5D Library › Horary Dignity Scoring, Sidereal Nakshatra Precession and Vimshottari Dasha Chains · 中文
Chapter 3. Accidental Dignity and the Convention Budget of “the Strongest Planet”
Points from motion and from the Sun
Accidental dignity looks at a planet’s “circumstances”: its house, whether it is retrograde, fast or slow, and its distance from the Sun. The book takes a subset of Lilly’s table (Lilly 1647): direct +4, retrograde −5; faster than its mean daily motion +2, slower −2; free from the Sun’s beams +5; in the heart of the Sun (within 17 arcminutes, cazimi) +5; combust (within 8 degrees 30 minutes) −5; under the Sun’s beams (within 17 degrees) −4. House points: 1st and 10th +5; 4th, 7th and 11th +4; 2nd and 5th +3; 9th +2; 3rd +1; 12th −5; 6th and 8th −2.
Calculation
# Chapter 3. p05: Accidental dignities from motion and from the Sun.
# Subset of Lilly's accidental table used here:
# direct +4, retrograde -5; swift +2, slow -2 (against the mean daily
# motion); free from combustion and the Sun's beams +5; cazimi (within
# 0 deg 17') +5; combust (within 8 deg 30') -5; under the beams (within
# 17 deg) -4. Frequencies over 1900-2049 from the ephemeris of p02.
import importlib.util
import random
def load(name):
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(name, name + ".py")
m = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
spec.loader.exec_module(m)
return m
eph = load("p02_ephemeris")
MEAN = {"Moon": 13.176, "Mercury": 0.9856, "Venus": 0.9856,
"Mars": 0.524, "Jupiter": 0.0831, "Saturn": 0.0335}
def solar(dist):
if dist <= 17 / 60:
return "cazimi", 5
if dist <= 8.5:
return "combust", -5
if dist <= 17:
return "beams", -4
return "free", 5
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(73005)
N = 30000
rows = {p: {"retro": 0, "cazimi": 0, "combust": 0, "beams": 0,
"score": 0} for p in MEAN}
for _ in range(N):
jd = rng.uniform(2415020.5, 2469807.5)
pos = eph.positions(jd)
for p in MEAN:
w = eph.speed(jd, p)
sc = 0
if p != "Moon":
rows[p]["retro"] += w < 0
sc += -5 if w < 0 else 4
sc += 2 if abs(w) > MEAN[p] else -2
dist = abs((pos[p] - pos["Sun"] + 180) % 360 - 180)
kind, pts = solar(dist)
if kind != "free":
rows[p][kind] += 1
rows[p]["score"] += sc + pts
print(" planet retro cazimi combust beams mean subset score")
for p, r in rows.items():
print(" {:8s} {:5.3f} {:6.4f} {:7.4f} {:5.3f} {:6.2f}".format(
p, r["retro"] / N, r["cazimi"] / N, r["combust"] / N,
r["beams"] / N, r["score"] / N))
# planet retro cazimi combust beams mean subset score
# Moon 0.000 0.0020 0.0447 0.046 4.05
# Mercury 0.187 0.0078 0.2396 0.312 2.76
# Venus 0.073 0.0043 0.1257 0.134 6.90
# Mars 0.096 0.0021 0.0756 0.079 7.54
# Jupiter 0.305 0.0016 0.0533 0.055 6.14
# Saturn 0.367 0.0020 0.0522 0.051 5.88At random moments between 1900 and 2049 the shares of time spent retrograde are: Mercury 0.187, Venus 0.073, Mars 0.096, Jupiter 0.305 and Saturn 0.367. Mercury is combust 0.2396 of the time and Venus 0.1257; each is in the heart of the Sun less than one per cent of the time. The mean score of this subset runs from 2.76 for Mercury to 7.54 for Mars: Mercury is handicapped by staying near the Sun, Jupiter and Saturn lose points for frequent retrogradation.
The strongest planet under three conventions
A horary judgement often has to say “which planet is strongest” or “which of two significators is stronger”. The program compares three conventions at random moments:
- A: essential score (Chapter 1, peregrine deducted even when detriment or fall is present) plus the accidental subset above plus house points;
- B: as A, but no peregrine deduction when detriment or fall is already present;
- C: essential score alone.
Each chart is taken as a day or night chart at random, and each of the seven planets gets a house drawn uniformly (there is no model of location).
