5D Library › Architectural Acoustics, Reverberation Time and the Environmental Psychology of Built Space · 中文
Chapter 2 Standing Waves, Room Modes and Low-Frequency Noise
Where reverberation theory fails
The formulas of Sabine and Eyring in Chapter 1 both assume a “diffuse” sound field, in which many waves of similar frequency travelling in all directions coexist and their energy mixes evenly. At middle and high frequencies, and in larger rooms, this assumption roughly holds. At low frequencies in a small room, however, the room can sustain only a few stable patterns of vibration, its normal modes (room modes). Each mode is a standing wave formed by waves reflected back and forth between walls and adding together, with places of very high pressure (antinodes) and places of almost none (nodes). The low-frequency response of the room then depends on the particular frequency and position, and no longer on a single reverberation time.
Derivation: normal frequencies of a rectangular room
Calculation
For a rectangular room with rigid walls (length , width , height ), the sound pressure satisfies the wave equation with zero normal particle velocity at the boundaries. Separating variables, the solutions that satisfy the boundary conditions are
with normal frequencies
Modes with one non-zero index are axial (between one pair of parallel walls), those with two are tangential and those with three are oblique. The number of modes below frequency is approximately
where is the total surface area and the total edge length (Kuttruff 2009). The count grows as : sparse at low frequencies, dense at high ones.
When two or more modes fall at exactly the same frequency they are called degenerate. If the length, width and height are in simple integer ratios, many different combinations give the same frequency, so modes “pile up” at a few frequencies and leave large gaps between them. Bolt discussed room proportions in 1946 in terms of the statistics of mode spacing (Bolt 1946); in 1981 Bonello proposed a widely used criterion: counting modes in third-octave bands, the number per band should never decrease with frequency (Bonello 1981).
The program below compares three rooms of equal volume (about 46.7 m³, a large study or a small meditation hall): a 3.6 m cube, a 1:2:2 room and the often recommended 1:1.4:1.9.
Calculation
# Rectangular-room modes f = (c/2) sqrt((nx/L)^2 + (ny/W)^2 + (nz/H)^2) for three rooms
# of equal volume (about 46.7 m3); degeneracy, gaps, Bonello's third-octave counts,
# Schroeder frequency.
import math, itertools
c = 343.0
ROOMS = {"cube 3.60 m": (3.60, 3.60, 3.60), "1:2:2": (4.54, 4.54, 2.27),
"1:1.4:1.9": (4.94, 3.64, 2.60)}
def modes(L, W, H, fmax):
out = []
for n in itertools.product(range(12), repeat=3):
f = c / 2 * math.sqrt((n[0] / L) ** 2 + (n[1] / W) ** 2 + (n[2] / H) ** 2)
if 0 < f <= fmax:
out.append((f, ("axial", "tangential", "oblique")[sum(k > 0 for k in n) - 1]))
return sorted(out)
def weyl(L, W, H, f): # expected number of modes below f (Weyl / Maa formula)
V, S, E = L * W * H, 2 * (L * W + L * H + W * H), 4 * (L + W + H)
return 4 * math.pi * V * f ** 3 / (3 * c ** 3) + math.pi * S * f ** 2 / (4 * c ** 2) \
+ E * f / (8 * c)
THIRDS = [20 * 2 ** (k / 3) for k in range(11)] # third-octave edges 20 ... 200 Hz
for name, (L, W, H) in ROOMS.items():
m = modes(L, W, H, 200.0)
fs = [f for f, _ in m]
distinct = sorted(set(round(f, 1) for f in fs))
low = [f for f in distinct if f <= 120]
gaps = [b - a for a, b in zip(low, low[1:])]
kinds = {k: sum(x == k for _, x in m) for k in ("axial", "tangential", "oblique")}
