5D Library › Subscription Unit Economics, Net Revenue Retention and AI Inference Scaling Laws · 中文

Chapter 2. Net Revenue Retention: a Threshold at 100 %, and Why It Does Not Last

One equation

Net revenue retention (NRR) compares what the customers you had a year ago pay you now with what they paid then, counting the ones who left as zero. Above 100 %, the installed base is growing on its own; investors call that “negative churn”. This chapter writes it as one differential equation and then asks how long a high NRR can last.

Calculation

The model. Let R(t)R(t) be monthly recurring revenue, AA the new monthly revenue added each month by acquisition, ee the monthly expansion rate of the installed base and cc its monthly contraction-plus-churn rate: dRdt=A+(e−c)R,R(0)=0.\frac{dR}{dt} = A + (e – c)\,R, \qquad R(0) = 0 . With k=e−ck = e – c, the solution is R(t)=Ak(ekt−1)R(t) = \frac{A}{k}\left(e^{kt} – 1\right), which tends to AtA\,t as k→0k \to 0. Annual NRR is e12ke^{12k}.

  • If e<ce < c (NRR<100%\text{NRR} < 100\,\%), R(t)→A/(c−e)R(t) \to A/(c – e): a ceiling, reached however long the business keeps acquiring at the same pace. The fixed point R*=A/(c−e)R^* = A/(c-e) is stable.
  • If e=ce = c, R(t)=AtR(t) = A\,t: linear growth.
  • If e>ce > c, R(t)R(t) grows exponentially at rate e−ce – c; the fixed point has moved to negative revenue and repels.

The change at e=ce = c is a bifurcation of the fixed point — the sense in which “negative churn” is a qualitative change and not just a better number.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. Net revenue retention as a differential equation. Recurring
# revenue R(t) (monthly) grows by new business at a constant rate A (new
# customers per month times their starting revenue) and changes on the
# installed base at net rate (e - c):
#     dR/dt = A + (e - c) R,
# where e is expansion and c is contraction plus churn, per month. Annual net
# revenue retention is NRR = exp(12 (e - c)). Solution, with R(0) = 0:
#     e < c:  R(t) = A / (c - e) x (1 - exp(-(c - e) t))   -> saturates at A /
#     (c - e) e = c:  R(t) = A t                                    -> grows
#     linearly e > c:  R(t) = A / (e - c) x (exp((e - c) t) - 1)     -> grows
#     exponentially
# A = 10 (thousand a month of new monthly revenue). Same acquisition in every
# row.
import math

def R(t, A, k):            # k = e - c per month
    if abs(k) < 1e-12:
        return A * t
    return A / k * (math.exp(k * t) - 1)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    A = 10.0
    print(
        "   annual NRR   e - c / month  R at 12 mo   36 mo    60 mo  120 mo "
        " ceiling"
    )
    for nrr in (0.80, 0.90, 1.00, 1.10, 1.20):
        k = math.log(nrr) / 12
        ceil = "none" if k >= 0 else "{:.0f}".format(A / -k)
        print(
            "   {:7.0%}      {:+8.5f}      {:7.0f}   {:7.0f}  {:7.0f} "
            " {:7.0f}   {}".format(
                nrr,
                k,
                R(12, A, k),
                R(36, A, k),
                R(60, A, k),
                R(120, A, k),
                ceil,
            )
        )
    print("\nTime for revenue to double from month 60, by NRR:")
    for nrr in (0.90, 1.00, 1.10, 1.20):
        k = math.log(nrr) / 12
        target = 2 * R(60, A, k)
        t = 60.0
        while R(t, A, k) < target and t < 2000:
            t += 0.25
        print(
            "   {:5.0%}: {}".format(
                nrr,
                (
                    "never (ceiling below double)"
                    if t >= 2000
                    else "{:.0f} months".format(t - 60)
                ),
            )
        )
    print(
        "\nReading: below 100 % NRR a business that keeps acquiring at the"
        " same pace"
    )
    print(
        "still stops growing - revenue approaches a ceiling A / (c - e). At"
        " 100 % it"
    )
    print(
        "grows linearly; above 100 % the installed base compounds on its own."
    )
#    annual NRR   e - c / month  R at 12 mo   36 mo    60 mo  120 mo  ceiling
#        80%      -0.01860          108       262      362      480   538
#        90%      -0.00878          114       309      466      742   1139
#       100%      +0.00000          120       360      600     1200   none
#       110%      +0.00794          126       417      769     2007   none
#       120%      +0.01519          132       479      980     3417   none
#
# Time for revenue to double from month 60, by NRR:
#      90%: 135 months
#     100%: 60 months
#     110%: 40 months
#     120%: 31 months
#
# Reading: below 100 % NRR a business that keeps acquiring at the same pace
# still stops growing - revenue approaches a ceiling A / (c - e). At 100 % it
# grows linearly; above 100 % the installed base compounds on its own.

The table holds acquisition fixed and changes only NRR. At 80 % the business never exceeds 538 a month, whatever it does; at 90 % its ceiling is 1139 and it takes 135 months to double from its month-60 level. At 100 % it grows linearly, doubling in 60 months. At 110 % and 120 % the base compounds: 2007 and 3417 by month 120, against 1200 for the linear case, with the same sales effort.

The managerial consequence is sharp. Below 100 % NRR, a growth plan that keeps acquisition constant is a plan to stop growing; to keep growing, acquisition itself must grow. Above 100 %, the installed base becomes a second engine.