Calculation
# Chapter 3. p06: "The strongest planet" under three scoring conventions.
# A essential (p01, peregrine counted even with detriment or fall)
# + accidental subset (p05) + house points (Lilly: 1st/10th 5,
# 4th/7th/11th 4, 2nd/5th 3, 9th 2, 3rd 1, 12th -5, 6th/8th -2)
# B as A, but peregrine is not added on top of detriment or fall
# C essential dignity alone (p01 rule)
# Charts: random moments 1900-2049 (p02), day or night with probability
# 1/2, each planet in a house drawn uniformly (no location model).
import importlib.util
import random
def load(name):
spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(name, name + ".py")
m = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec)
spec.loader.exec_module(m)
return m
dig = load("p01_dignity_tables")
eph = load("p02_ephemeris")
acc = load("p05_accidental")
HOUSE = (5, 3, 1, 4, 3, -2, 4, -2, 2, 5, 4, -5)
def totals(pos, speeds, day, houses, double, with_acc):
out = {}
for p in dig.PL:
s = dig.score(p, pos[p], day, double)
if with_acc:
s += HOUSE[houses[p]]
if p in acc.MEAN:
w = speeds[p]
if p != "Moon":
s += -5 if w < 0 else 4
s += 2 if abs(w) > acc.MEAN[p] else -2
dist = abs((pos[p] - pos["Sun"] + 180) % 360 - 180)
s += acc.solar(dist)[1]
out[p] = s
return out
def winner(t):
best = max(t.values())
return tuple(sorted(p for p, v in t.items() if v == best))
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" mean house points: {:.4f}".format(sum(HOUSE) / 12))
rng = random.Random(73006)
N, agree = 12000, {"A-B": 0, "A-C": 0, "B-C": 0}
pair = {"A-B": 0, "A-C": 0, "B-C": 0}
for _ in range(N):
jd = rng.uniform(2415020.5, 2469807.5)
pos = eph.positions(jd)
speeds = {p: eph.speed(jd, p) for p in acc.MEAN}
day = rng.random() < 0.5
houses = {p: rng.randrange(12) for p in dig.PL}
t = {"A": totals(pos, speeds, day, houses, True, True),
"B": totals(pos, speeds, day, houses, False, True),
"C": totals(pos, speeds, day, houses, True, False)}
for k in agree:
a, b = k.split("-")
agree[k] += winner(t[a]) == winner(t[b])
pair[k] += (t[a]["Moon"] > t[a]["Saturn"]) == \
(t[b]["Moon"] > t[b]["Saturn"])
print(" conventions same strongest planet same Moon-vs-Saturn order")
for k in agree:
print(" {:11s} {:21.4f} {:25.4f}".format(
k, agree[k] / N, pair[k] / N))
# mean house points: 1.8333
# conventions same strongest planet same Moon-vs-Saturn order
# A-B 0.9688 0.9603
# A-C 0.4303 0.7644
# B-C 0.4223 0.7248The mean of the house points is 1.8333. A and B name the same strongest planet in 0.9688 of charts and agree on “Moon or Saturn, which is stronger” in 0.9603; A and C agree only in 0.4303 and 0.7644, B and C in 0.4223 and 0.7248. A seemingly small choice in the scoring (whether peregrine is deducted twice) affects about three charts in a hundred, while the choice whether to count accidental dignity changes the strongest planet in more than half of all charts.
Evidence
Conclusion: “the strongest planet” is a function of the convention. Across the three conventions of this book, agreement on the strongest planet falls as low as 0.4223. Before comparing the judgements of two programs or two astrologers, compare their scoring conventions.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s hypothesis (not yet tested): given the same horary charts, two astrologers who habitually use “essential only” and “essential plus accidental” disagree on the relative strength of significators at about the rate of disagreement between those conventions in this chapter. What would show it wrong: if, under blind conditions, the two kinds of astrologer agree on the same charts significantly more often than the conventional agreement rates (such as 0.7644 for Moon against Saturn), their judgements share something beyond the conventions, and the hypothesis fails.
Summary
The frequencies of accidental dignities are set by kinematics: Jupiter and Saturn are retrograde about a third of the time, and Mercury is combust about a quarter of the time. Agreement on the strongest planet under three scoring conventions lies between 0.4223 and 0.9688; whether accidental dignity is counted is the largest source of disagreement.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Horary Dignity Scoring, Sidereal Nakshatra Precession and Vimshottari Dasha Chains: Reception Matrix Algebra, Ayanamsha Drift Kinetics and Non-Uniform Planetary Period Partitions [古典卜卦尊贵度积分、恒星二十七宿岁差与维姆肖塔里运限链] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090195 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).