counts = [sum(1 for f in fs if a <= f < b) for a, b in zip(THIRDS, THIRDS[1:])]
print(f"{name:10s} {L:.2f} x {W:.2f} x {H:.2f} m, V = {L * W * H:.1f} m3")
print(f" modes <= 200 Hz: {len(m)} ({kinds['axial']} axial, {kinds['tangential']}"
f" tangential, {kinds['oblique']} oblique); Weyl {weyl(L, W, H, 200):.0f}")
print(f" distinct frequencies: {len(distinct)}; lowest {distinct[0]:.1f} Hz;"
f" largest gap below 120 Hz {max(gaps):.1f} Hz")
print(" modes per third-octave 20-200 Hz: " + " ".join(f"{n:2d}" for n in counts)
+ (" (never decreasing)" if all(b >= a for a, b in zip(counts, counts[1:]))
else " (decreases)"))
for T in (0.4, 0.8):
print(f"Schroeder frequency 2000 sqrt(T/V) for V = 46.7 m3, T = {T} s:"
f" {2000 * math.sqrt(T / 46.7):.0f} Hz")
# cube 3.60 m 3.60 x 3.60 x 3.60 m, V = 46.7 m3
# modes <= 200 Hz: 62 (12 axial, 30 tangential, 20 oblique); Weyl 63
# distinct frequencies: 15; lowest 47.6 Hz; largest gap below 120 Hz 19.8 Hz
# modes per third-octave 20-200 Hz: 0 0 0 3 0 3 4 9 18 25 (decreases)
# 1:2:2 4.54 x 4.54 x 2.27 m, V = 46.8 m3
# modes <= 200 Hz: 62 (12 axial, 31 tangential, 19 oblique); Weyl 64
# distinct frequencies: 20; lowest 37.8 Hz; largest gap below 120 Hz 22.2 Hz
# modes per third-octave 20-200 Hz: 0 0 2 0 1 3 5 9 16 26 (decreases)
# 1:1.4:1.9 4.94 x 3.64 x 2.60 m, V = 46.8 m3
# modes <= 200 Hz: 63 (12 axial, 31 tangential, 20 oblique); Weyl 64
# distinct frequencies: 62; lowest 34.7 Hz; largest gap below 120 Hz 12.4 Hz
# modes per third-octave 20-200 Hz: 0 0 1 1 1 3 6 7 18 26 (never decreasing)
# Schroeder frequency 2000 sqrt(T/V) for V = 46.7 m3, T = 0.4 s: 185 Hz
# Schroeder frequency 2000 sqrt(T/V) for V = 46.7 m3, T = 0.8 s: 262 HzThe three rooms have almost the same number of modes below 200 Hz (62–63, in line with the approximation’s 63–64); the difference lies entirely in their distribution. The cube’s 62 modes fall on only 15 distinct frequencies; at 47.6 Hz, for example, three axial modes coincide. The 1:2:2 room has only 20 distinct frequencies; the 1:1.4:1.9 room’s 63 modes fall on 62. The largest gap between neighbouring modes below 120 Hz is 19.8 Hz for the cube, 22.2 Hz for 1:2:2 and only 12.4 Hz for 1:1.4:1.9, and only the last satisfies Bonello’s “never decreasing” criterion. In this sense the author’s statement that “a cubic room produces severe degeneracy and piling-up of low-frequency modes” is correct.
The Schroeder frequency
When are modes dense enough for the field to be treated as diffuse? Schroeder’s answer was: when, on average, about three other modes overlap within the resonance bandwidth of each mode. The half-power bandwidth of a mode is about Hz; using the modal density and setting their product equal to 3 gives
The last two lines of the program give, for a 46.7 m³ room, Hz at a reverberation time of 0.4 s and about 262 Hz at 0.8 s. Below this frequency neither the reverberation formulas of Chapter 1 nor “clapping and listening to the tail” can be trusted; low-frequency boom is a problem of individual modes and has to be analysed frequency by frequency and position by position.
What is heard at a seat
Degeneracy stands out on the frequency axis, but a person sitting at one place hears the sum of all modes at that point. The next program uses a modal sum to compute the low-frequency response with the source in a corner and the listener at nine different seats, measures the irregularity by the standard deviation of the 50–150 Hz response, and compares two amounts of damping (a reverberation time of 0.8 s, and 0.4 s after adding low-frequency absorption). The model uses the same damping for every mode, a simplification.
