5D Library › 内感受解离、突显网络切换与内脏自主神经修复 · English

第一章 内感受与精度加权:第一个环节就反了

内感受的通路

「内感受」指对身体内部状态的感知:心跳、呼吸、胃肠的蠕动、膀胱的充盈、血管的搏动、组织的化学环境。

证据

解剖与生理(综述)。 内脏与组织的小径传入纤维(Aδ 与 C 类)经脊髓的背角进入,在板层 I 换元,经脊髓丘脑束上行到丘脑后腹核的小细胞部,再投射到背后岛叶皮质;Craig 把这条通路描述为灵长类特有的、支持「身体状态的皮质表征」的系统 (Craig 2002, 2009)。另有迷走传入经孤束核、臂旁核上行。岛叶自后向前存在表征的再表征梯度,前岛叶与前扣带一起参与情绪与身体状态的整合 (Craig 2009; Critchley and Harrison 2013)。Critchley 等人发现,心跳觉察的个体差异与右前岛叶的灰质体积及其对心跳的反应相关 (Critchley et al. 2004)。

需要分清的是:以上是解剖通路与相关性的证据。它说明身体状态有皮质表征,不说明「调节表征即可调节身体」。

注

不要把岛叶当成开关。 岛叶参与几乎所有涉及身体状态、风险、疼痛与情绪的任务,Uddin 对此有综述 (Uddin 2015)。一个在许多任务中都激活的脑区,不能用来证明某个特定的因果故事;这是反向推理的标准问题,第 33 本第二章讨论过。

把内感受写成推断

近十五年来,内感受越来越多地被写成推断:大脑并不直接读出身体状态,而是维持一个关于身体状态的生成模型,用预测误差去更新它。Barrett 与 Simmons 把这一思路称为内感受预测 (Barrett and Simmons 2015),Seth 与 Friston 把它放进主动推断的框架 (Seth and Friston 2016),Petzschner 等人把它用于「计算身心医学」(Petzschner et al. 2017)。其数学基础是预测编码 (Rao and Ballard 1999) 与自由能原理 (Friston 2010);注意在这一框架里被写成精度的调节 (Feldman and Friston 2010)。第 15 本整本书讨论这一框架,这里只取它最简单的形式。

最简单的形式是两个高斯源的组合。设身体状态为 xx,先验为 𝒩(μ0,π0−1)\mathcal{N}(\mu_0, \pi_0^{-1}),内感受样本为 yy、其精度为 πy\pi_y(精度 = 方差的倒数)。后验是

π1=π0+πy,μ1=π0μ0+πyyπ0+πy.\pi_1 = \pi_0 + \pi_y, \qquad \mu_1 = \frac{\pi_0 \mu_0 + \pi_y\, y}{\pi_0 + \pi_y}.

这两个式子是本章的全部数学,而第一个结果就从它们直接读出来。原说法要求「下调内感受通道的精度」,也就是减小 πy\pi_y。看 μ1\mu_1 的式子:减小 πy\pi_y 把 μ1\mu_1 推向 μ0\mu_0。后验移向先验。 若先验温和(μ0\mu_0 接近基准),后验估计下降,紧张减轻;若先验本身是警觉的(μ0\mu_0 大于当前的身体信号),后验估计上升。

推导

# Chapter 1. Interoceptive inference as precision-weighted cue combination.
# Two Gaussian sources, a prior (expected bodily state) and an interoceptive
# signal, combine into a posterior whose precision is the sum of the two
# precisions:
#   pi_post = pi_prior + pi_sense,  mu_post = (pi_prior mu_prior + pi_sense y)
#   / pi_post.
# "Turning down the precision of the interoceptive channel" therefore moves
# the posterior TOWARD THE PRIOR and shrinks posterior variance less; it does
# not by itself make the posterior benign. This is the dark-room objection in
# one line: if the prior is itself alarming, lowering sensory precision makes
# the estimate MORE alarming, not less. All numbers are dimensionless
# illustrative units.
import math