Monthly recurring revenue over ten years with identical acquisition and five levels of NRR: saturation below 100 %, a straight line at 100 %, compounding above.

Why high NRR does not last

The model treats expansion as a fixed rate per month for ever. Real expansion is bounded: a customer cannot buy more seats than it has people, more usage than it has work. The fifth program lets each account expand logistically toward a ceiling of four times its starting revenue, with churn of 0.01 a month.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. Why NRR above 100 % does not last. Each account starts at revenue
# 1 and expands logistically toward a ceiling of 4 (it cannot buy more seats
# than it has people): r(t) = 4 / (1 + 3 exp(-0.06 t)), t in months since
# signing. Accounts churn with probability 0.01 a month whatever their age. A
# cohort's NRR in year y is its revenue at the end of year y divided by its
# revenue at the end of year y - 1 (accounts that churned in between count as
# zero, as NRR is defined). A business that signs the same number of accounts
# every month has a blended NRR over its whole base; we compute it at company
# ages 2 to 10 years.
import math

CAP, K, CHURN = 4.0, 0.06, 0.01

def rev(t):
    return CAP / (1 + (CAP - 1) * math.exp(-K * t))

# expected revenue of a cohort of 1 account
def cohort_revenue(t):
    return rev(t) * (1 - CHURN) ** t

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("A. One cohort's NRR by year since signing")
    for y in range(1, 8):
        print(
            "   year {}: {:6.1%}".format(
                y, cohort_revenue(12 * y) / cohort_revenue(12 * (y - 1))
            )
        )
    print(
        "   long-run limit: (1 - churn)^12 = {:.1%}".format((1 - CHURN) ** 12)
    )
    print(
        "\nB. Blended NRR of a business signing one account a month, by"
        " company age"
    )
    for age_y in (2, 3, 5, 7, 10):
        T = 12 * age_y
        # signing months of accounts live at T-12
        signed = range(0, T - 12)
        before = sum(cohort_revenue(T - 12 - m) for m in signed)
        after = sum(cohort_revenue(T - m) for m in signed)
        print(
            "   company age {:>2} years: blended NRR {:6.1%}".format(
                age_y, after / before
            )
        )
    print(
        "\nReading: expansion is front-loaded, so each cohort's NRR falls"
        " toward the"
    )
    print(
        "survival rate as accounts fill their ceilings, and a company's"
        " blended NRR"
    )
    print(
        "falls as its base ages - with no change in the product or the team."
    )
# A. One cohort's NRR by year since signing
#    year 1: 144.1%
#    year 2: 127.5%
#    year 3: 112.7%
#    year 4: 102.1%
#    year 5:  95.7%
#    year 6:  92.2%
#    year 7:  90.4%
#    long-run limit: (1 - churn)^12 = 88.6%
#
# B. Blended NRR of a business signing one account a month, by company age
#    company age  2 years: blended NRR 134.6%
#    company age  3 years: blended NRR 125.6%
#    company age  5 years: blended NRR 112.0%
#    company age  7 years: blended NRR 104.8%
#    company age 10 years: blended NRR 100.2%
#
# Reading: expansion is front-loaded, so each cohort's NRR falls toward the
# survival rate as accounts fill their ceilings, and a company's blended NRR
# falls as its base ages - with no change in the product or the team.

Section A follows one cohort. Its NRR is 144.1 % in its first year, 127.5 % in the second, falls below 100 % in year 5 (95.7 %) and approaches the survival rate, 88.6 %. Expansion is front-loaded; churn is not.

Section B follows a business that signs the same number of accounts every month. Its blended NRR is 134.6 % at age two, 112.0 % at five and 100.2 % at ten — with no change in the product, the price or the team. The base simply ages. A falling NRR in a maturing company is therefore not, by itself, evidence that something has gone wrong; and a young company’s 130 % NRR is not evidence that it will keep compounding.

Note

What this means for valuation. Extrapolating a young company’s NRR — in the ODE above, plugging a constant e>ce > c into a long horizon — assumes the exponential branch for ever. The fifth program shows the default path is the opposite: blended NRR decays toward the survival rate as the base ages, so the business crosses back to the saturating branch unless it keeps finding new room to expand (new products, new seats, price increases).

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s hypothesis (not established): among subscription companies that disclose NRR over several years, blended NRR declines with the revenue-weighted average age of the customer base, after controlling for price increases and new product launches. What would show it to be wrong: no relation, or NRR rising with base age.

Summary

With constant acquisition, recurring revenue follows dR/dt=A+(e−c)RdR/dt = A + (e – c)R: below 100 % NRR it saturates at A/(c−e)A/(c – e), at 100 % it grows linearly, and above 100 % the installed base compounds — a bifurcation at e=ce = c. But expansion is bounded, so each cohort’s NRR falls toward its survival rate (from 144.1 % in year one to below 100 % in year five in the example), and a company’s blended NRR falls as its base ages (134.6 % at two years to 100.2 % at ten) without any change in the business. High NRR is a phase of a company’s life, not a constant to extrapolate.

Fan, Y. (2026). Subscription Unit Economics, Net Revenue Retention and AI Inference Scaling Laws: Cohort Survival Mixtures, Negative-Churn Differential Equations, Token Compute Margins and Metcalfe Congestion Limits [订阅制单位经济学、净收入留存与人工智能推理标度律] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090164 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).