Calculation
# Low-frequency response at one seat: modal sum p(w) ~ sum psi(src) psi(rcv) / (L_n
# (wn^2 - w^2 + 2j d w)), d = 6.91 / T for every mode (a simplification). Source near a
# corner; nine seated listening positions. Spread (SD) of the response 50-150 Hz in dB:
# smaller = smoother bass.
import math, itertools
c = 343.0
ROOMS = {"cube 3.60 m": (3.60, 3.60, 3.60), "1:1.4:1.9": (4.94, 3.64, 2.60)}
def mode_list(L, W, H, fmax=400.0): # norm: factor 0.5 per non-zero index
out = []
for nx, ny, nz in itertools.product(range(12), repeat=3):
f = c / 2 * math.sqrt((nx / L) ** 2 + (ny / W) ** 2 + (nz / H) ** 2)
if 0 < f <= fmax:
out.append((f, nx, ny, nz, 0.5 ** ((nx > 0) + (ny > 0) + (nz > 0))))
return out
def response(dims, T, src, rcv, freqs):
L, W, H = dims
d = 6.91 / T
ms = mode_list(L, W, H)
shape = lambda n, x, D: math.cos(n * math.pi * x / D)
psi = lambda nx, ny, nz, r: (shape(nx, r[0], L) * shape(ny, r[1], W)
* shape(nz, r[2], H))
weights = [(2 * math.pi * f, psi(nx, ny, nz, src) * psi(nx, ny, nz, rcv) / norm)
for f, nx, ny, nz, norm in ms]
out = []
for f in freqs:
w = 2 * math.pi * f
p = sum(a / (wn * wn - w * w + 2j * d * w) for wn, a in weights)
out.append(20 * math.log10(abs(p) * w + 1e-12)) # x w: ~ constant-volume source
return out
def spread(db):
m = sum(db) / len(db)
return math.sqrt(sum((x - m) ** 2 for x in db) / len(db))
FREQS = [50 + 0.5 * k for k in range(201)] # 50-150 Hz
SEATS = [(fx, fy) for fx in (0.3, 0.45, 0.6) for fy in (0.3, 0.45, 0.6)]
for name, dims in ROOMS.items():
L, W, H = dims
src = (0.3, 0.3, 0.3)
for T in (0.8, 0.4):
sds = [spread(response(dims, T, src, (fx * L, fy * W, 1.2), FREQS))
for fx, fy in SEATS]
print(f"{name:11s} T = {T} s: SD over 9 seats mean {sum(sds) / 9:4.1f} dB"
f" (best {min(sds):4.1f}, worst {max(sds):4.1f})")
# cube 3.60 m T = 0.8 s: SD over 9 seats mean 7.3 dB (best 5.8, worst 10.3)
# cube 3.60 m T = 0.4 s: SD over 9 seats mean 6.0 dB (best 4.6, worst 9.9)
# 1:1.4:1.9 T = 0.8 s: SD over 9 seats mean 7.6 dB (best 5.7, worst 9.3)
# 1:1.4:1.9 T = 0.4 s: SD over 9 seats mean 6.4 dB (best 4.9, worst 8.9)The result surprises some people: in this simplified model the mean irregularity over nine seats is 7.3 dB for the cube and 7.6 dB for 1:1.4:1.9, almost the same; the difference between the best and worst seat within one room (5.8 versus 10.3 dB for the cube) is far larger than the difference between the two proportions; and lowering the reverberation time from 0.8 to 0.4 s reduces the irregularity in both rooms by about 1.2–1.3 dB. Figure 2 (right) shows that the cube’s problem is not that it is “worse everywhere”, but that its peaks are concentrated at a few frequencies with deeper and wider gaps between modes.
Note
Qualification of the author’s framework. Room proportions do determine how modes are distributed in frequency, but at a single seat the positions of listener and source and the low-frequency damping matter at least as much. Cox, D’Antonio and Avis argued in 2004 for optimising room dimensions together with loudspeaker and listener positions, allowing for construction tolerances (Cox et al. 2004). For a study or meditation hall that has already been built, moving the seat and adding low-frequency absorption in the corners is usually far more practical than changing the room’s proportions.
Chapter summary
The normal frequencies of a rectangular room are given by , and the number of modes grows as . At equal volume, a cube’s 62 modes below 200 Hz fall on only 15 frequencies, whereas a 1:1.4:1.9 room has almost no coincidences; the Schroeder frequency marks the boundary between the modal and diffuse regions (about 185–262 Hz for the example room). At a single seat, though, listener position and low-frequency damping matter at least as much as proportions. A-weighting hides low-frequency noise: two ventilation noises at the same 40 dB(A) can differ by 13 dB in C − A. The 2002 experiment by Persson Waye and colleagues suggests that low-frequency noise may affect the cortisol rhythm of highly sensitive people, but the evidence is limited. The next chapter discusses a property of sound that matters more than decibels: the voices in the background.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Architectural Acoustics, Reverberation Time and the Environmental Psychology of Built Space: From Sabine's Equation and Fractal Visual Dimensions to Cognitive Performance, Read Beside Classical Chinese Spatial Design [建筑声学、混响时间与空间环境心理学的物理模型] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23782090 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).