def combine(mu_prior, pi_prior, y, pi_sense):
    pi_post = pi_prior + pi_sense
    mu_post = (pi_prior * mu_prior + pi_sense * y) / pi_post
    return mu_post, pi_post

def kl_gauss(m1, p1, m0, p0):
    """KL( N(m1,1/p1) || N(m0,1/p0) ) in nats."""
    return 0.5 * (math.log(p1 / p0) + p0 / p1 + p0 * (m1 - m0) ** 2 - 1.0)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    # an interoceptive signal 2 units from the benign set point
    Y = 2.0
    print("A. benign prior (mu_prior = 0): lowering sensory precision helps")
    print("   pi_sense   mu_post   sd_post   |mu_post| vs signal")
    for pi_s in (4.0, 2.0, 1.0, 0.5, 0.25):
        m, p = combine(0.0, 1.0, Y, pi_s)
        print("   {:8.2f} {:9.3f} {:9.3f}   {:5.0f}% of the signal"
              .format(pi_s, m, 1 / math.sqrt(p), 100 * m / Y))

    print(
        "\nB. alarmed prior (mu_prior = 3): the SAME move makes the estimate"
        " worse"
    )
    print("   pi_sense   mu_post   sd_post   |mu_post| vs signal")
    for pi_s in (4.0, 2.0, 1.0, 0.5, 0.25):
        m, p = combine(3.0, 1.0, Y, pi_s)
        print("   {:8.2f} {:9.3f} {:9.3f}   {:5.0f}% of the signal"
              .format(pi_s, m, 1 / math.sqrt(p), 100 * m / Y))

    print("\nC. what has to change for the posterior to come down:")
    base_m, base_p = combine(3.0, 1.0, Y, 2.0)
    print(
        "   baseline (alarmed prior, pi_sense 2): mu_post = {:.3f}".format(
            base_m
        )
    )
    for lab, args in (
        ("halve sensory precision", (3.0, 1.0, Y, 1.0)),
        ("halve PRIOR precision", (3.0, 0.5, Y, 2.0)),
        ("move the prior to 0", (0.0, 1.0, Y, 2.0)),
        ("move prior to 0 AND halve its precision", (0.0, 0.5, Y, 2.0)),
    ):
        m, p = combine(*args)
        print(
            "   {:42s} mu_post = {:+.3f}  ({:+.3f})".format(
                lab, m, m - base_m
            )
        )

    print(
        "\nD. cost of the shift, KL from the alarmed to the revised posterior"
        " (nats):"
    )
    for lab, args in (("halve sensory precision", (3.0, 1.0, Y, 1.0)),
                      ("move the prior to 0", (0.0, 1.0, Y, 2.0))):
        m, p = combine(*args)
        print("   {:42s} {:.4f}".format(lab, kl_gauss(m, p, base_m, base_p)))
# A. benign prior (mu_prior = 0): lowering sensory precision helps
#    pi_sense   mu_post   sd_post   |mu_post| vs signal
#        4.00     1.600     0.447      80% of the signal
#        2.00     1.333     0.577      67% of the signal
#        1.00     1.000     0.707      50% of the signal
#        0.50     0.667     0.816      33% of the signal
#        0.25     0.400     0.894      20% of the signal
#
# B. alarmed prior (mu_prior = 3): the SAME move makes the estimate worse
#    pi_sense   mu_post   sd_post   |mu_post| vs signal
#        4.00     2.200     0.447     110% of the signal
#        2.00     2.333     0.577     117% of the signal
#        1.00     2.500     0.707     125% of the signal
#        0.50     2.667     0.816     133% of the signal
#        0.25     2.800     0.894     140% of the signal
#
# C. what has to change for the posterior to come down:
#    baseline (alarmed prior, pi_sense 2): mu_post = 2.333
#    halve sensory precision                    mu_post = +2.500  (+0.167)
#    halve PRIOR precision                      mu_post = +2.200  (-0.133)
#    move the prior to 0                        mu_post = +1.333  (-1.000)
#    move prior to 0 AND halve its precision    mu_post = +1.600  (-0.733)
#
# D. cost of the shift, KL from the alarmed to the revised posterior (nats):
#    halve sensory precision                    0.0889
#    move the prior to 0                        1.5000

