.EXALT[p]
for p in dig.PL),
"mutual": rec.cycles({p: int(pos[p] // 30)
for p in dig.PL})[0] > 0,
"combust": any(abs((pos[p] - pos["Sun"] + 180) % 360 - 180)
<= 8.5 for p in OTHERS[1:] + ("Moon",))}
left = (30 - pos["Moon"] % 30) / w["Moon"]
f["void Moon"] = all(pro.next_perfection(
pos["Moon"], w["Moon"], pos[x], w[x], left) is None
for x in OTHERS)
f["any of these"] = any(f.values())
for k, v in f.items():
hits[k] += v
for k, v in hits.items():
print(" {:13s} {:.4f}".format(k, v / N))
# retrograde 0.6882
# dom/exalt 0.8179
# mutual 0.3595
# combust 0.4857
# void Moon 0.2237
# any of these 0.9908At random moments between 1900 and 2049, at least one of Mercury to Saturn is retrograde with probability 0.6882; at least one planet is in domicile or exaltation 0.8179; at least one mutual reception by domicile 0.3595; at least one planet (the Moon included) combust 0.4857; and the Moon is “void of course” (making no further Ptolemaic aspect to the Sun or to Mercury through Saturn before it leaves its sign) 0.2237. At least one of these five occurs with probability 0.9908. Almost every chart, in other words, carries at least one “notable” mark.
This is the same phenomenon as the multiple comparisons of Chapter 5 of Volume 71: a feature named in advance has its own base rate, but picking out afterwards whichever of many features happened brings the base rate close to one. Add the coverage effect of vague statements and selective recall (Forer 1949; Dickson and Kelly 1985), and the experience “this chart got it right” can arise with almost no real predictive power.
Note
A four-step check. First, state the scoring conventions: the version of the terms, the triplicity rulers, whether peregrine is deducted twice, whether accidental dignity counts (Chapters 1 and 3). Second, state the ayanamsha and the length of the dasha year (Chapters 4 and 7). Third, check the precision of the birth time or the time of the question (Chapter 5). Fourth, compare any “special mark” with the base rates of this chapter first, and replace “was it accurate?” by a blind test registered in advance.
Study A: horary yes-or-no questions
Questions whose answer will be known within three months are collected. An astrologer who never meets the askers judges “yes” or “no” from the chart of the moment each question was asked and registers the judgement before the outcome. Because the base rate of “yes” differs between questions, each question is paired with a control judgement decided by a coin, so chance agreement is 0.5.
Calculation
# Chapter 8. p16: Two pre-registered studies and their sizes.
# (A) Horary yes/no: questions with an outcome that will be known within
# three months are submitted; an astrologer who never sees the asker
# judges each from the chart of the moment of asking, recording
# "yes" or "no" before the outcome. Base rates of "yes" differ by
# question, so each question is paired with a coin-matched control:
# chance agreement 0.5. Exact one-sided binomial, alpha 0.05, power 0.90.
# (B) Dasha periods: participants receive four unlabelled timelines of
# mahadasha changes (their own and three from other birth data) and
# choose the one that best matches their life. Chance 1/4.
from math import comb
def tail(n, k, p):
return sum(comb(n, i) * p ** i * (1 - p) ** (n - i)
for i in range(k, n + 1))
def plan(p0, p1, alpha=0.05, power=0.90):
for n in range(20, 5000):
k = next(k for k in range(n + 1) if tail(n, k, p0) <= alpha)
if tail(n, k, p1) >= power:
return n, k, tail(n, k, p0)
if __name__ == "__main__":
for p1 in (0.60, 0.65):
n, k, a = plan(0.5, p1)
print(" (A) accuracy {:.2f} vs 0.50: {} questions, at least {}"
" correct".format(p1, n, k))
print(" exact size {:.4f}".format(a))
for p1 in (0.32, 0.35):
n, k, a = plan(0.25, p1)
print(" (B) hit rate {:.2f} vs 0.25: {} participants, at least {}"
" hits".format(p1, n, k))
print(" exact size {:.4f}".format(a))
# (A) accuracy 0.60 vs 0.50: 213 questions, at least 119 correct
# exact size 0.0499
# (A) accuracy 0.65 vs 0.50: 93 questions, at least 55 correct
# exact size 0.0483
# (B) hit rate 0.32 vs 0.25: 359 participants, at least 104 hits
# exact size 0.0485
# (B) hit rate 0.35 vs 0.25: 179 participants, at least 55 hits
# exact size 0.0485If the true accuracy is 0.60, an exact one-sided binomial test at 0.05 with power 0.90 needs 213 questions and at least 119 correct, with an actual type I error of 0.0499; at 0.65 it needs 93 questions and at least 55 correct.
Study B: blind recognition of dasha timelines
Each participant receives four unlabelled timelines of major periods (one from their own birth data, three from other people’s) and chooses the one that best fits their life. The chance hit rate is 1/4. If the true hit rate is 0.32, 359 participants and at least 104 hits are needed; at 0.35, 179 participants and at least 55 hits. The timelines list only the ages at which major periods begin and end and the names of their lords, with no interpretive text, to avoid the Barnum effect.
Hypothesis · not established
Pre-registered predictions (not yet tested): the accuracy in Study A does not differ significantly from 0.5; the hit rate in Study B does not differ significantly from 0.25. What would show them wrong: an accuracy in Study A significantly above 0.5, or a hit rate in Study B significantly above 0.25.
Summary of the book
Essential dignity is a step function of longitude and the planets’ expected scores are unequal; mutual reception is a 2-cycle of the dispositor map and prohibition a first-passage race; “the strongest planet” changes with the scoring convention. Precession puts 0.8073 of longitudes (p07) in different signs in the two zodiacs; the navamsha is the pada index modulo 12; and in a population of fixed age the Vimshottari shares are neither one ninth nor the period shares. Every conclusion comes from the structure of the rules themselves and involves no claim that any judgement comes true.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Horary Dignity Scoring, Sidereal Nakshatra Precession and Vimshottari Dasha Chains: Reception Matrix Algebra, Ayanamsha Drift Kinetics and Non-Uniform Planetary Period Partitions [古典卜卦尊贵度积分、恒星二十七宿岁差与维姆肖塔里运限链] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090195 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).