A 段是原说法成立的情形:先验为 0,把感觉精度从 4.0 降到 0.25,后验从信号的 80% 降到 20%。B 段是同一操作在警觉先验(μ0=3.0\mu_0 = 3.0)下的结果:后验从信号的 110% 升到 140%,也就是从 2.200 升到 2.800。C 段把四种干预并排:下调感觉精度使后验上升 0.167;移动先验到 0 使后验下降 1.000。D 段给出两种移动在后验分布之间的 KL 距离:0.0889 对 1.5000,相差近 17 倍。

后验均值随内感受通道精度 \pi_y 的变化。左:温和先验(\mu_0 = 0,点线)时,降低精度使后验(实线)从信号值(金色虚线)向下移动。右:警觉先验(\mu_0 = 3)时,同一操作使后验向上移动。箭头标出降低精度时后验移动的方向。

这就是自由能框架里著名的「暗室」问题:如果目标只是减少预测误差,那么最优策略是躲进一个什么都不会发生的黑屋子 (Friston, Thornton, and Clark 2012)。Friston、Thornton 与 Clark 的回应是,先验本身包含了对多样化感觉输入的期望,所以暗室并非真正的自由能最小点。但这个回应恰恰说明了本章的要点:决定结果的是先验,不是感觉精度的大小。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的假说(尚未确立): 把注意力放到身体内部而不解释它,其有效成分不是降低内感受通道的精度,而是降低先验本身的警觉程度;在先验仍然警觉时,同样的练习会使主观的身体威胁估计升高,并表现为练习早期症状加重。什么样的结果能证明它是错的: 在事先登记的试验中,按基线的「身体威胁先验」分层(例如以身体警觉量表或焦虑敏感度分层),若练习在高警觉层与低警觉层中产生方向相同、大小相近的改善,则本假说错。

两层模型:解离的是什么

上面的两个式子是静态的。原说法里还有一个动态的成分:「高阶觉知安抚默认模式网络」,也就是让关于身体的估计不再驱动关于处境的估计。把这写成两层的预测编码环路:第一层保持身体状态估计 x1x_1,第二层保持处境估计 x2x_2(「这件事危险吗」),而一个标量 πh\pi_h 缩放整条第二层通路。

dx1dt=k(π1(y−x1)−πhπ2(x1−x2)),dx2dt=kπhπ2(x1−x2)−λx2.\frac{dx_1}{dt} = k\big(\pi_1 (y – x_1) – \pi_h \pi_2 (x_1 – x_2)\big), \qquad \frac{dx_2}{dt} = k\,\pi_h \pi_2 (x_1 – x_2) – \lambda x_2 .

推导

# Chapter 1. A two-level predictive-coding loop with an explicit higher-order
# precision term, integrated with the Euler method (dt = 0.001, 20 s). Level 1
# holds a bodily state estimate x1 driven by an interoceptive sample y; level
# 2 holds a context estimate x2 ("is this situation dangerous?").
# Precision-weighted errors:
#   e1 = y - x1,            e2 = x1 - x2
#   dx1/dt = k (pi_1 e1 - pi_2 e2),   dx2/dt = k pi_2 e2 - lambda x2
# pi_h scales the WHOLE second-level pathway (pi_2 -> pi_h pi_2): this is the
# one knob the author's framework calls "higher-order awareness". The run
# shows what it does to the steady state and to the time constant. Author's
# model; illustrative dimensionless units.
import math

DT, T = 0.001, 20.0

def run(pi1, pi2, pi_h, y=2.0, k=4.0, lam=0.25):
    x1 = x2 = 0.0
    peak_rate = 0.0
    t_half, target = None, None
    traj = []
    n = int(T / DT)
    for i in range(n):
        e1, e2 = y - x1, x1 - x2
        d1 = k * (pi1 * e1 - pi_h * pi2 * e2)
        d2 = k * pi_h * pi2 * e2 - lam * x2
        x1 += DT * d1
        x2 += DT * d2
        peak_rate = max(peak_rate, abs(d2))
        traj.append((i * DT, x1, x2))
    # steady state from the last 1 s
    tail = traj[-int(1.0 / DT):]
    ss1 = math.fsum(r[1] for r in tail) / len(tail)
    ss2 = math.fsum(r[2] for r in tail) / len(tail)
    # time for x2 to reach 63 % of its steady state
    if abs(ss2) > 1e-9:
        target = 0.632 * ss2
        for t, _, v in traj:
            if (v >= target) if ss2 > 0 else (v <= target):
                t_half = t
                break
    return ss1, ss2, t_half, peak_rate, traj

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("pi_h   x1*      x2*     tau63(s)   peak |dx2/dt|")
    for pi_h in (2.0, 1.0, 0.5, 0.25, 0.1, 0.0):
        s1, s2, th, pk, _ = run(1.0, 1.0, pi_h)
        ts = "{:8.3f}".format(th) if th is not None else "       -"
        print(
            "{:4.2f} {:7.3f} {:8.3f} {} {:14.3f}".format(pi_h, s1, s2, ts, pk)
        )

    print(
        "\nThe second level is what carries the interoceptive signal into a"
        " context"
    )
    print(
        "estimate. Lowering pi_h lowers x2* and slows the approach; at pi_h ="
        " 0 the"
    )
    print(
        "second level is cut off and x2* = 0, while x1* tracks the body"
        " unchanged."
    )

    print(
        "\nSensitivity of x2* to the interoceptive sample y (pi_h = 1 vs"
        " 0.25):"
    )
    print("   y      x2*(pi_h=1)   x2*(pi_h=0.25)   ratio")
    for y in (0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0):
        _, a, _, _, _ = run(1.0, 1.0, 1.0, y=y)
        _, b, _, _, _ = run(1.0, 1.0, 0.25, y=y)
        print(
            "   {:4.1f} {:13.3f} {:16.3f} {:7.2f}".format(
                y, a, b, b / a if a else float("nan")
            )
        )

    print(
        "\nNOTE: x1* is unchanged by pi_h in this model, so 'decoupling' here"
    )
    print(
        "means the context estimate stops tracking the body, NOT that the"
        " body"
    )
    print("signal goes away.")
# pi_h   x1*      x2*     tau63(s)   peak |dx2/dt|
# 2.00   1.886    1.829    0.580          2.689
# 1.00   1.889    1.778    0.688          2.139
# 0.50   1.895    1.684    0.883          1.558
# 0.25   1.905    1.524    1.209          1.033
# 0.10   1.926    1.185    1.886          0.526
# 0.00   2.000    0.000        -          0.000
#
# The second level is what carries the interoceptive signal into a context
# estimate. Lowering pi_h lowers x2* and slows the approach; at pi_h = 0 the
# second level is cut off and x2* = 0, while x1* tracks the body unchanged.
#
# Sensitivity of x2* to the interoceptive sample y (pi_h = 1 vs 0.25):
#    y      x2*(pi_h=1)   x2*(pi_h=0.25)   ratio
#     0.5         0.444            0.381    0.86
#     1.0         0.889            0.762    0.86
#     2.0         1.778            1.524    0.86
#     4.0         3.556            3.048    0.86
#
# NOTE: x1* is unchanged by pi_h in this model, so 'decoupling' here
# means the context estimate stops tracking the body, NOT that the body
# signal goes away.

结果有三点值得记下。第一,πh\pi_h 下降时,处境估计的稳态 x2*x_2^* 从 1.778 降到 1.185(πh=0.1\pi_h = 0.1),到 πh=0\pi_h = 0 时为 0;而身体估计 x1*x_1^* 几乎不变(1.889 到 2.000)。所以在这个模型里,「解离」的意思是处境估计不再跟踪身体,不是身体信号消失了。练习不会让心跳变得感觉不到;它让心跳不再被读成「有危险」。这与第三章要讨论的「无评判」是同一件事的两种写法。

第二,πh\pi_h 下降时达到稳态的时间常数变长(0.688 秒到 1.886 秒)。也就是说,这个模型中的处境估计不但更低,也更迟钝。迟钝对无害的身体事件是好事,对真实的危险则不是;这一点在第三章用信号检测模型精确化。

第三,x2*x_2^* 对身体信号 yy 的敏感度在 πh\pi_h 的两个取值下成固定比例(表中四行的比值都是 0.86)。这是因为模型在 yy 上是线性的。真实系统不会如此,但这说明一件事:在线性模型里,「降低高阶精度」是一个增益操作,而不是一个阈值操作;它等比例地缩小所有的处境反应,不区分该缩小的和不该缩小的。

注

πh\pi_h 不是一个已知的生理量。 本书把 πh\pi_h 当作模型参数,不声称它对应某个可测的神经信号。把精度加权等同于某条特定的神经机制(例如某个频段的功率或某条通路的增益)需要独立证据,而第 8 本第三章已指出这类等同在熵脑文献中常被过早作出。

内感受的测量:一个必须先解决的问题

如果要检验任何关于内感受的说法,就得先能测量它。这里有一个方法学的坑。

证据

心跳计数任务的问题。 长期以来,「内感受准确度」常用心跳计数任务测量:请被试在不摸脉搏的情况下数出一段时间内的心跳数,与实际心跳数比较。Zamariola 等人指出这一得分存在根本问题:它与实际心率强相关,低估心跳数的人得分反而可能更高,而简单的双变量相关就能显示这些混淆 (Zamariola et al. 2018)。Garfinkel 等人较早就区分了三个层次:内感受准确度(客观成绩)、内感受敏感度(自评倾向)与内感受觉察(元认知,即成绩与信心的对应)(Garfinkel et al. 2015),三者相关很弱。Mehling 等人的多维内感受觉察量表(MAIA)测的是自评的注意方式,包括「不担忧」「不分心」等分量表 (Mehling et al. 2012),与客观成绩是不同的构念。

这对第八章有直接后果:本书的试验不以心跳计数作为任何结局。原说法关心的是人与身体信号的关系,而这恰好是自评量表测的东西,不是心跳计数测的东西。把自评与客观成绩混为一谈,会得到无法解释的结果:一项练习可能提高「我注意身体的方式更从容」的自评分数,同时完全不改变数心跳的成绩,而这两件事都不等于「内感受变准了」。

证据

内感受与精神健康(综述)。 Paulus 与 Stein 提出,焦虑与抑郁中的内感受异常可以写成「身体预测信号的放大」(Paulus and Stein 2010)。Khalsa 等人的路线图文件综述了这一领域,并明确列出了测量与定义上的分歧 (Khalsa et al. 2018)。这是一个活跃但方法学尚未统一的领域;本书引用它作为问题的来源,不作为结论的依据。

本章小结

内感受有明确的解剖通路,把它写成精度加权的推断是一个有生产力的框架。但该框架的第一个式子就否证了原说法的第一个环节:下调内感受通道的精度把后验推向先验,所以只有先验温和时才使身体威胁的估计下降;先验警觉时它使估计上升(程序 p01:从 2.333 升到 2.800)。要让估计下降,必须移动先验,而这与「不作解释」不是同一个操作,其在分布上的代价也大约 17 倍。两层模型说明,「解离」的内容是处境估计不再跟踪身体估计,而不是身体信号消失,并且它同时使处境估计变得更迟钝(时间常数从 0.688 秒到 1.886 秒)。最后,内感受的测量本身存在未解决的问题:心跳计数任务的得分不能当作内感受准确度,自评量表与客观成绩是不同的构念,第八章据此选择结局。

参考文献

Barrett, Lisa Feldman, and W. Kyle Simmons. 2015. “Interoceptive Predictions in the Brain.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 16: 419–29. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn3950.
Craig, A. D. 2002. “How Do You Feel? Interoception: The Sense of the Physiological Condition of the Body.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 3: 655–66. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn894.
———. 2009. “How Do You Feel — Now? The Anterior Insula and Human Awareness.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 10: 59–70. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2555.
Critchley, Hugo D., and Neil A. Harrison. 2013. “Visceral Influences on Brain and Behavior.” Neuron 77 (4): 624–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2013.02.008.
Critchley, Hugo D., Stefan Wiens, Pia Rotshtein, Arne Öhman, and Raymond J. Dolan. 2004. “Neural Systems Supporting Interoceptive Awareness.” Nature Neuroscience 7: 189–95. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn1176.
Feldman, Harriet, and Karl J. Friston. 2010. “Attention, Uncertainty, and Free-Energy.” Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 4: 215. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2010.00215.
Friston, Karl. 2010. “The Free-Energy Principle: A Unified Brain Theory?” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11: 127–38. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2787.
Friston, Karl, Christopher Thornton, and Andy Clark. 2012. “Free-Energy Minimization and the Dark-Room Problem.” Frontiers in Psychology 3: 130. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00130.
Garfinkel, Sarah N., Anil K. Seth, Adam B. Barrett, Keisuke Suzuki, and Hugo D. Critchley. 2015. “Knowing Your Own Heart: Distinguishing Interoceptive Accuracy from Interoceptive Awareness.” Biological Psychology 104: 65–74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2014.11.004.
Khalsa, Sahib S., Ralph Adolphs, Oliver G. Cameron, Hugo D. Critchley, Paul W. Davenport, Justin S. Feinstein, Jamie D. Feusner, et al. 2018. “Interoception and Mental Health: A Roadmap.” Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging 3 (6): 501–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpsc.2017.12.004.
Mehling, Wolf E., Cynthia Price, Jennifer J. Daubenmier, Mike Acree, Elizabeth Bartmess, and Anita Stewart. 2012. “The Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness (MAIA).” PLOS ONE 7 (11): e48230. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0048230.
Paulus, Martin P., and Murray B. Stein. 2010. “Interoception in Anxiety and Depression.” Brain Structure and Function 214: 451–63. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00429-010-0258-9.
Petzschner, Frederike H., Lilian A. E. Weber, Tim Gard, and Klaas E. Stephan. 2017. “Computational Psychosomatics and Computational Psychiatry: Toward a Joint Framework for Differential Diagnosis.” Biological Psychiatry 82 (6): 421–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsych.2017.05.012.
Rao, Rajesh P. N., and Dana H. Ballard. 1999. “Predictive Coding in the Visual Cortex: A Functional Interpretation of Some Extra-Classical Receptive-Field Effects.” Nature Neuroscience 2: 79–87. https://doi.org/10.1038/4580.
Seth, Anil K., and Karl J. Friston. 2016. “Active Interoceptive Inference and the Emotional Brain.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 371 (1708): 20160007. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2016.0007.
Uddin, Lucina Q. 2015. “Salience Processing and Insular Cortical Function and Dysfunction.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 16: 55–61. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn3857.
Zamariola, Giorgia, Pierre Maurage, Olivier Luminet, and Olivier Corneille. 2018. “Interoceptive Accuracy Scores from the Heartbeat Counting Task Are Problematic: Evidence from Simple Bivariate Correlations.” Biological Psychology 137: 12–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2018.06.006.

Fan, Y. (2026). Interoceptive Decoupling, Salience-Network Switching and Autonomic Visceral Restoration: From Precision-Weighting in the Default Mode Network and the Redistribution of Vagal Tone to the Neurophenomenology of a Non-Judgmental Imagery Stream, with a Textual Examination of neiguan in the Huangdi Neijing [内感受解离、突显网络切换与内脏自主神经修复] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020418 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).